Film details

Never Let Me Go  2010

Cast

  • Carey Mulligan
  • Andrew Garfield
  • Charlotte Rampling
  • Sally Hawkins
  • Nathalie Richard
  • Andrea Riseborough
  • Charlie Rowe
  • Ella Purnell
  • Izzy Meikle-Small
  • Gareth Derrick
  • Lydia Wilson

Synopsis

A highly praised novel by Kazuo Ishiguro (The Remains Of The Day / The White Countess), Never Let Me Go promises to be an intelligent and though-provoking drama, as screenwriter Alex Garland (The Beach) has promised fidelity to the source material which although, of all people, Michael Bay turned the central idea into the shoot-'em-up and chase movie The Island in 2005, is actually an idea which could come to pass in the future, as stem cell technology proceeds. Keira Knightly gets her landlegs back after the Pirates Of The Caribbean movies to play Ruth, a woman who remembers her younger years at a seemingly exclusive private boarding school deep in the English countryside, and reminisces with her two closest friends from that time Tommy (Andrew Garfield - The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus) and Kathy (Carey Mulligan - An Education). Having no memories of any time before the school, they investigate the seemingly nonexistent pasts, and come to find that they are clones, bred purely for the purpose of providing organs for transplantation, But does that mean they are not valid persons in themselves, and if they are the clones then were are those they were cloned from? Ishiguro's novel posts a lot of moral and ethical questions, not only about cloning but also what constitutes a 'person', and oddly the idea of clones used purely for transplantation was used in the rarely-seen but surprisingly clever and effective 1971 film The Resurrection Of Zachery Wheeler, in which the same idea was the central plot twist. Director Mark Romanek (One Hour Photo) came to this after his abrupt and apparently acrimonious departure from the remake of The Wolfman, and has some fine British talent in the cast, including Charlotte Rampling (The Night Porter / Paris By Night) as Miss Emily, the headmistress of the boarding school, and Sally Hawkins and Andrea Riseborough (both to be seen in Mike Leigh's Happy Go Lucky) as teachers at the surprisingly secure facility. Ishiguro's works are often so dense and complex in the narrative that they do not translate easily to the screen, with several including the excellent When We Were Orphans being optioned for the screen only to fall at the screenplay stage, but Never Let Me Go looks to be one of the more interesting dramas of 2010, with the sci-fi angle being just an adjunct to some very serious subject matter.

Production

Director
Mark Romanek
Producer
Alex Garland and Allon Reich
Art Director
Denis Schnegg (supervisor)
Editor
Barney Pilling
Music
Rachel Portman
Screenplay
Alex Garland, based on the novel by Kazuo Ishiguro
Director of Photography
Adam Kimmel

Review

Based on the 2005 Booker Prize shortlisted novel by Kazuo Ishiguro (The Remains Of The Day / The White Countess), Never Let Me Go has a science-fiction premise, set in an alternative but extremely recognisable future, and screenwriter Alex Garland (The Beach / 28 Days Later) has admirably kept fidelity with Ishiguro's source material which, of all people, Michael Bay also used the central idea, without crediting the novel, turning it into the overcooked shoot-'em-up and chase movie The Island. The central premise, which it is fair to say is no longer a 'spoiler', having been mentioned repeatedly since the first publication, that the characters are little more than living donors, is given heft not only by the fact that it could come to pass in the future, as stem cell technology proceeds, but that already families have had 'saviour siblings', children born specifically to help an ailing older brother or sister who may have a specific medical complaint or condition in which DNA-sympathic organs, blood or bone marrow may be needed at some point in the future. As with the book, Garland and director Mark Romanek (One Hour Photo), who came to this after his abrupt and apparently acrimonious departure from the remake of The Wolfman, concentrate on the triangular relationship at the heart of the novel, being seen in reminiscences by one of the characters, which makes the sci-fi and transplantation angle only all the more harrowing when the 'donors' realise the very reasons why they are alive, and how their time on the planet is to be short. The memories are those of Kathy (Carey Mulligan - An Education), a woman who remembers her younger years at a seemingly exclusive private boarding school, Hailsham, deep in the English countryside, and her two closest friends from that time Tommy (Andrew Garfield - The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus) and Ruth (Keira Knightley getting her land legs back after the Pirates Of The Caribbean movies. Having no memories of any time before the school, they investigate their seemingly nonexistent pasts, and come to find that they are clones, bred purely for the purpose of providing organs for transplantation for who can be classed as their 'originals'. But does that mean they are not valid persons in themselves, and if they are the clones then where are those they were cloned from? Against this background is played out the three-sided relationship with is a very melancholic love story but also shot through with cruelty, as Ruth takes tommy away from Kathy, even though it is clear that she does not feel as much for him as Kathy does, and even in their time-constrained lives there is still room for such manipulation and petty jealousies. Ishiguro's novel posts a lot of moral and ethical questions, not only about cloning but also what constitutes a 'person', and oddly the idea of clones used purely for transplantation was used in the rarely-seen but surprisingly clever and effective 1971 film The Resurrection Of Zachery Wheeler, in which the same idea was the central plot twist. Romanek's film is a thought provoking and sensitive piece of work, an extremely dark love story in which at times the cloning angle is almost incidental, and then returns to remind the audience just how dark and sinister the brave new alternate world really is. The central casting is surprisingly deft, with Knightley showing how good she is at playing slightly cold, controlling characters, Garfield's weak and pliant Tommy very obviously falling under that very control, while mulligan shows the vulnerability and sadness which was so effectively used in An Education and not at all in the misguided Wall Street sequel. There is also some fine British talent in the cast, including Charlotte Rampling (The Night Porter) as Miss Emily, the headmistress of the boarding school, and Sally Hawkins and Andrea Riseborough (both to be seen in Mike Leigh's Happy Go Lucky), but it is the central three who have most screen time and use it most effectively. Ishiguro's works are often so dense and complex in the narrative that they do not translate easily to the screen, with several including the excellent When We Were Orphans being optioned for the screen only to fall at the screenplay stage, but Never Let Me Go is one of the most impressive and assured dramas of 2010, with the sci-fi angle being just an adjunct to some very serious and affecting subject matter.