Film details

Crying with Laughter  2009

Film still

Cast

  • Malcolm Shields
  • Micaiah Dring
  • Niall Greig Fulton
  • Jo Hartley
  • Tom Jude
  • Laura Keenan
  • Andrew Neil
  • Alan Marsh
  • Grant O'Rourke
  • Olivia McEwan
  • Paul McCole

Synopsis

With Scottish filmmakers still trying to follow in the steps of Trainspotting, made a mere fourteen years ago, writer / director Justin Molotnikov is the latest to try to make a film which gets favourably compared to Danny Boyle's film, Crying With Laughter being a very dark comedy, focusing on Joey Frisk (Stephen McCole - TV's High Times), a coke-snorting stand-up Edinburgh comedian who seems to be on the verge of the great career break. His act is abrasive but a hit with audiences, but things take a turn for the sinister after he meets an old friend, Frank Archer (Malcolm Shields - Death Defying Acts), now working at a sauna. Frank likes reminding Joey of when they were at school together, and how Joey went to borstal for a spell after trying to burn down the headmaster's office. Joey thinks nothing of their meeting, working it into an anecdote to use in his act, ridiculing his friend's intimacy in a sauna, or as he puts it, a room full of naked men. Frank is in the audience, and is humiliated, but this is the catalyst for Joey's life to start to go desperately wrong, getting horrendously drunk and winding up arrested, having attacked his landlord. Thrown out of his flat and picked up for GBH, he truly has no memory of what has happened, and when no one else will put him up, he ends up in Frank's expensive and inherited house, which is exactly as Frank wanted, since now he can put the rest of his plan into action. With touches which seem rather strangely like the two-hander Sleuth at times, and walking an uneasy path between black comedy and horrific psychological drama, as Frank turns the screws on his former friend, getting him further and further involved in truly bizarre and disturbing pranks and games, including bringing him face to face once more with the headmaster whose office he immolated, now senile and barely cognisant, but still a part of Frank's overall scheme. Critics have pointed out that the director uses a wraparound structure, with Joey telling the story as one of his own on-stage anecdotes, which adds a certain layer of doubt to what the audience is watching, but was also used in the inexplicably over-praised Seinfeld, and although there is a certain unevenness of tone, veering between the daftly humorous and the truly sinister, Molotnikov apparently uses the Edinburgh locations well, and this is certainly a calling card for things to come.

Production

Director
Justin Molotnikov
Producer
Alistair Clark, Claire Mundell and Rachel Robey
Art Director
Mike McLoughlin
Editor
Gary Scott
Music
Lorne Balfe
Screenplay
Justin Molotnikov
Director of Photography
Martin Radich

Review

With some Scottish filmmakers still trying to follow in the steps of Trainspotting, made fourteen years ago, writer / director Justin Molotnikov is the latest to try to make a film in the style of Danny Boyle's hugely successful endeavour, mixing very dark comedy with edgy drama and outright horror at points, Crying With Laughter focusing on Joey Frisk (Stephen McCole - TV's High Times), a coke-snorting stand-up Edinburgh comedian who seems to be on the verge of his great career break. His act is abrasive but a hit with audiences, but things take a turn for the sinister after he meets an old friend, Frank Archer (Malcolm Shields - Death Defying Acts), in a sauna, Frank seemingly enjoying reminding Joey of when they were at school together, and how Joey went to borstal for a spell after trying to burn down the school. Joey thinks nothing of their meeting, but this is the catalyst for Joey's life to start to go desperately wrong, getting horrendously drunk and winding up arrested, having attacked his landlord, he is evicted and then picked up for GBH, and when no one else will put him up, he ends up in Frank's expensive and inherited house, which is exactly as Frank wanted, since now he can put the rest of his plan into action. With touches which seem rather strangely like the two-hander stage play Sleuth at times, and walking an uneasy path between black comedy and horrific psychological drama, as Frank turns the screws on his former friend, getting him further involved in truly bizarre and disturbing pranks and games, which threaten to take the film into very different territory from where it begun, and also making the audience believe that Justin Molotnikov was certainly making notes which he was watching Park Chan-Wook's Lady Vengeance, including bringing him face to face once more with who is seemingly his tormentor, the headmaster whose office he immolated, now senile and barely cognisant, but still a part of Frank's overall scheme. Unfortunately the real danger and potential suspense of the situation is immediately defused by the structure of the piece, since Joey, a little battered and ragged around the edges, is telling the story on stage, recounting the events of the past few days, making the audience immediately realise that whatever happens he escapes relatively unscathed, or making them perhaps wonder at the veracity of what they have been told, and that some or perhaps none of the story is real. Despite it seeming that Frank's plan is going to leave one or maybe more people dead, that Joey is alive and cracking his barbed gags on stage shows that whoever the victims may be, he isn't one of them. Although there is a definite unevenness of tone, veering between the darkly humorous and the truly sinister, Molotnikov uses the Edinburgh locations well, but if the film could decide what it actually wants to be, and make Joey's stage act a little more convincing, then the balance of comedy, suspense, and threatened genuine horror could be more successful.