Cast
-
-
Amanda Peet
-
-
-
Anne Guilbert
-
Sarah Steele
-
Thomas Ian Nicholas
-
-
Elizabeth Berridge
-
Lois Smith
-
Scott Cohen
-
Maddie Corman
Synopsis
The films of writer and director Nicole Holofcener, Walking And Talking, Lovely & Amazing and Friends With Money, can all certainly be identified as the work of the same filmmaker, being relationship dramas, shot though with a thick vein of often quite dark comedy, and which are actually fair minded in the treatment of their characters, be they caught up in relationship problems of their own causing, or only just realising how bad a parent they have been over their now adult child's lifetime. New York-born Holofcener returns to her home city, with the excellent Catherine Keener, who has appeared in all of the director's films so far, playing Kate, a successful business woman running a vintage furniture and accessories shop, the bohemian inhabitants of her borough liking the various objet d'art she finds at rummage sales and deceased tenant apartment clearances which she then heftily marks up. Although married to Alex (the very fine Oliver Platt - Lake Placid / 2012), and having a teenage daughter, Abby (Sarah Steele - TV's Law And Order), Kate feels guilt not only at her relationships, wondering if she could do better in both, but in the fact that they are successful and wealthy when there is literally poverty on her doorstep, she seeing the poor and the homeless everyday. Her next door neighbours are an elderly and extremely cantankerous woman, Andra (TV veteran Ann Guilbert), and the two granddaughters who look after her, Mary (Amanda Peet - Identity / TV's Studio 60 At The Sunset Strip) and Rebecca (Rebecca Hall - The Prestige), Kate and Alex have managed to buy their apartment, in order to turn it into a separate space for Abby, but before they can do that Andra has to die, she living there until then as per the terms of their contract. Holofcener's film doesn't stoop to the pair knocking off the abrasive and unlikable Andra, but instead focuses on how the two families interact, all of them being very different personalities, and the film revolves about just how far some people will go with others, an example being Mary becoming especially close to Alex, in all spheres of life, from romance to cold, hard business, and how plain guilt can make some people make very bad decisions. Not everybody is going to sympathise with Holofcener's characters or the problems in which they find themselves, but she is a filmmaker whose scripts actually have the audience seeing the pros and cons on both sides of any argument, and she always gets fine performances from her talented casts.
Production
- Director
- Nicole Holofcener
- Producer
- Anthony Bregman
- Art Director
- Robert Frazen
- Editor
- Lauren Fitzsimmons
- Music
- Marcelo Zarvos
- Screenplay
- Nicole Holofcener
- Director of Photography
- Yaron Orbach
Review
The films of writer and director Nicole Holofcener, Walking And Talking, Lovely & Amazing and Friends With Money, can all certainly be identified as the work of the same filmmaker, being relationship dramas, shot through with a thick vein of often quite dark comedy, and which are actually surprisingly fair minded in the treatment of their characters, be they caught up in relationship problems of their own causing, or only just realising how bad a parent they have been over their now adult child's lifetime. New York-both Holofcener returns to her home city, for Please Give, a story which tries to blend several themes but dwelling on the guilt of the affluent, seen here in the 'plight; of Kate and Alex, whose business is successful through their purchase of antique furniture from the families of those who have recently died, and yet despite her success Kate is constantly struck by the homeless who are literally outside her door, and in a case of true avarice even wants the apartment next door, not being content with just one impressive and highly desirable home. The excellent Catherine Keener, who has appeared in all of the director's films so far, plays Kate, the bohemian inhabitants of her borough liking the various object d'art she finds at rummage sales and deceased tenant apartment clearances which she then heftily marks up. Married to Alex (the very fine Oliver Platt - Lake Placid / 2012), and having a teenage daughter, Abby (Sarah Steele - TV's Law And Order), her next door neighbour is an elderly and extremely cantankerous women, Andra (TV veteran Ann Guilbert), she having two granddaughters, Mary (Amanda Peet - Identity / TV's Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip) and Rebecca (the superb Rebecca Hall - The Prestige), she being the only one who visits her granny regularly. When it becomes clear Kate and Alex want the apartment, a strange and uncomfortable false friendship is forged, being taken further when Alex and Mary begin an affair. Holofcener's film doesn't stoop to the pair knocking off the abrasive and unlikable Andra, but instead focuses on how the two families interact, all of them being very different personalities, and the film revolves about just how far some people will go with others, and how plain guilt can make some people make very bad decisions. Not everybody is going to sympathise with Holofcener's characters, considering the comfortable lives most of them have, or the problems in which they find themselves, and but she is a filmmaker whose scripts actually have the audience seeing the pros and cons on both sides of any argument, and she always gets fine performances from her talented casts.