Film details

City of War: The Story of John Rabe  2009

John Rabe / La Bei Ri Ji

Cast

  • Ulrich Tukur
  • Anne Cosigny
  • Daniel Bruhl
  • Gottfried John
  • Dagmar Manzel
  • Jingchu Zhang
  • Teruyuki Kagawa
  • Mathias Herrmann
  • Tetta Sugimoto
  • Christian Rodska

Synopsis

Having been a previously taboo subject in the East, recent years have seen several films about the horrendous Nanking Massacre, the almost unimaginable slaughter carried out by invading Japanese troops in the city on Nanking in December 1937 in what has been called one of the most appalling war crimes in any period of time, having been the subject matter of Lu Chuan's highly praised The City Of Life And Death, the exploitative Black Sun, directed by the infamous T.F. Mou (The Men Behind The Sun series), and Nanking, a American-funded dramatised documentary, made in 2007. The events of the horrendous period are undeniable, with estimates of over 200,000 killed and executed and tens of thousands of women raped, estimated to be around 85% of the female population of the city, although subsequent Japanese governments have largely refused to accept any culpability at all until recently, and even then grudgingly. John Rabe, written and directed by Florian Gallenberger (Tango Berlin) focuses on one of the heroes of the situation, John Rabe (Ulrich Tukur - The White Ribbon / Seraphine), a German businessman based in the city, and ironically a Nazi Party member who used his party credentials to gain leverage with the military authorities, and whose delaying tactics and offers of sanctuary allowed some 200,000 Chinese to flee the city, the Japanese being careful not to harm Rabe less it attracted international attention to what was happening in the city, allowing him to establish the Nanking Safety Zone where many took refuge. Focusing on the ex-patriate efforts to help the native Chinese, the film details the immense humanitarian struggle to get as many people as possible out of the city, which led to Rabe being compared to Oskar Schindler, and director Gallenberger takes a rather more restrained approach to almost any other version of the story, largely avoiding explicit violence but still managing to make a very impactful and effective drama. A strong cast of character actors includes Dagmar Manzel (Schtonk!) as Rabe's devoted wife Dora, Steve Buscemi (Reservoir Dogs) as Dr. Robert O. Wilson, an American physician working in China at the time, and Daniel Bruel (Goodbye Lenin) as a German compatriot, Dr. Georg Rosen.

Production

Director
Florian Gallenberger
Producer
Benjamin Herrmann, Mischa Hofmann and Jan Mojto
Art Director
Juhua Tu, Xinran Tu and Marcus Wellendorf
Editor
Hansjorg Weissbrich
Music
Annette Focks
Screenplay
Florian Gallenberger, inspired by the book John Rabe: Der Gute Deutsche Von Nanking / John Rabe: The Good German Of Nanking, edited by Erwin Wickert
Director of Photography
Jurgen Jurges

Review

Having been a previously taboo subject in the East, recent years have seen several films about the horrendous Nanking Massacre, the almost unimaginable slaughter carried out by invading Japanese troops in the city on Nanking in December 1937 in what has been called one of the most appalling war crimes in any period of time, having been the subject matter of Lu Chuan's highly praised The City Of Life And Death, the exploitative Black Sun, directed by the infamous T.F. Mou (The Men Behind The Sun), and Nanking, a American-funded dramatised documentary, made in 2007. The events of the horrendous period are undeniable, with estimates of over 200,000 killed and executed and tens of thousands of women raped, estimated to be around 85% of the female population of the city, although subsequent Japanese governments have largely refused to accept any culpability at all until recently, and even then grudgingly, and City Of War, written and directed by Florian Gallenberger (Tango Berlin) focuses on one of the heroes of the situation, John Rabe (Ulrich Tukur - The White Ribbon / Seraphine), a German businessman based in the city, and ironically a Nazi Party member who used his party credentials to gain leverage with the military authorities, and whose delaying tactics and offers of sanctuary allowed some 200,000 Chinese to flee the city. Compared by some to Oskar Schindler, this is certainly the approach Gallenberger takes, basing his script on a book entitled John Rabe: The Good German Of Nanking, and Rabe is a good German beyond parallel, despite the Nazi credentials and a belief that his telegram to Hitler will get a personal response, and interestingly this very much concentrates on the Europeans involved rather than the Chinese themselves, who are very much relegated to extras milling around, grateful for the benevolence of Rabe. A strong cast of character actors includes Dagmar Manzel (Schtonk!) as Rabe's devoted wife Dora, Steve Buscemi (Reservoir Dogs) as Dr. Robert O. Wilson, an American physician working in China at the time, and Daniel Bruel (Goodbye Lenin) as a German compatriot, Dr. Georg Rosen, but interestingly one of the major players in the real story, American missionary Minnie Vautrin, is eliminated from this telling of the tale altogether and replaced by a fictional character, much as Rabe's supporters focused on him rather than Vautrin in their accounts of the time. The full horror of the real event may be too awful to ever truly capture on film, but if The City Of Life And Death is the arthouse production of the tale then City Of War, the English language title adopted to associate it with the Lu Chuan film, is the ITV early Sunday evening version.