Film details

Burke and Hare  2010

Cast

Synopsis

1828, and Ulstermen William Burke and William Hare are in Edinburgh, selling a supposedly efficacious 'Donegal moss' to the gullible, it in fact being mould pared off cheese until their scam is discovered and they only just escape with their lives when chased. Returning home, Hare finds from his drunken wife, Lucky, that their lodger, an elderly man called Donald, has died. Hare hears that two surgeons at the local medical college, Drs. Robert Knox and Alex Munro, are paying for good quality cadavers for dissection, £5 each, and he and Burke put the body in a barrel and take it to the college, where Dr. Knox pays them, and promises the same for any more they should deliver. Believing all they have to do is dig up graves, the pair are interrupted in the cemetery late at night by Captain McLintock, head of the local militia, but the pair have another idea for securing a body, turning to another elderly lodger, Joseph, and accelerating his demise. Spending their new-found wealth in a tavern, Burke becomes captivated by Ginny Hawkins, a prostitute with ambitions to become an actress, and becomes determine d to stage her idea for an all-female production of Macbeth. Wanting more money, and starting to see everybody in the street late at night as a potential victim, the pair start to try to snare random victims, failing several times, including tangling with a drunk who seems virtually indestructible, but an obese man does of fright when they advance on him from the shadows. Their lucrative sideline is noticed by street gang boss Danny McTavish, who demands half their earnings in order to remain 'in business'. With the King about to visit the city, an announcement is made that the most beneficial advance in medical science will be feted, pitting Knox and Munro against each other, Knox plans to 'map the human anatomy' with the help of Nicephore, a French photographer, and tells Burke and Hare he will be requiring two cadavers a week from them in order to do so. Burke tells Ginny that he will back her production, just as McTavish tells the pair that he is going into partnership with them, which does not please his other gang members, and McTavish soon becomes the next corpse Burke and Hare deliver to Dr. Knox. Ginny's Macbeth is staged, and is surprisingly a triumph, but Captain McLintock has started to suspect Dr. Knox may be involved in something suspicious, just as the Doctor is about to present his photographs, the first taken of the insides of the human body, to the King, but McLintock seizes them as evidence. Burke and Hare are arrested, as are Ginny and Lucky, but the medical authorities are keen that their reputation should go unsullied, and for one half of the partnership of Burke and Hare, they are about to find that there is no such thing as honour among thieves, or murderers.

Production

Director
John Landis
Producer
Barnaby Thompson
Art Director
Nick Dent
Editor
Mark Everson
Music
Joby Talbot
Screenplay
Piers Ashworth and Nick Moorcroft
Director of Photography
John Mathieson

Review

The real-life case of body-snatchers, or 'resurrectionists', William Burke and William Hare, who provided bodies for the anatomist Dr. Robert Knox in Edinburgh, murdering at least seventeen people during a ten month spell during 1827-28, has actually hit the screen several times before, either naming the characters as themselves, in 1960's The Flesh And The Fiends, briefly in Hammer's Dr. Jekyll And Sister Hyde, and 1971's black comedy Burke & Hare, as well as inspiring 1945's The Body Snatcher, with Boris Karloff and Bela Lugosi, and 1985's The Doctor And The Devils, a rather more serious version of the tale, based on an unproduced Dylan Thomas script. This time around its' a black comedy spin on the undeniably dark tale, with Simon Pegg and Andy Sirkis as the eponymous characters, getting into the body-selling business after a sick tenant dies under the roof of the tenement block where Burke lives, and knowing of the shortage of bodies to be dissected in front of anatomy students by Dr. Knox (Tom Wilkinson - Rush Hour / In The Bedroom), sold the body to him, earning, it is believed, £6/10 for it, or £6.50 in today's coin, a considerable amount, but since people conveniently dying were in short supply, Burke and Hare went into the murder business, supplying men and women, mostly from the lower levels of Edinburgh society at the time, which was pretty desperate, but at least the money went up, getting between £8-10 a stiff, er, cadaver. A definite upturn in the recent career of John Landis, who hasn't made a feature since 1998's barely-seen Susan's Plan, the script, by Piers Ashworth and Nick Moorcroft, announces at the beginning that it is a true story, then admitting that some of it isn't, and Landis' instance that this is the most accurate telling of the tale is quite palpably false, although it does at least have them as broad Ulstermen, with the requisite equally wide accents, which some may strive to decode at times, and being played by Pegg and Sirkis, the latter replacing David Tennant who had to drop out through scheduling clashes, makes them inevitably the heroes of the piece, being portrayed almost as little more than cheeky scamps when in actuality they were a grubby and venal pair of murderers. Landis is obviously having fun, and the pic is as usual studded with cameos, including a reunion for American Werewolf In London stars Jenny Agutter, John Woodvine, and David Schofield, one of the most alarmed dart players in The Slaughtered Lamb pub in the beginning of the pic, and such impressive names as Ricky Gervais' oppo Stephen Merchant, Jessica Hynes (opposite Pegg for the first time since TV's Spaced), the excellent Hugh Bonneville (TV's Hunter), Bill Bailey (who looks sort of Victorian and Edinburgian), as well as those who are pretty much in-jokes for the true film buff, such as Ray Harryhausen and director Costa-Gavras (really), and on a slightly sadder note Robert Paynter, the DoP of American Werewolf and who died before Burke And Hare opened, but its' an uneasy mix, some surprising gore and flashes of vicious violence being tempered with jokes both clever and smart and rather heavy and laboured, although Ronnie Corbett is surprisingly good as the determined militia Captain. The story of Burke and Hare has often confused filmmakers who haven't known how to approach it, as ribald black comedy or very dark drama, and Landis, like many, tries both, which makes for a watchable comedy with grim edges, but is somehow another missed opportunity.