Film details

City of Life and Death  2009

Nanjing! Nanjing! / Nanking Nanking

Cast

  • Ye Liu
  • Yuanyuan Gao
  • Hideo Nakaizumi
  • Wei Fan
  • Yiyan Jiang
  • Ryu Kohata
  • Bin Liu
  • Yuko Miyamoto
  • John Paisley
  • Beverly Peckous
  • Lan Qin
  • You Sima

Synopsis

A major hit in it's native China in early 2009, The City Of Life And Death deals with a subject long regarded taboo in the area, the almost unimaginable slaughter carried out by invading Japanese troops in the city of Nanking in only four days in December 1937 in what has been called one of the most appalling war crimes in any conflict, with figures of fatalities and casualties still being disputed, with estimates of over 200,000 killed and executed and tens of thousands of women raped, estimated to be around 85% of the female population of the city. Director Lu Chuan, maker of the sometimes remarkably beautiful Kekexili: Mountain Patrol in 2004, knows that the subject is a huge and very contentious one, so shoots in black and white, but also does not avoid some incredibly harrowing sights, with scenes of literally hundreds of mutilated bodies piled in the streets. Knowing the scale of the story, Chuan opts for a fragmented narrative, while also making the story of what happened clear to non-Eastern audiences, focusing on a handful of characters in what are almost vignettes, including Lu, a resistance fighter, and Miss Jang, a leader in what the Japanese called 'Safety Zones' set up as sanctuaries, but which were little more than holding pens which the soldiers raided for males to execute and women to rape, to Mr. Tang a conflicted collaborator and local prostitute Xiao. Also involved are two foreigners, the German businessman John Rabe, ironically a Nazi Party member who used his party credentials to gain leverage with the military authorities, and missionary Minnie Vautrin, both of whose delaying tactics and offers of sanctuary allowed some 200,000 Chinese to flee the city, the Japanese being careful not to harm Rabe or Vautrin less it attracted international attention to what was happening, and Kadokawa, a Japanese soldier who is horrified by what he sees happening, but is also too much of an adherent to the rules of his status to intervene, a sympathetic Japanese character who caused Chuan to have death threats made against him and his family. An unbelievably harrowing tale, but one which is told with discretion and even subtlety, and the fact that the subject is not even touched upon in many Japanese school textbooks dealing with the war shows what a contentious subject it still is. Interestingly, a previously taboo subject, the massacre has been the subject of a number of films in recent years, apart from the exploitative Black Sun, directed by the infamous T.F. Mou (The Men Behind The Sun series) in 1987, with both Nanking, a American-funded dramatised documentary, made in 2007, and John Rabe, a German drama revolving around the businessman, with Ulrich Takur winning awards in the title role, being made in 2009.

Production

Director
Lu Chuan
Producer
Han Sanping, Qin Hong, Zhou Li, John Chong and Andy Zhang
Art Director
Hao Yi and Lin Chaoxiang
Editor
Yun Teng
Music
Tong Liu
Screenplay
Lu Chuan
Director of Photography
Yu Cao

Review

A major if hugely controversial hit in it's native China in early 2009, City Of Life And Death deals with a subject long regarded taboo in the country, the almost unimaginable slaughter carried out by invading Japanese troops in the city on Nanjing in December 1937 / January 1938 in what has been called one of the most appalling war crimes in any conflict, with figures of fatalities and casualties still being disputed, with estimates of over 200,000 killed and executed and tens of thousands of women raped, estimated to be around 85% of the female population of the city. Director Lu Chuan, maker of the sometimes remarkably beautiful Kekexili: Mountain Patrol in 2004, knows that the subject is a huge and very contentious one, so shoots in black and white, but also does not avoid some incredibly harrowing sights, with scenes of literally hundreds of mutilated bodies piled in the streets. Knowing the scale of the story, Chuan opts for a fragmented narrative, while also making the story of what happened clear to non-Eastern audiences, focusing on a handful of characters in what are almost vignettes, including Lu (Liu Ye - The Curse Of The Golden Flower), a resistance fighter, and Miss Jiang (Gao Yuanyuan - Beijing Bicycle), a leader in what the Japanese called 'Safety Zones' set up as sanctuaries, but which were little more than holding pens which the soldiers raided for males to execute and women to rape, to Xiao (Jiang Yiyan), a local woman forced to be a sex slave for the Japanese. Also featured is John Rabe (John Paisley - Fearless), the German businessman, ironically an influential Nazi Party member, who used his party credentials to gain leverage with the military authorities, and whose delaying tactics and offers of sanctuary allowed some 200,000 Chinese to flee the city, the Japanese being careful not to harm Rabe less it attracted international attention to what was happening, and Kadokawa (Hideo Nakaizumi - Who's Camus Anyway), a Japanese soldier who is horrified by what he sees happening, but is also too much an adherent to the rules of his status to intervene, a sympathetic Japanese character which caused Chuan to have death threats made against him and his family by hardline Chinese groups for having the temerity to include. An unbelievably harrowing tale, but one which is told with discretion and even subtlety, and that fact that the subject is not even touched upon in many Japanese school textbooks dealing with the war shows what a contentious subject it still is. Interestingly the previously unmentionable massacre has been the subject of a number of films in recent years, apart from the exploitative Black Sun, directed by the infamous T.F. Mou (The Men Behind The Sun series) in 1987, with both Nanking, a American-funded dramatised documentary, made in 2007, and John Rabe, a German drama revolving around the businessman, with Ulrich Takur winning awards in the title role, in 2009. The style in which Lu Chuan handles the story, focusing on aspects and individuals rather than the widespread horror happening literally in the streets, makes it almost unbearably moving, the fact that consecutive Japanese governments have refused to apologise only adding to the sense of bewilderment that such a thing could ever happen.