Film details

Shattered Glass  2003

Film still

Cast

  • Hayden Christensen
  • Peter Sarsgaard
  • Rosario Dawson
  • Melanie Lynskey
  • Chloe Sevigney
  • Cas Anvar
  • Ted Kotcheff
  • Mark Blum
  • Simone-Elise Girard
  • Chad Donella

Synopsis

In 1998 Stephen Glass is a twenty-five year old journalist working on the Washington-based political magazine The New Republic, whose staff are mostly comprised of low-paid interns straight from college. Glass' work has impressed editor Mike Kelly, and his features regularly appear in the magazine, but Kelly gives him a mild reprimand for making unconfirmed assumptions in a piece on a young Republicans political meeting. Glass becomes popular with the other staff members and more of his work appears, the reporter starting to gather a reputation among the political movers of Capitol Hill and he also freelances for other magazines while studying for a law degree. Marty Peretz, publisher of the magazine, unhappy at the direction The New Republic seems to be taking, fires Mike Kelly, replacing him with Charles Lane, who initially receives a cold reception from the New Republic staff loyal to Kelly. Glass produces one of his most provocative stories to date, how he visited a convention of computer hackers, some responsible for major viruses, and how he met the star delegate, a teenage hacker whose prowess at writing viruses and defending against them led to them being hired as a security consultant by Jukt Electronics, an expanding software firm. The story runs big in The New Republic, but is spotted by the editor of Forbes Digital, an online business magazine. The Forbes reporter Adam Penenberg is queried by the editor as to why Glass got the story when a specialist publication such as themselves didn't. Penenberg investigates and on reading the piece finds that a lot of the technical side is inaccurate, leading Penenberg to believe that Glass has been fed false information by hackers. Penenberg calls Charles Lane, telling him that he believes Glass has been compromised by the people he has interviewed. Lane starts an internal investigation and is surprised that the staff are angered that he is not supporting Glass without question, and Lane hears that they want him replaced as editor. He contacts the Forbes editor and asks him to keep the story about Glass quiet while they probe the truth of the matter. With Glass as a passenger he drives out to where the hacker's convention was meant to have taken place according to the article, and starts to realise that the story is fiction. Stephen Glass knows that his deception has been discovered but once more contacts Mike Kelly, claiming that he is only going to lose his job because Charles Lane is jealous of his loyalty to the deposed Kelly. Lane goes through copies of the magazine and starts to find questionable passages in many of Glass' pieces. Lane fires him, but to his surprise he then receives a letter of support from the New Republic staff, agreeing with his decision to fire the fraud.

Production

Director
Billy Ray
Producer
Craig Baumgarten, Adam Merims, Gaye Hirsch and Tove Christensen
Art Director
Pierre Perrault
Editor
Jeffrey Ford
Music
Mychael Danna
Screenplay
Billy Ray, based on an article in Vanity Fair magazine by Buzz Bissinger
Director of Photography
Mandy Walker

Review

Although occurring in the late 90s, the warning which the case of Stephen Glass presented to the American press was seemingly not heeded, despite the furore which surrounded it in the media and beyond, hence the 2003 and 2004 cases of both USA Today and the more influential and widely respected New York Times having to apologise to readers, and enduring high-level resignations, after it was proved that feature reporters, like Stephen Glass, had fabricated entire or major portions of prominent stories, features and articles. Although the film focuses on only two stories which Glass fabricated, he eventually admitted to making up twenty-seven of forty-one published pieces, an incredible two-thirds, and his boldness didn't stop there, trying to launch himself as a media pundit and commentator, apparently not seeing the irony in the fact that no one would believe anything he said. Glass (Hayden Christensen, about as compelling as he is on screen as Luke Skywalker - not very) fabricated not only the stories but his 'notes' to go with them, and the scenes of him confusing and muddling the teams of fact-checkers is well observed, and a lot of the atmosphere in the newsroom of The New Republic is convincing in its sheer drabness, writer and director Billy Ray refusing to 'jazz up' magazine production, especially on such a publication where stories, quotes, paragraphs or even certain individual words would have to be verified, scrutinised and approved before getting into print. Peter Sarsgaard (Kinsey) gives the best performance in the film as Charles Lane, a man who tolerates both Glass and the staff's seemingly unconditional support for him, slowly discovering the features on which the young man's reputation are founded are partially fabricated at best, and Billy Ray's film has to be regarded as one of the most authentic films about publishing and the sheer mechanical business of producing a magazine. The scale of Glass' deception, and the work he did to produce his bogus stories, show, sadly, that he was actually a very talented writer. The delicious irony of the piece is that for all the in-built safeguards The New Republic wove around itself it was an online magazine and not a rival 'print' publication which finally exposed Glass for the liar he was.