Film details

Cold Souls  2009

Cast

  • Paul Giamatti
  • Dina Korzun
  • David Straithairn
  • Katheryn Winnick
  • Lauren Ambrose
  • Boris Kievsky
  • Osanna Lada
  • Natalia Zvereva
  • Rebecca Brookaher
  • Fabrizia Del Farra
  • Yevgenly Dekhtyar

Synopsis

Having agreed to take the title role in an upcoming production of Uncle Vanya, New York actor Paul Giamatti is having problems with the depths of the role, having been told that he has to become soulless in order to play Checkov's character, and in the best interests of the production visits a smart and efficient facility run by the equally smart Dr. Flintstein, where his soul is removed and safely stored under secure conditions until he comes to reclaim it. Giamatti does not know that Flintstein also has a sideline, dealing in souls which are brought to him by Nina, a young Russian woman who acts as a 'mule' for the soul trade, the Doctor offering them to select clients who may want them. Giamatti finds his soullessness initially emboldening, but then finds that he cannot deliver a decent performance as Vanya, and his relationship with his wife, Claire, starts to suffer terribly as they seem to be drifting apart, Claire wondering just why her husband has become so distant and cold. Forced to buy a soul, his acting improves considerably after he implants the soul of Olga, a poet. Olga goes to Nina, wanting her soul to be returned, but she tells her that the contract is irreversible and it is gone for good. Sveta, a Russian soap actor, wants to have a famous actor's soul implanted, hoping for someone the calibre of Al Pacino, her husband, Dimitri, Nina's boss, telling her to find something suitable. The only actor's soul Flintstein has in stock is Giamatti's, and Nina implants it into herself in order to transport it to St. Petersburg. Returning to Flintstein in order to claim his soul back, the actor is stunned to find it is gone. Being told about Nina, he travels to Russia and they meet, the pair being strangely in tune with each other due to Nina's harbouring of what Giamatti wants back, but has already gone to Sveta. The pair travel across Russia, Giamatti managing to finally track down Sveta and subjecting her to the extraction process while drugged. Wanting to return Olga's soul to her, Giamatti no longer needing it, they are shocked to find that she has committed suicide, unable to live without her soul, which was so much part of her inspiration. Giamatti returns to the States, to find that Flintstein's facility has been taken over and is in the process of being dismantled and destroyed. He finds Flintstein and asks if Nina, whose own soul was removed in order for her to act as a mule, can have her it restored, but what Flintstein tells him makes him realise what a tragic and tawdry business it is.

Production

Director
Sophie Barthes
Producer
Daniel Carey, Elizabeth Giamatti, Paul S. Mezey, Andrij Parekh and Jeremy Kipp Walker
Art Director
Michael Ahern
Editor
Andrew Mondshein
Music
Dickon Hinchliffe
Screenplay
Sophie Barthes
Director of Photography
Andrij Parekh

Review

Very much borrowing elements from Charlie Kaufman movies, including, a la Being John Malkovich and Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind, having the lead actor essentially play a version of himself, the excellent Paul Giamatti (Sideways / Duplicity) is playing actor Paul Giamatti, in a pic which has some very clever ideas at its' core, and some dependable cast members, but as with so many films which attempt such a mixture of reality and fantasy, is actually reluctant to class itself as science-fiction, instead settling for being an absurdist drama. It is a delicate balancing act to pull off, as director and writer Sophie Barthes, making her feature debut, discovers. The Giamatti in the film, grumpy from the beginning, is about to take the demanding lead in a production of Chekov's Uncle Vanya, but is worried about how to approach such a cold and chill role, so visits one of the new soul storage surgeries, where his soul can be taken out and stored, enabling him to be focused and emotionless enough for the role. He agrees, submitting to the procedure under the bizarre Dr. Flintstein (David Straithairn - Good Night, And Good Luck). But as with any valuable commodity there is a black market, and Giamatti's soul soon falls prey to the illegal traffickers in souls, Giamatti having to track it down, eventually tracing it to St. Petersberg and meeting soul trafficker Nina (the excellent and fittingly soulful Dina Korzun - Forty Shades Of Blue), who has already passed it onto an actress who wants more talent, believing that the implantation of a soul will change her this dramatically, which is perhaps the deepest idea in the film, that it is the soul and not the personality or wealth of experiences that a person has which makes them what they are, and its' a nice self-denegrating joke against Giamatti that she actually wants someone like Al Pacino rather then the crumpled hangdog New York thesp. Based on a dream the writer / director once had, although it was Woody Allen instead of Giamatti who was the victim of the extraction, to use an uncomfortable phrase, there are some very nice ideas, such as Giamatti finding his relationship with his wife (Emily Watson - Synecdoche, New York, another Kaufman connection), failing once his soul is removed, another nice concept, that is the soul which makes us connect with others, but again bathes is unwilling to really follow any of the tantalising philosophical ideas to any real conclusion except towards the end when it is revealed just how damaging the soul trade has been to Nina. Eventually the film becomes one of ideas rather than a really engaging narrative, redeemed by excellent performances, Giamatti being oddly endearing as this aggrieved version of himself, and his 'soulless' performance of Vanya is an excellent parody of some actor's 'serious drama' technique, while Straithairn is a perfectly convincing and charming semi-charlatan as Flintstein, and ends on the nice idea that something as potentially heartless and damaging as soul-smuggling has been superseded by something even more ruthless and manipulative. Cold Souls is certainly rewarding in various odd ways, preferring dry wit and observation to all-out comedy, and it is a delight to see the increasingly demoralised Giamatti try to claim back what he begins to realise he values the most, but Sophie Barthes is certainly a talent behind the camera, with hopefully a more fixed and positive narrative for her next project.