Film details

New York, I Love You  2009

NY, I Love You

Cast

Synopsis

Having already made the often interesting but also infuriatingly bitty and distracted Paris, Je T'Aime in 2006, producer and 'conceptualist' Emmanuele Benbihy brings off the same formula again, to apparently similar results, setting the same idea in New York City, filming ten vignettes with a loose wraparound, engaging eleven directors as different as the German / Turkish Fatih Akin, the French Yvan Attal, American Allen Hughes of The Hughes Brothers, Japanese Shunji Iwai, Indian Shekar Kapur, actress turned helmer Natalie Portman, and Brett Ratner, more associated with the Rush Hour crowdpleasers than anything with loftier ambitions. Wanting to encapsulate, as with Paris, the feel of the city, the vignettes are a very varied lot, ranging from a pickpocket being outsmarted by one of his marks, a Hasidic woman on the eve of her wedding deciding to approach a stranger for the first time and an artist in desperate need of a model while inspiration seizes him, to a kid going to the school prom with a wheelchair-bound girl, defying what the other students will say, and a retired singer contemplating committing suicide. As with any compilation of this sort, and as in the case of Paris, there is talent to spare in almost all categories, with music from the likes of Mychael Danna (Little Miss Sunshine), Marcelo Zarvos (Sin Nombre) and Devo's Mark Mothersbaugh, writers such as the late and much-missed Anthony Minghella, cinematographers including Benoit Debie (Irreversible) and Mark Pin Bing-Lee (Flight Of The Red Balloon), and a truly remarkable cast including the likes of Christina Ricci, Andy Garcia, Orlando Bloom, Ethan Hawke, James Caan, Julie Christie, John Hurt, Shia LaBeouf, Burt Young, Chris Copper and the venerable veteran Eli Wallach, but of course due to the stricture of the thing, essentially cramming eleven different strands or stories into a 103 minute running time, they actually get little individual screen time. The idea is nice, for those who can put up with the necessarily episodic and fractured structure, but with so much having to be crammed into such a compressed format it can also become extremely infuriating, vignettes ending or being cut away from just as they are getting interesting.

Production

Director
Fatih Akin, Yvan Attal, Randall Balsmeyer, Allen Hughes, Shunji Iwai, Wen Jiang, Shekar Kapur, Joshua Marston, Mira Nair, Matalie Portman and Brett Ratner
Producer
Emmanuele Benbihy and Marina Grasic
Art Director
Katya DeBear
Editor
Jennifer Auge, Tricia Cooke, Jacob Craycroft, Affonso Goncalves, Mark Hlefrich, Shunji Iwai, Allyson C. Johnson, Melody London, Cindy Mollo, (uncredited - and Craig McKay)
Music
Tonino Ballardo, Nicholas Britell, Paul Cantelon, Mychael Danna, Ilhan Ersahin, Jack Livesey, Shiji Mitsui, Mark Mothersbaugh, Peter Nashel, Marcelo Zarvos, Atticus Ross, Leopold ross and Claudia Sarne
Screenplay
Hu Hing and Yao Meng, Suketi Mehta, Shunji Iwai, Olivier Lecot, Jeff Nathanson, Alexandra Cassavettes and Stephen Winter, Anthony Minghella, Nathalie Portman, Fatih Akin, Joshua Marston, (uncredited - Yvan Attal), transitions written by Hall Powell, Istarl Horovitz and James Strouse, concept by Emmanuele Benbihy, premise by Tristan Carne, some segments adaprted from stories by Israel Horovitz
Director of Photography
Jean-Louis Bompoint, Benoit Debie, Pawel Edelman, Pin Bing-Lee, Michael McDonough, Andrij Parekh, Declan Quinn and Marcello Rubenstein

Review

Having already made the often interesting but also infuriatingly bitty and distracted Paris, Je T'Aime in 2006, and intending to do the same with Rio, Shanghai, Jerusalem and Mumbai in the ongoing Cities of Love series, producer and 'conceptualist' Emmanuele Benbihy brings off the same formula again, setting the same idea in New York City, filming ten vignettes with a loose wraparound, engaging eleven directors as different as the German / Turkish Fatih Akin, the French Yvan Attal, American Allen Hughes of The Hughes Brothers, Japanese Shunji Iwai, Indian Shekar Kapur, actress turned helmer Natalie Portman, and Brett Ratner, more associated with the Rush Hour crowdpleasers than anything with loftier ambitions. Wanting to encapsulate, as with Paris, the feel of the city, the vignettes are an extremely varied lot, ranging from a pickpocket being outsmarted by one of his marks, a Hasidic woman on the eve of her wedding haggling with an Arabic diamond dealer and an artist in desperate need of a model while inspiration seizes him, to a kid going to the school prom with a wheelchair-bound girl, this being perhaps the most tasteless and certainly contrived episode, helmed by Brett Ratner and seeming to be the filmed version of a shaggy dog story. As with any compilation of this sort, and as in the case of Paris, there is talent to spare in almost all categories, with music from the likes of Mychael Danna (Little Miss Sunshine), Marcelo Zarvos (Sin Nombre) and Devo's Mark Mothersbaugh, writers such as the late and much-missed Anthony Minghella, cinematographers including Benoit Debie (Irreversible) and Mark Pin Bing-Lee (Flight Of The Red Balloon), and a truly remarkable cast including the likes of Christina Ricci, Andy Garcia, Orlando Bloom, Ethan Hawke, James Caan, Julie Christie, John Hurt, Shia LaBeouf, Burt Young, Chris Copper and the venerable veteran Eli Wallach, but of course due to the stricture of the thing, essentially cramming eleven different strands or stories into a 103 minute running time, they actually get little individual screen time. The idea is nice, for those who can put up with the necessarily episodic and fractured structure, but with so much having to be crammed into such a compressed format it can also become extremely infuriating, vignettes ending or being cut away from just as they are getting interesting. The tone also varies hugely, from the frat-boy comedy of the Ratner episode to the poignant drama of Fatih Akin's segment concerning an artist and his unfinished canvases, to the most baffling of the lot, the obviously fantasy-oriented vignette, by Shekar Kapur, involving Julie Christie and the seeming reincarnation of someone she once knew, appearing after the accidental defenestration of a bellhop. A curate's egg to be sure, but perhaps the best idea is to approach this, and the others in the series, as a collection of shorts, and watch them singly or two or three at a time. Seeing them all at once is disorienting.