Cast
-
Emma Stone
-
-
-
Amanda Byrns
-
Cam Gigandet
-
-
Penn Badgley
-
-
-
Dan Byrd
-
Alyson Michalka
-
Stacey Travis
Synopsis
High-schooler Olive Penderghast attends a school in a small Californian town, and in order to avoid going on a camping trip with her friend Rhiannon invents a date for the weekend. Back at school, and just for devilment, Olive embroiders the story so that it becomes a weekend of forbidden passion with an older lover, her story being overheard by another student, Marianne, who quickly spreads the gossip which soon goes through the whole school, Olive being at first surprised then amused by her sudden fame, or infamy. Brandon, a fellow student, tells her that her reputation is now so utterly tarnished that they should tell all their friends they had sex, so that it might stop the homophobic bullying Brandon is subjected to. Olive agrees, but soon finds that she is approached by more and more of the school's misfits and outsiders, all wanting to claim a relationship with her in order to give them cachet among their own bands and cliques. Olive's parents Dill and Rosemary hear of her reputation and the rumours about her but are unconcerned, but her favourite teacher, Mr. Griffiths, under whom her class are studying Nathanial Hawthorne's classic novel The Scarlet Letter, the heroine of which, Hester Prynne, finds herself vilified by scandal and rumour, becomes concerned, sending her to see his wife, who is also the school's guidance counsellor, and who gives Olive several packets of condoms. Shocked and outraged at what she has heard about her, Marianne, a staunch Evangelical Christian, mounts a campaign of moral disapproval against Olive, branding her a 'scarlet woman', even Rhiannon joining the campaign, although Woodchuck Todd, the first boy Olive ever has a crush on, does not, and refuses to have anything to do with Marianne and her campaign. Marianne is shocked when her boyfriend is diagnosed with the sexual disease chlamydia, which he claims to have caught from Olive, nobody knowing that Olive is still a virgin, and everything which has been said about her is pure fantasy. Olive discovers just who infected him, and realises that it is information which could cause a lot of damage were it to become known, so decides to accept the blame in order to preserve the feelings and emotions of others, but also realises that this has already gone far too far, and has to devise some sort of strategy to somehow restore her reputation.
Production
- Director
- Will Gluck
- Producer
- Zanne Devine and Will Gluck
- Art Director
- Bo Johnson
- Editor
- Yana Gortskaya and Susan Littenberg
- Music
- Brad Segal
- Screenplay
- Bert V. Royal
- Director of Photography
- Michael Grady
Review
An ambitious concept, the reworking of the basics of an 1850 novel The Scarlet Letter by Nathanial Hawthorne on a US high school campus, is the central idea behind this deceptively clever comedy, which actually can't fall into the lazy rom-com classification, with some decidedly dramatic edges, with Emma Stone (Zombieland) as the central character, Olive Penderghast, a virginal high school student who is surprised when she finds that a rumour she began herself about spending a weekend with her much older lover spreads like wildfire through he campus. Knowing of the novel, she sees herself as parallelling the character of Hester Prynne in Hawthorne's work, which her class is conveniently studying, she realises that it brings her notoriety in such a hidebound college, and she starts to use it to her advantage, managing to put the school's more puritanical teachers, who see her as immoral, against their more understanding counterparts, but also finds that it makes her popular by association, kids who want to be in the cool clique wanting to be known to be her friends, and taken to an interesting reversal when one of her classmates wants to be included in her 'legend' since it will stop the homophobic bullying against him. It's certainly an ambitious idea, especially the idea that a lot of US high school students, essentially the target audience, would actually know of The Scarlet Letter in the first place, and debuting screenplay writer Bert V. Royal seems to delight in bizarre names, with characters including Olive's father, Dill Penderghast (Stanley Tucci - The Lovely Bones), and Penn Badgley (TV's Gossip Girl) as Olive's fellow student Woodchuck Todd, but despite the slightly forced oddness there is a solid and surprisingly intricate plot at its' core, particularly when Olive's falsifications and inventions lead to the threatened exposure of a genuine affair, and one involving the least expected characters. The idea may be farcical but Royal also has the confidence to make this actually serious, having genuine consequences should it become common knowledge. An interestingly varied supporting cast includes Thomas Haden Church (Sideways / Spider-Man 3), ex-Friends Lisa Kudrow, Patricia Clarkson (Shutter Island) as her mother Rosemary (married to Dill, geddit), and the always watchable Malcolm McDowell as the uptight School Principle Gibbons, but the film very much belongs to lead Emma Stone, who apparently took the role after several other teen actresses passed on it, also turning down Zack Snyder's Sucker Punch in order to do this much lower-budgeted, smaller scale pic. Stone makes Olive believable and extremely entertaining, using a variation of Hawthorne's 'brand of shame', the scarlet letter 'A', standing in the book for 'Adulterer', as a badge of pride, embroidering one onto her tops and proudly showing it off, a celebration to some and a provocation to others, and when Olive finds herself involved in events far beyond what she ever envisaged, its' not difficult to feel sympathy for her for a harmless fib which spirals way out of control. Will Gluck, making his second feature, after the crude and rather lame Fired Up, helms, making a far better job out of this campus comedy than his initial offering, and one has to give it top marks for ambition (how many other teen rom-coms have such firm literary connections?), it is the very able Emma Stone who got all the good reviews and made the pic one of the better reviewed pics of the summer period.