Cast
-
Vera Farminga
-
Peter Sarsgaard
-
Isabelle Fuhrman
-
-
Jimmy Bennett
-
Aryana Engineer
-
Lorry Ayers
-
Margo Martindale
-
Rosemary Dunsmore
-
Matthew Raudsepp
-
Karel Roden
-
Andrew Shaver
Synopsis
Kate and John Coleman, seeking to try to cement their relationship after Kate conquering her alcoholism and a miscarriage, decide to adopt a child, already having two of their own, Max, a young girl who is deaf, and a boy, Daniel, The pair decide to adopt Esther, a Russian nine-year-old, who seems to bond quickly with Max but not so Daniel, who seems to take an instant dislike to her. After a girl who has been bullying her in the playground is found badly injured, Kate starts to realise that Esther has a violent streak, and is possibly actually very dangerous, but John refuses to listen to her protests, causing a rift between them. Investigating her background, Kate receives a visit from Sister Abigail, a nun who worked at the orphanage which Esther came from, who tells her that Esther seems to attract trouble, and strange and often violent events seem to occur wherever she is. As Sister Abigail is driving home, her car veers off the road, Esther having sabotaged it, and she beats the nun to death when she tries to escape the wreckage, forcing Max to help her. Daniel sees them hiding some of the evidence of the killing, but Esther threatens both of them into keeping silent over what has happened, but suspecting Daniel may go to his parents, she locks him in the treehouse in the garden and sets it alight. He is saved and taken to hospital, badly burned, where Esther tries to kill him once more, suffocating him, but Kate discovers her in the act and hits her, but this causes her to be heavily sedated and admitted to the hospital. Esther returns home, where an already confused John is shocked when he finds that Esther tries to seduce him, but a call Kate receives in the hospital suddenly makes her realise who Esther really is, and that everybody is in very real danger.
Production
- Director
- Jaume Collet-Serra
- Producer
- Leonardo DiCaprio, Susan Downey, Jennifer Davisson Killoran and Joel Silver
- Art Director
- Micele Laliberte and Pierre Perrault
- Editor
- Tim Alverson
- Music
- John Ottman
- Screenplay
- David Leslie Johnson, based on a story by Alex Mace
- Director of Photography
- Jeff Cutter
Review
Another of Dark Castle Entertainment's original productions, rather than being a remake such as Thirteen Ghosts or House On Haunted Hill, Orphan has a Dark Castle remake director at the helm, Jaume Collett-Serra (House Of Wax), for a chiller which revolves around a simply outrageous twist, but despite some of the extreme plot contrivances, manages to entertain extremely well for a two hour running time, but director Collett-Serra and scriptwriter David Leslie Johnson turn a familiar theme, the idea of an evil child running through films as diverse as The Bad Seed to The Omen, into an effective piece of work as long as one doesn't take it quite as solemnly as one suspects it was originally conceived. The leads are Peter Sarsgaard (Shattered Glass) and Vera Farminga (The Boy In the Striped Pyjamas) as parents John and Kate Coleman, who decide to adopt a child to join their young son and daughter, after suffering a miscarriage, and the child they eventually take in is Esther (Isabelle Fuhrman - Hounddog) a nine year old Russian girl and, predictably, everything seems to initially go well, but then certain events make the Colemans start to worry about Esther's past, and the deeper they investigate the more concerned they become, as Esther starts to show her true nature, and very uncomfortable it will probably make many people feel. Just how evil Esther is, and why, is why various pressure groups in the US vociferously called for the film to be banned, without seeing it naturally, since they insisted it will demonise adopted children, and dissuade any potential adoptive parents from taking in any orphans, which of course raises the point that anyone who would be put off adoption by merely seeing a movie is very probably not fit to be a parent anyway. The actual plans and schemes Esther comes up with seem terribly sophisticated for a child, and there is a strange underlying subtext in that much is made of Esther's Russian heritage, as if this makes her even more of a threat, and much is made of her strange appearance, her antiquated dresses and dated hairstyle. The script does actually have more subtle aspects, such as Kate seeming to conquer her alcoholism, and it is obviously the relationship has been under strain in the past, mostly, it is hinted, because of John's infidelity but most disquieting of all is a scene near the finale where Esther dons provocative clothes and make-up in an attempt to seduce John when Kate is hospitalised, a scene which is certain to unsettle many and really offend some. Collett-Serra proved he could handle horror material with House Of Wax, and gave the audience what they demanded by giving the hideous Paris Hilton an equally hideous death, and how could anybody resist a film with the excellent CCH Pounder (TV's The Shield) as a nun? Effective and enjoyable, and you'll find a grin inescapably crossing your face when Esther's real past is revealed. That it doesn't totally derail the movie is an achievement in itself.