Cast
-
John C. Reilly
-
-
-
-
Matt Walsh
-
Tim Guinee
-
Kathryn Aselton
-
Jamie Donnelly
-
Kellan Rhude
-
Zosia Mamet
-
Steve Zissis
-
Kathy Whittes
Synopsis
John is a divorcee in Los Angeles, in his forties and working as a film editor, he is still utterly emotionally dependent on his ex-wife, Jamie, and also still believes there is a chance of reconciliation, only to be crushed when she tells him she is remarrying. Overweight and unkempt, as well as emotionally fragile, John believes that he will never find anybody else, Jamie and her fiancee, Tim, insist on taking John to a party, where his attempts to chat up women are disastrous, and he finds himself emotionally unspooling to a male guest how he is looking for someone to be honest with, only to find himself self being approached by an attractive woman, Molly, the two getting on together very well. But Molly insists on not staying at John's apartment, insisting she has to get home, although she will not explain why, John believing she may have some sort of pet which needs to be taken care of. When John surreptitiously follows her back to her home he finds she has a son in his twenties, and when he engineers a meeting between the three of them he finds the boy, Cyrus, is totally manipulative and demanding, and obviously unwilling to share his mother's affections with anybody else, John finding the closeness of their relationship, and Cyrus' emotional domination of his mother worrying, and the two find themselves battling for Molly's affections, with Cyrus making no attempt to disguise his intention to win and drive John out of their lives. Cyrus' attempts to break up his mother's relationship are crass and obvious, and he tries to raise the stakes by moving out of their home, which gives John to opportunity to movie in, but Cyrus returns, trying to gain sympathy by claiming he is incapable of looking after himself, and has been suffering panic attacks. Finally unable to take the situation nay more, John accused Cyrus of coldly manipulating his mother, telling Molly who he son is using her, but she seems oblivious to his claims. The battle between the two reaches a pinnacle at Jamie's wedding, where John and Cyrus go head-to-head, ending in a physical fight, but Molly still refuses to see the control Cyrus has over her, forcing John to end their relationship, and for the first time in his life Cyrus starts to feels pangs of conscience.
Production
- Director
- Jay Duplass and Mark Duplass
- Producer
- Michael Costigan
- Art Director
- Anne Spitz
- Editor
- Jay Deuby
- Music
- Michael Andrews
- Screenplay
- Jay Duplass and Mark Duplass
- Director of Photography
- Jas Shelton
Review
Certainly one of the more interesting and less indulgent creative teams to come out of the briefly fashionable 'mumblecore' sub-genre, the Duplass brothers, responsible for such well received but zero-budget productions as The Puffy Chair and Baghead, go relatively mainstream, with a piece produced by Ridley and Tony Scott's Scott Free Productions, of all people, the very antithesis of the brothers Duplass in filmmaking size and scale, but the Duplass brothers intriguingly make a film which is only slightly different from what they have been associated with previously, in style and form. Although having some very impressive names in the cast, including John C. Reilly (Chicago), Catherine Keener (Capote), Marisa Tomei (My Cousin Vinny) and the tiresomely ubiquitous Jonah Hill (Superbad / Funny People), the script, penned as usual by the brothers, has all the hallmarks of their rather uncomfortable and painful sense of humour, with Reilly as the uncomfortably convincing John, a man whose social life has ground to a halt, a divorcee of seven years trying to cope with the impending marriage of his ex-wife, but who finally thinks his life has changed when he meets Molly (Tomei) at a party and believes she is the perfect woman and the relationship between the two is immediate Wanting to know what is being kept secret, and why she will only ever visit his apartment, and then never stay the night, he follows her home only to discover she has a twenty-one year old son, Cyrus (Hill), and the two have an oddly close relationship, more like affectionate friends than mother and son, and John soon sees that Cyrus is jealous and possessive to a quite disturbing degree, and is determined not to share his mother with anybody, especially not John, and the battle lines are drawn. Although in some ways having similarities with the Will Ferrell comedy Step Brothers, which also featured the fascinatingly weathered Reilly, this is a far more uncomfortable concept for a comedy, with Hill, whose unnervingly infantile features and steadily increasing girth are actually making him a very uncomfortable screen presence, making Cyrus himself a truly creepy creation, a definite and strangely sexual threat, and although the brothers may now be shooting on a bigger budget than they have ever known, this is still a low-budget and unsettling piece of work which eventually cannot decide whether it is an all-out comedy or something really more troubling, and an unexpectedly upbeat ending seems ill-fitting. The Duplass brothers may have gone slightly more mainstream, but their material certainly hasn't.