Film details

Everybody's Fine  2009

Cast

Synopsis

Frank Goode, a widower, is preparing a barbecue, hoping to reunite his four grown-up children, Amy, Rosie, Robert and David, who all live in different parts of the States, but he receives calls from Amy, Rosie and Robert all to tell him that David won't be able to make it, and neither will they. Frank decides that if they will not come to him, then he will go to them, despite being warned by his physician, Dr. Ed, of the strain of such a long trip on his heart, for which he is on medication. Arriving in New York to surprise David, an artist, Frank is disappointed to find he is not home, no one seeming to know when he will return. Travelling to Chicago to see Amy, a successful advertising executive, and her family, Amy phones Rosie and Robert privately, the three knowing that david is in Mexico, and in trouble, and decide to keep this from their father. When Frank travels to Denver in order to see Robert, Amy goes to Mexico to try to find their brother, but receives no help from the Mexican authorities, who show a decided reluctance to be of any assistance at all. Once in Denver Frank finds that his son is a percussionist in an orchestra, and not the conductor he had always been led to believe. Hearing that the orchestra is about to go on tour, Frank decides to move on without speaking to Robert, not wanting him to realise his father knows the truth, and sets off for Las Vegas, but misses the bus, and a scuffle with a homeless man in the bus station results in Frank losing most of his heart pills. Once in Vegas he meets up with Rosie, who shows him her impressive apartment, telling him that she is doing very well as a dancer, but while she is out of the room her hears a phone message on the machine from the real owner of the apartment. Meeting her friend Jilly when she drops off her baby which Rosie takes care off and baby-sits. Boarding a flight home, and still thinking about David, Frank suffers a heart attack. In hospital in intensive care, he dreams about his children, and what they have been keeping from him, none of them wanting to reveals the truth about themselves - that Amy is on the verge of splitting up with her husband, that Robert never shared the high ambitions his father had for him and is happy just being a percussionist, and that Rosie is in a happy relationship with Jilly. As he recovers, the three come to visit him, but with them they bring news of David, the one whose fate he could not see....

Production

Director
Kirk Jones
Producer
Vittorio Cecchi Gori, Ted Field, Glynis Murray and Gianni Nunnari
Art Director
Drew Boughton
Editor
Andrew Mondshein
Music
Dario Marianelli
Screenplay
Kirk Jones, based on the screenplay of the film Stanno Tutti Bene by Massimo De Rita, Tonino Guerra and Giuseppe Tornatore
Director of Photography
Henry Braham

Review

A remake which was a long time on the cards, and seemingly just as long in the editing suite, this remake of Giuseppe Tornatore's 1990 comedy / drama Stanno Tutti Bene has an interesting cast, and is a subject which sets it self up well for a US-set remake, despite Tornatore's original being very country-specific, reflecting on problems in both Italian society and increasingly fragmented Italian families. The core idea, that families actually hide a lot from each other for the good of all concerned, is a universal one, and the adaptation of the original script by British writer and director Kirk Jones (Waking Ned / Nanny McPhee) is well served by his notable cast, even if what was largely hinted at in the Italian original is underlined heavily for the benefit for the US audiences, such as Rosie (Drew Barrymore - Charlie's Angels) being a lesbian, and Jones is also unable to save the revelations at the end as Robert De Niro's widower Frank lies in a hospital bed, from being terribly heavy-handed, making mawkish and slushy what was sentimental but more genuinely affecting in the Tornatore pic. De Niro is good casting as the lead here, played by the excellent Marcello Mastroianni in the original, as Frank, a widower who realises that his only real connection with his four children has largely come through his late wife, also bringing up the pertinent and very accurate point in the script that children always find it easier to genuinely confide in their mothers than their fathers, so decides to visit all four of them, they all having responsible jobs and inconveniently living in four different cities, causing Frank to have to go on a meandering road trip, although he finds he cannot meet up with his son David, this becoming the one thing, apart from their own situations, which the other three have to keep from their father as they try to locate him, knowing only that he is in Mexico and in trouble. There are certainly some classy names in the cast, including Kate Beckinsale (the Underworld series), Sam Rockwell (Confessions Of A Dangerous Mind) as some of Frank's brood, and the Oscar-nominated Melissa Leo, and the film is certainly finely played and well written, even if the feeling that there is going to be an over-sentimental ending is ever-looming, and one has to think that Frank should be suspicious when it seems that everything is going so swimmingly for his children, at least through what they tell him. One can't help but get the feeling that what was just tolerable at points in Tornatore's original, Mastroianni's central performance veering dangerously close to sticky sentimentality at times, is ramped up here to quite dangerous levels to make it more palatable for US audiences, De Niro at least playing the part admirably straight and not reverting to the doddery absent-mindedness which Mastroianni too often relied on. Kirk Jones certainly makes a decent job of the adaptation and the performances are all creditable, but with the sentimental manipulation of the last couple of reels and a too-pat ending it's a case of everybody's fine rather than everybody's excellent.