Film details

The Cove  2009

Cast

  • Richard O'Barry
  • Louie Psihoyos
  • Joe Chisholm
  • Mandy-Rae Cruikshank
  • Charles Hambleton
  • Simon Hutchins
  • Kirk Krack
  • Isabel Lucas
  • Dave Rastovich
  • Roger Payne
  • Paul Watson

Synopsis

Already a cause celebre in the green and animal rights movements, Louis Psihoyos' The Cove has been garnering awards in various sympathetic film festivals, and is certainly impassioned, but of course also has its' detractors saying that many of the facts and statistics quoted by Psihoyos and its' central character, Richard 'Ric' O'Barry, are manipulated at best and fictitious at worst. O'Barry himself is certainly an interesting character, being an ex-dolphin trainer who claims to have trained the five dolphins which played the central character in the hugely popular Flipper TV series, which ran from 1964 to 1968, until an apparently Damacean conversion when he had a 360 change of heart and decided that no dolphins should ever be trained or kept in captivity for the amusement of humans ever again. Becoming a campaigner on behalf of the mammals, and protesting against dolphin hunting by Japanese fleets, which harvest them both for food and for specimens to be taken to various sea parks and other such amusement centres around the world. Travelling to Taiji, a town in Japan, which seems to be devoted to dolphins and their observation, with regular tourist boats travelling out to see them O'Barry and Psihoyos claim to find a cove further up the shore where dolphins are hunted and penned, being slaughtered for meat which they claim is often, instead of being healthy, actually high in mercury, and is sold labelled as tuna rather what it actually is, and the scenes of the dolphins being killed in the cove are distressing. But the story doesn't quite end there, with several actually questioning O'Barry's claimed credentials, some believing his involvement with the Flipper TV series was occasional at best, (the dolphins, three instead of the five that he claims, being actually trained by an ex-fisherman called Milton Santini), was in fact, and still is, a bit-part actor rather than any sort of marine expert, and wondering why he often goes under another name, Richard O'Feldman. Other claims raised include the fact that the workings and purpose of the cove have been known for years and that this, like the earlier Sharkbait, doesn't actually tell anything new, just sensationalises it and makes it more camera-friendly by trying to essentially turn it into a thriller, claiming that the makers put themselves in danger by making it. One may also question why Hayden Panettiere (TV's Heroes) may be a spokesperson for dolphins and their conservation, but is also the advertising face of a range of hugely expensive and exclusive leather handbags in the US, and seems to see no hypocrisy or clash of beliefs here, because dolphins are more appealing, or more awareness-raising, than leather? The Cove may have some alarming footage, but with the various questions being raised as to O'Barry's veracity, as well as claims that Japan has stopped hunting dolphins because of Psihoyos' film, a fanciful idea at best, have to make one regard the film with more than a little scepticism.

Production

Director
Louie Psihoyos
Producer
Paula DuPre Pesman and Fisher Stevens
Art Director
Not credited
Editor
Geoffrey Richman
Music
J. Ralph
Screenplay
Mark Monroe
Director of Photography
Brook Aitken

Review

Already a cause celebre in the green and animal rights movements, Louis Psihoyos' The Cove has garnered awards in various sympathetic film festivals, and is certainly impassioned, but of course also has its' detractors saying that many of the facts and statistics quoted by Psihoyos and its' central character, Richard 'Ric' O'Barry, are manipulated at best and fictitious at worst. O'Barry himself is certainly an interesting character, claiming to be an ex-dolphin trainer who trained the five dolphins which played the central character in the hugely popular Flipper TV series, which ran from 1964 to 1968, until an apparently Damacean conversion when he had a 360 degree change of heart and decided that no dolphins should ever be trained or kept in captivity for the amusement of humans ever again, after claiming, with an admirably straight face, that a dolphin committed suicide in front of him. If one accepts this then one will probably swallow everything O'Barry comes out with, some of it of dubious provenance. Becoming a campaigner on behalf of the mammals, and protesting against dolphin hunting by Japanese fleets, which harvest them both for food and for specimens to be taken to various sea parks and other such amusement centres around the world. O'Barry and Psihoyos travel to Taiji, a town in Japan, which seems to be devoted to whales, dolphins and their observation, with regular tourist boats travelling out to see them, O'Barry and Psihoyos claim to find a cove further up the shore when dolphins are hunted and penned, being slaughtered for meat which they claim is often, instead of being healthy, can actually be very high in mercury, and is often sold labelled as tuna rather what it actually is, which is really what the core and focus of the story should be, and the scenes of the dolphins being killed in the cove are distressing. But the story doesn't quite end there, with several actually questioning O'Barry's claimed credentials, some believing his involvement with the Flipper TV series was occasional at best, (the dolphins, three instead of the five that he claims, being actually trained by an ex-fisherman called Milton Santini), O'Barry then being in fact, and still is, a bit-part actor rather than any sort of marine expert, and wondering why he often goes under another name, Richard O'Feldman. Other claims raised include the fact that the workings and purpose of the cove have been known for years and that this, like the earlier Sharkbait, doesn't actually tell anything new, just sensationalises it and makes it more camera-friendly by trying to essentially turn it into a thriller, insisting that the makers put themselves in danger by making it, claiming they are being targeted by everybody from local government officials and private detectives as well as, to make the commercial brew even spicier, the Yakuza, although there is no evidence or any of this. One may also question why Hayden Panettiere (TV's Heroes) may be a spokesperson for dolphins and their conservation, and who claims to be a vegan, but is also the advertising face of a range of hugely expensive and exclusive Dooney & Bourke leather handbags in the US, claiming to have designed several, and seems to see no hypocrisy or clash of beliefs here, because dolphins are more appealing, or more awareness-raising, than leather, which after all comes from far less photogenic old cattle? Where's the cuddle factor there? The Cove may have some alarming footage, but with the various questions being raised as to O'Barry's veracity, as well as claims that Japan has stopped hunting dolphins because of Psihoyos' film, a fanciful idea at best, have to make one regard most of the film with more than a little scepticism.