Film details

Greenberg  2010

Cast

Synopsis

Having had considerable critical success with his earlier The Squid And The Whale and Margot At The Wedding, even if neither exactly shattered box-office records even at the pokiest arthouses, director and co-writer Noah Baumbach switches coasts from his regular New York milieu for Greenberg, co-written with co-star Jennifer Jason Leigh, setting his tale in a strangely idealised Los Angeles, but which revolves around his familiar themes of people being trapped in a state of stasis in both their professional and personal lives, ambition and long-term goals being vague and unformed, living instead for a bland meandering day-to-day existence. That's the state Florence Hope (Greta Gerwig - Hannah Takes The Stairs / Baghead) finds herself in as she looks after the rather plush Hollywood Hills home owned by the Greenberg family for whom she works as a family assistant, when they go overseas, not expecting the arrival of Roger (Ben Stiller in a credible film for once), the brother of the owner, and who is just getting over a nervous breakdown, his plan is to stay for six weeks, doing nothing in particular except building a dog house for the family. A mass of neuroses and contradictions, Roger also cannot drive, utterly fatal in Los Angeles, meaning Florence has to take him everywhere and a tentative relationship grows between them, until Roger makes his intentions very plain indeed and their affair is as weird and disjointed as anything in Baumbach's other films. His life goes yet further off the rails of a supposed recovery after an attempted reconciliation with an ex (JJ Leigh), who is now a mother, and a meeting with an old friend, Ivan (Rhys Ifans), a British former band member who is trying to ditch the booze and drugs while also undergoing a trial separation from his wife, just to add to his troubles, and his meeting with Ivan gets Roger back on the drugs he had previously dumped years previously. All this sounds grim but Baumbach directs with the sort of level and even pace which gives most events the same emotional gravity, from the mundane to the provocative, and Stiller is getting surprisingly good notices for his performance, a man who has turned forty and realises he has absolutely no anchors in his life, no stability and nothing to cling on to. The presence of Greta Gerwig indicates the film's acknowledgement to the briefly in vogue 'mumblecore' sub-genre, and indeed her performance here has been described as almost imperceptible, Florence being a character who just seems to eventually react to anything which happens around her, never instigating anything herself, which will strike some as frighteningly realistic and other as essentially anti-cinema, and Greenberg, despite the box-office potential of Ben Stiller, seems as if it will once more play largely to Baumbach's already established audience.

Production

Director
Noah Baumbach
Producer
Jennifer Jason Leigh and Scott Rudin
Art Director
Curt Beech
Editor
Tim Streeto
Music
James Murphy
Screenplay
Noah Baumbach, based on a story by Jennifer Jason Leigh and Noah Baumbach
Director of Photography
Harris Savides

Review

Having had considerable critical success with his earlier The Squid And The Whale and Margot At The Wedding, even if neither exactly shattered box-office records even at the pokiest arthouses, director and co-writer Noah Baumbach switches coasts from his regular New York milieu for Greenberg, co-written with co-star and real-life wife Jennifer Jason Leigh, setting his tale in a strangely idealised Los Angeles, but which revolves around his familiar themes of alienation and people being trapped in a state of stasis in both their professional and personal lives, ambition and long-term goals being vague and unformed, living instead for a bland meandering day-to-day existence. It is into this Roger Greenberg (Ben Stiller in a credible film for once) arrives, the brother of the owner of an impressive, sprawling house, and who is just getting over a nervous breakdown, his plan being to stay for six weeks, doing nothing in particular. A mass of neuroses and contradictions, which we know the script will eventually tease out for both Greenberg and the audience to confront, Roger also cannot drive, utterly fatal in Los Angeles, meaning Florence (Greta Gerwig - Hannah Takes The Stairs / Baghead), his brother's PA, reduced to checking in on the dog, has to take him everywhere and a tentative relationship grows between them, and their affair is as weird and disjointed as anything in Baumbach's other films. His life goes yet further off the rails after an attempted reconciliation with an ex (JJ Leigh), who is now a mother, and a meeting with an old friend, Ivan (Rhys Ifans), a British former band member who seems to have ditched the booze and drugs, and his meeting with Ivan gets Roger back on the substances he had dumped years previously. All this sounds grim but Baumbach directs with the sort of level and even pace which gives most events the same emotional gravity, from the mundane to the provocative, and Stiller is effective as the man in his forties who realises that he has largely squandered most of the opportunities in his life, either intentionally or accidentally, and has the slightly dazed look which certainly tags him as a survivor of something traumatic and realising he has absolutely no anchors in his life, no stability and nothing to cling on to. The presence of Greta Gerwig indicates the film's acknowledgement to the briefly in vogue 'mumblecore' sub-genre, even to the point of a small role for one of the Duplass brothers, almost the inventors of the form, and her performance here at times is almost impenetrable, Florence being a character who just seems to eventually react to anything which happens around her, never instigating anything herself, which will strike some as frighteningly realistic and others as essentially anti-narrative. The performances are certainly note-worthy, and while it is hard to sympathise with Roger and his actions, some of which seem heartlessly thoughtless, he is certainly believable. Greenberg, despite the box-office potential of Ben Stiller, seems as if it will once more play largely to Baumbach's already established audience, simply because it refuses to offer easy answers and happy, glib endings.