Film details

Straw Dogs  2011

Cast

  • James Marsden
  • Kate Bosworth
  • Alexander Skarsgard
  • Dominic Purcell
  • Laz Alonso
  • Willa Holland
  • Rhys Coiro
  • Anson Mount
  • Billy Lush
  • Drew Powell

Synopsis

Newly married couple David and Amy Sumner return to the small town in Mississippi where Amy was raised, intending to live in her late father's house as David, a Hollywood scriptwriter who is working on a project dealing with the Battle of Stalingrad, works on the script, Amy being an actress whose roles have mostly been restricted to TV. Going to the local bar, David immediately attracts the attention of the locals by ordering a light beer, and then finding they do not accept credit cards, but is also alarmed by the loud and violent behaviour of Tom Heddon, a man in his sixties, and the local football coach, and seeing how those in the bar all seem to be in deference to him. David is also alarmed by how close Amy seems to be with Charlie Venner, her ex-boyfriend and once the local school's star quarterback, but now working in construction, having never made the leap from college football. David hires him and his crew to repair the roof of the barn opposite their home, and Charlie and his men make no attempt to hide their open leering over Amy as she appears at the windows of the cottage, or to try to get the job done, working only a few hours each day, much to David's frustration. Their lack of respect for him comes to a head when one of them walks through the house to get a beer from the fridge while David is working, and seems resentful when he asks the labourer to affix an ornamental bear-trap to the wall. David and Charlie get to talking, David realises that, unlike a lot of the locals, he has a good education, knowing the dates of the Battle of Stalingrad and recognising the music playing in the study as Beethoven, but Charlie also goads David, telling him that Amy has returned because she still feels something for him, and berates David for walking out of church when he realised how fundamentalist and intolerant the local preacher's sermon was. Invited by the workmen to join them on a deer hunt in to woods, Charlie and one of his friends, Norman, force themselves into the cottage while he is away and rape Amy, but when he returns she says nothing to him about the ruthless attack, although David knows something has happened and deeply upset her. On Friday night there is the traditional Friday night college football games, during which Janice Heddon, Tom Heddon's precocious cheerleader daughter, makes advances towards Jeremy Niles, a local young man who is badly retarded, and as the two fumble in the darkness Niles accidentally strangles her, mistaking her struggles for passion. Running away, Niles is hit by David's car, and taken back to the Sumner's house to recover. Discovering Janice dead and hearing that Niles was last seen with her, Heddon, Charlie and his cronies find he is at David and Amy's house, going there to demand they hand him over. When local Police officer John Burke, an Iraq veteran and African-American, tries to intervene, Heddon shoots him in the back. With the cottage under siege, and Heddon and the others determined to kill all three of them so as to not leave any witnesses, David realises he will have to put his moral code aside and turn to violence to protect himself, Amy and Niles, one man against a heavily-armed mob of seething thugs.

Production

Director
Rod Lurie
Producer
Marc Frydman and Rod Lurie
Art Director
John P. Goldsmith
Editor
Sarah Boyd
Music
Larry Groupe
Screenplay
Rod Lurie, based on the ABC motion picture screenplay by David Zelag Goodman and Sam Peckinpah, based on the novel The Siege Of Trencher's Farm by Gordon M. Williams
Director of Photography
Alik Sakharov

Review

In a time where so many remakes seem to be largely pointless, Sam Peckinpah fans may believe that a remake of his 1971 pic Straw Dogs is truly one of the most needless, the original film still packing a brutal punch today, and one has to remember the absolute furore the film caused when it first opened, but director and screenplay writer Rod Lurie (The Contender / The Last Castle) has remained oddly close to the original, both in content and feel. Crediting the original screenplay by David Zelag Goodman and Sam Peckinpah, itself based on the novel The Siege Of Trencher's Farm by Gordon M. Williams, a fine writer and journalist who also co-created the much-missed TV series Hazell with Terry Venables (yes, the same) and who hasn't been heard from in any media for several years, making some believe he has passed away, Lurie makes a pivotal change to the original, the most obvious being changing the film's British location of Cornwall to Mississippi in the Deep South, with all that entails, where Los Angelean David Sumner (James Marsden - the X-Men series) relocates with his wife Amy (Kate Bosworth - Superman Returns), returning to her home town, thus losing the idea of complete alienation, the fact that Sumner was an American in the Peckinpah version being a vital plot point and also fuelling his impotent resentment against the locals, and the fact that there is very little age difference between Marsden and Bosworth also loses the age differential in the Peckinpah pic between Dustin Hoffman and Susan George which was another plot point, slowly fuelling the ire of the dangerous Charlie (Del Henney in the Peckinpah film and played by Alexander Skarsgard from TV's True Blood here), Amy's ex-boyfriend who wants her back. In the original the feelings of jealousy and xenophobia combined brilliantly, and the siege of the title is triggered when a local mentally retarded man, Niles (here played by Dominic Purcell - TV's Prison Break), accidentally kills a young girl who has precociously led him on, taking refuge with the Sumners, and where the revelation of Amy's rape by Charlie and the thuggish Norman (Rhys Corio - The Unborn) is made. On the first the effectiveness was partly due to the film actually being relatively restrained, for all its' press-led hysteria, but extraordinarily intense, and here there it is almost more explicit, and one knows that the worker's nail-guns which are lying around are going to be used in ways not recommended in the manufacturer's manual, and the bear trap David is using as rustic decoration also gets used in an unorthodox way, but four decades on the actual level of violence is really almost what is expected in an American revenge thriller, with rape being the inevitable trigger and motivation, and as with the first, the violence David has to meet out is seen as a form of initiation in to some form of more brutal manhood, he being forced for the first time to put down the pen and take up the sword in order to protect those he loves. With the performances all being adequate, although the villains here are not as effective since they are largely the same as David Sumner rather than the very different and more rough-hewn and cruder natives Hoffman's character encountered, Lurie adds a couple of interesting angles, such as the character of Tom Heddon, Peter Vaughn as a psychopathic Pop Larkin in the first and here being a boorish super-patriot played by James Woods (TV's Shark), and having sway in the town through being the local football coach, while the racial tensions which one would have thought could have been central only being seen in the only black character, John Brown (Laz Alonzo - Avatar), the local cop and an Iraq veteran, who is killed by Heddon despite his blubbing devotion to the flag. The supporting line-up, which includes such fearsome sorts as Walton Goggins (TV's The Shield) and Billy Lush (TV's Generation Kill), and the mere fact that the new pic is located in the deep South rather than the serene and quiet English countryside only makes the inevitable violence all the less surprising. Straw Dogs still manages to push some provocative buttons, but the landscape against which it does so is much changed, and what was from Peckinpah terrifying and, to some, bordering on the obscene, many objecting to what was heavily hinted at but never made fully explicit in Susan George's rape scene, is now the sort of revenge thriller which Hollywood turns out on a conveyer belt, with such films as Justice and Trespass, both starring Nicolas Cage, being released in the same time period as this. Effective and watchable, but without the crushing impact of the original.