Film details

Whatever Works  2009

Cast

  • Larry David
  • Evan Rachel Wood
  • Ed Begley Jr.
  • Michael McKean
  • Henry Cavill
  • Jessica Hecht
  • Samantha Bee
  • Adam Brooks
  • Conleth Hill
  • John Gallagher Jr
  • Olek Krupa

Synopsis

Opening in the UK over a year after its' US release, Whatever Works is yet another of the films in Woody Allen's unbelievably inconsistent recent filmography, and by and large squanders the goodwill which some felt towards his previous Vicky Christina Barcelona, with some critics calling it one of the misjudged in his filmography, mostly due to the casting of Larry David (TV's Curb Your Enthusiasm) as the lead character, who spends large sections of the film ranting directly to camera about the injustices he feels the world has heaped upon him in every field from love to chance and what links them, quantum physics, which many scribes attested gets very grating, very quick. Originally a script Allen wrote over thirty years ago, intended to star Zero Mostel, he has now blown the dust off to have David plays the lead, Boris Yellnikov, a New Yorker who is trying to justify his own existence, and that of everybody else in the world, hence the long rambling disquisitions to camera, but whose abrasive nature softens slightly when he lets a young runaway, Melody St. Ann Celestine (Evan Rachel Wood - The Wrestler) stay in his apartment (and this is where the alarm bells start ringing, given Allen's previous). He sees it as a chance to teach her his philosophy, which seems to boil down to when it comes to love 'whatever works' is what he lives by, and by this time the audience will be getting well uncomfortable, and so they should since, despite their forty-year age difference the pair marry. Yes, you read that correctly. Of course when Melody's Bible-punching mother Marietta (Patricia Clarkson - Lars And The Real Girl) finds out where she is and come looking for her, she is shocked by what she finds, and passes out on the doorstep. Of course Marietta's is soon seduced by Boris' charm (no, really) and the city of New York itself, as is Melody's father (Christopher Guest regular Ed Begley Jr.), when he finally turns up on the doorstep, armed. Of course Boris is less than pleased when Melody starts seeing a younger man, Randy (Henry Cavill - TV's The Tudors), Boris being forced to admit that it is a relationship which won't need Viagra, and if that isn't the point where the audience finally walk out we'd be surprised. Although some have admitted that some of Boris' long and shouted rants have some smart lines, David's personality does little to really make his character particularly likable, and the same old Allen obsessions with women young enough to be his granddaughter surface yet again, almost as if the filmmaker was taunting the viewer with them. Another Allen flop, taking just over $5 million in the US against a budget of over $15m, his first film shot in New York in more than five years, is just another entry in a CV which gets more disappointing and more disturbing the further it progresses.

Production

Director
Woody Allen
Producer
Letty Aronson and Stephen Tenenbaum
Art Director
Tom Warren
Editor
Alisa Lepselter
Music
Various
Screenplay
Woody Allen
Director of Photography
Harris Savides

Review

Opening in the UK over a year after its' US release, Whatever Works is yet another of the films in Woody Allen's unbelievably inconsistent recent filmography, and by and large squanders the goodwill which some felt towards his previous Vicky Christina Barcelona, with some critics calling it one of the most misjudged in his career, mostly due to the casting of Larry David (TV's Curb Your Enthusiasm) as the lead character, who spends large sections of the film ranting directly to camera about the injustices he feels the world has heaped upon him in every field from love to chance and what links them, quantum physics, which becomes very grating, very quickly. Originally a script Allen wrote over thirty-five years ago, intended to star Zero Mostel, he has now blown the dust off to have David play the lead, Boris Yellnikov, a New Yorker who is trying to justify his own existence, and that of everybody else in the world, hence the long rambling disquisitions to camera, but whose abrasive nature softens slightly when he lets a young runaway, Melody St. Ann Celestine (Evan Rachel Wood - The Wrestler) stay in his apartment (and this is where the alarm bells start ringing, given Allen's previous). He sees it as a chance to teach her his philosophy, which seems to boil down to when it comes to love 'whatever works' is what he lives by, and by this time the audience will be getting well uncomfortable, and so they should since, despite their forty-year age difference the pair marry. Yes, you read that correctly. Of course when Melody's Bible-punching mother Marietta (Patricia Clarkson - Lars And The Real Girl) finds out where she is and comes looking for her, she is shocked by what she finds, and passes out on the doorstep. Of course Marietta is soon seduced by Boris' charm (no, really) and the city of New York itself, as is Melody's father (Christopher Guest regular Ed Begley Jr.), when he finally turns up on the doorstep, both won over by the bohemian city, Marietta living in a menange a trois, and John finding his true nature after a night at a gay bar. Of course Boris is less than pleased when Melody starts seeing a younger man, Randy (Henry Cavill - TV's The Tudors), Boris being forced to admit that is a relationship which won't need Viagra, all of which comes across as the daydreams of a smutty-minded adolescent, and Allen's claims to have originally written it back in the Sixties shows that it was either the first of his disturbing age-gap fantasies, or that particular syndrome goes back very far indeed. As Allen was largely writing stage plays in the Sixties, Whatever Works can be seen very much as a stage-bound two-act play, being actually limited in locations and very much breaking conveniently into two halve, pre- and post-marriage, Boris' speeches being essentially monologues delivered directly to the audience, but David's sour and crabby personality does little to really make his character particularly likable, and the same old Allen obsessions with women young enough to be his granddaughter surface yet again, almost as if the filmmaker is taunting the viewer with them. Another Allen flop, taking just over $5 million in the US against a budget of over $15m, his first film shot in New York in more than five years, is just another entry in a CV which gets more disappointing and more disturbing the further it progresses.