Cast
-
-
Jessica Haynes
-
Fiona Press
-
Eriq Ebouaney
-
Paula Arundell
-
Charles Tertiens
-
Antoinette Engel
-
Monroe Reimers
-
Natalie Becker,
-
Anne Looby
-
Antonio Fisher
-
David Dennis
Synopsis
David Laurie, a white professor of literature, specialising in the Romantic Poets, lectures at a Cape Town university in post-apartheid South Africa. Divorced and in his fifties, he uses his persistence and position at the faculty to embark on an affair with reluctant student Melanie Isaacs, a mixed-race pupil who is afraid that to refuse will badly affect her grades, although David does not see their relationship in that way. He awards her a pass mark for an examination paper she misses sitting. When their relationship, and the pass mark on the paper, are discovered, David is brought before a disciplinary panel in the faculty. Although given a lifeline of keeping his tenure if he will apologise for his actions, he refuses to do so, and is forced to resign his post. Wanting to get away from the city, he goes to stay with his daughter Lucy on the remote farm on the Eastern Cape she used to share with her lesbian partner, but their relationship has now broken up. She shares the land with Petrus, a local black farmer, who is often the only person she sees for days on end, so remote is the farm. David helps her on the farm, enjoying the physical work, so different from his teaching, and also helping at the animal clinic run by Bev Shaw, another of Lucy's friends. The farm is attacked by three young men, who kill Lucy's dogs, attack and beat David and repeatedly rape Lucy during an assault lasting hours. Afterwards, shaken but defiant, Lucy refuses to report the crime, despite David's instance, frustrating him with her acceptance to even acknowledge the severity of what was done to her. He becomes enraged when he finds that Petrus is protecting one of the rapists, a relation of his wife. Disillusioned at what he believed the future could hold, he finds a sympathetic friend in Bev, with whom he begins a tentative relationship, and travels back to the city to apologise to Melanie's parents about his relationship with their daughter, which he seems to accept was inappropriate. His relationship with Bev turns out to be brief, and Lucy tells him she is pregnant, and intends to keep the child. She also says she has agreed to accepting Petrus' protection, even though it means having to sign over the farm and the attached land to him. David is bewildered, but slowly the reasoning behind her decisions become clear to him.
Production
- Director
- Steve Jacobs
- Producer
- Steve Jacobs, Anna Maria Monticelli and Emile Sherman
- Art Director
- Mike Berg and Annie Beauchamp
- Editor
- Alexandre De Franceschi
- Music
- Antony Partos (original)
- Screenplay
- Anna-Maria Monticelli, adapted from the novel by J.M. Coetzee
- Director of Photography
- Steve Jacobs
Review
Adapted by Anna Maria Monticelli from the Booker Prize-winning novel by J.M. Coetzee, Disgrace in its' original form was a harrowing and sometimes punishing read, but the film version, directed by Steve Jacobs (La Spagnola, and writer Monticelli's husband), seems to have altered the emphasis as well as toning down some of the more explicit passages in the book which caused offence to some, so much so that the African National Party denounced it as racist, causing Coetzee to leave the country and move to Australia. Jacobs retains the essence of the Coetzee book but without the bleakness of the book's ending, giving the central character at least some slight aspects of hope whereas on the printed page there was none. The always interesting John Malkovich plays the leading character, David Laurie, a 52 year-old professor of Romantic Literature in post-apartheid South Africa, who starts an affair with a beautiful young mixed-race student. To him, the affair is just a fling, but a scandal erupts that forces David to abandon his lifelong profession and in disgrace, he leaves the city for the remote farm where his daughter, Lucy (Jessica Haines), lives a seemingly uncomplicated rustic life on the Eastern Cape. However, neither of them can escape the realities of contemporary society. When they fall prey to a particularly vicious and ruthless attack by three black men, the fabric of both their lives starts to unravel, and due to an acute inability to communicate, find themselves drifting apart just when they need each the most. The book was a very harrowing read, and at parts almost sadistic in its' treatment of Laurie, who ends up a truly broken man, and one who seems and feels utterly out of place in the new South Africa, but Coetzee also seems to be at pains to point out that it is a country which is undergoing truly terrifying birth pains, and is a place where old divisions and grudges are still being harboured and nurtured. Jacobs approaches the work with honesty, refusing to make Laurie either as stubborn and immovable as he is on the printed page, or making him any sort of heroic figure, Malkovich perfectly portraying a man taken out of the academic system which has essentially been his support system for so many decades, and to whom an affair with a student, no matter how ill-judged or morally dubious, he almost sees as an adjunct of his profession. Laurie is still the focus of Jacobs' narrative, but instead of just being a passive observer as in the book, it is through him that the audience sees his belated acceptance of his situation, and that of Lucy, a very fine performance from newcomer Jessica Haines, the choices she is forced to make, even though it will cost her her land, at least gives her some sort of future as well. Jacobs uses the landscape of the Eastern Cape spectacularly, vast deserted plains showing how insignificant the human dwellers are in such an area, and it also gives a reason why Laurie is initially so stilted and awkward in such emptiness, even in uncomfortable early scenes with his daughter, he previously being a city dweller who may not even know of life outside the big conurbations. Whether the film version will find a better reception with the book's critics is uncertain, both Jacobs and Coetzee being unstinting in some accusatory aspects, but unlike the book the film at least finds hope, if in small quantities, whereas Coetzee, looking hard and unsentimentally at his newly-liberated homeland, saw none.