Film details

My Last Five Girlfriends  2010

Cast

  • Brendan Patricks
  • Naomie Harris
  • Kelly Adams
  • Cecile Cassel
  • Jane March
  • Edith Bukovics
  • Michael Sheen
  • Mark Benton
  • Johnny Ball
  • Daniel Hoffman-Gill
  • Chris Gasgoyne

Synopsis

Duncan Anderson, a young writer living in London, has finally, after a life of frustration, pain and emotional heartache, decided to take his own life. As he pens his suicide note, it triggers memories of the relationships which have brought him to this point, his mind turning them into fantasy rides and attractions in an imaginary theme park based on his own life, Duncan's World. His first girlfriend was Wendy, with whom everything seemed to be going well, until delivering Duncan a major blow by leaving him to get back with her ex, for whom she previously had nothing but bad things to say. His second was Olive, a very attractive woman but with very particular habits and foibles, and his attempts to adapt his own behaviour and habits to try to be more in step with hers end in complete disaster and another break-up. His next was Rhona, completely different from him, but this too becomes a stumbling block and they break up because he finds it hard to cope with how completely different they are in almost all aspects. With his fourth, Nathalie, things seem to go very well, so much so that the pair end up living together, Nathalie believing that they truly have a future together, but they eventually break up due to Duncan's own doubt and misgivings about both their relationship and his own failings, seeing only future unhappiness where Nathalie sees hope. Duncan moves onto dating one of Nathalie's friends, Gemma, and falls desperately in love with her, taking her to Paris and hoping that this time he has truly found the one, but to destroy his euphoria Gemma reveals that she has also been sleeping with a good friend of his, Giles. They break up, it being the trigger for Duncan's suicide attempt, he having lost all faith in the idea of love and romance, but since everything else in his life has gone so wrong, why should killing himself be any different?

Production

Director
Julian Kemp
Producer
Michael Kelk, Marion Pilowsky and David Willing
Art Director
Kit Line
Editor
Julian Kemp
Music
Andy Blythe and Marten Joustra
Screenplay
Julian Kemp, based on the book Essays In Love by Alain de Botton
Director of Photography
Dave Miller

Review

Julian Kemp's My Last Five Girlfriends has aspirations to be a rom-com with a difference, based on a book by the influential philosopher Alain de Botton, a very respected writer, but more for his philosophy than his fiction, of which his book Essays In Love is an example, but rather than being just an example of chick-lit penned by a man, the fearsomely intelligent de Botton actually interweaves various philosophical tenets into the story, giving five examples of how to handle differing relationships, which in this film version has writer Duncan Anderson (Brendan Patricks - TV's Horne & Corden) looking back on the girls of the title, Julian Kemp's script appending each story to a fairground ride, with different hazards and pitfalls, and how their relationships blossomed and eventually faded, through the behaviour of both parties involved, although the whole point of vignettes one to four is essentially to set up number five, Gemma (Naomie Harris - Ninja Assassin) as the one he realises he should have kept, and now regrets losing, the cumulative effect of all these disasters leading to him wanting to top himself. Directed by screenplay writer Kemp, also responsible for the bingo comedy House!, My Last Five Girlfriends has some decent talent, including Cecile Cassel (The Romance Of Astrea And Celadon) and Kelly Adams (TV's Holby City / Hustle), and a return to the screen after several years away for Jane Marsh (The Lover / The Colour Of Night), as well as a couple of interesting if brief cameos from the ubiquitous Michael Sheen, Mark Benton (TV's Early Doors) and children's TV god Johnny Ball, but the Michael Douglas in the credits is not the one you're thinking of. Kemp is trying to carry off something quite high concept but on a completely inadequate budget, the theme park idea being clever but which is obviously too complicated and elaborate to be pulled off on screen effectively, and a scene of every patron having Duncan's face is not only blatantly stolen from Being John Malkovich, and pretty cheaply done, since they are obviously paper cut-out masks, but also has absolutely no relevance to anything within the script. De Botton's book poses some surprisingly potent philosophical questions including the inevitable question of why humans believe they need a mate, and whether monogamy is actual the ideal state for emotional wellbeing, but Kemp finds these a little too difficult to handle, briefly raising them as ideas before dispensing with them and focusing back on Duncan's increasingly gloomy reminiscences instead. One cannot accuse Kemp's film of lacking ambition, but to try to attempt it with such limited resources has produced the results on show here.