Cast
-
-
-
-
Samantha Bee
-
Stephanie Szostak
-
Jackie Stewart
-
Clea Lewis
-
Arjun Gupta
-
Alice Drummond
-
Daisy Tahan
-
David Schallipp
-
Matthew Schallipp
Synopsis
Eliza Welch, a New York wife, mother and writer, awakes on the morning of her daughter Clara's sixth birthday party. In the melee of getting ready for school, Clara finds herself going outside in her nightdress, and gets into an argument with her husband, Avery, for coming home with a box of second-hand books he found in the street, claiming that the apartment is already cluttered enough and they don't have room for them. Once Clara and Avery have been dealt with Eliza writes an entry for her blog, and notices an online writing competition, to write a competition essay answering the question What Does Motherhood Mean To Me, entries having to be in the following day, She comes up with a rough draft which she shows Avery, then meets her friend Shiela, who shares yet another racy incident from her life, swearing Eliza to secrecy as always. Returning home she retells Shiela's story in her blog, and when her friend finds out she is furious, reminding Eliza of her vow of silence regarding it. Going out to buy trinkets for the party, Eliza returns home to find a young courier delivering a package, and the friendly young man helps her up the stairs with her bags, she being delighted that he flirts with her charmingly, seeing her as an attractive woman and not automatically just a wife and mother, so much so that she has to ask him to leave in case she forgets herself. Finding that Avery has read her essay, and written very critical and acerbic notes in the margins, she drives off in a rage, wanting to dissipate her anger on the road, having an argument with Avery when he calls her on her mobile, but when she hears her baby son starting to choke on a sweet in the background noise of the call she turns round and rapidly returns home. The little boy is fine, but Eliza and Avery talk earnestly about the pressures and responsibilities of parenting, both agreeing it is one of the most difficult jobs in the world and how no one has a foolproof plan how to approach it. Both are fearing the birthday party but it goes very well, Clara and the other children having a great time and all the other guests, parents all, having a relaxing and enjoyable time, Shiela taking Eliza aside and forgiving her for purloining her story. Eliza manages to complete her essay. She believes she has had a good day, but Avery has a surprise for her.
Production
- Director
- Katherine Dieckmann
- Producer
- Rachel Cohen, Jana Edelbaum, Pamela Koffler, Christine Vachon and John Wells
- Art Director
- Charles Kulsziski
- Editor
- Michael R. Miller
- Music
- Joe Henry
- Screenplay
- Katherine Dieckmann
- Director of Photography
- Nancy Schreiber
Review
Having taken a surprising diversity in her career after the early parts in which she was generally the scatty or sassy girlfriend, Uma Thurman has played a variety of wildly differing roles, although she will probably always be identified with the yellow tracksuit and Samurai sword of Kill Bill. Motherhood, as it sounds, is the polar opposite of that iconic role, and rather reflects the sort of parts she is now more often taking, playing New Yorker Eliza Welch, a former fiction writer, now limited to blogging on her own site while trying to raise her two young children, having had to put her own ambitions to become a serious and recognised writer on the back burner while her kids are growing up, something her otherwise attentive but sometime thoughtless husband, Avery (ERs Anthony Edwards) does not seem to realise, nor how purely draining the job of motherhood can be, although her best friend, Sheila (Minnie Driver - Grosse Point Blank) understands all too well. Claiming to be heavily autobiographical, writer / director Katherine Dieckmann's script focuses on one particular day as Eliza faces a number of challenges, including throwing her daughter's sixth birthday party while taking care of her toddler son, deal with other mums and playground envy, core with a growing problem on her blog after accidentally revealing a friends confession, and entering a parenting magazines competition, as if she didn't have enough to do, answering the question What Does Motherhood Mean To Me, in five hundred words. Dieckmann (Diggers / A Good Baby) is trying to put over a lot about the thousands of aspects of motherhood in a tight ninety minutes, in a comedy which is sincere and obviously based on gruelling and bitter experience, and Thurman's performance doesn't essentially give her a minutes peace, meaning that the audience largely has to piece together her character through her deeds rather than her words, and although one can see that Eliza certainly has a hectic life, she also has it much better than 99.9% of women in her condition, who don't have two rent-stablisied apartments in a brownstone in NY's West Village, where money certainly doesn't seem to be a problem, and while no one is going to say Eliza is crying wolf, she certainly has it easier than most mothers. Even given these advantages, Dieckmann makes Eliza's predicament and problems believable, even if to have all of these happen on one day would probably send anybody else to the gin bottle, and it is certainly focused on her to the detriment of the other characters, Anthony Edwards doing as much as he can with a barely sketched character. Uma Thurman is a very capable actress, and can do roles like this with surprisingly little effort, but unfortunately as she always looks so capable that when Eliza obviously conquers everything and realises, eventually, she is making a good job of motherhood, or as good as anybody ever does, its' not actually a surprise. With enough smart insights and clever asides as to Eliza's plight, Motherhood is certainly watchable, and often cleverly funny, but one has to wonder just how it would be without Thurman in the leading role.