Cast
-
-
Jason Bateman
-
Patrick Wilson
-
-
-
Caroline Dhavemas
-
Kelli Barrett
-
Scott Elrod
-
Todd Louiso
-
Thomas Robinson
-
Erica Thomas
-
Rebecca Naomi Jones
Synopsis
Single New Yorker Kassie Larson tells her platonic best friend Wally Mars that she wants to have a baby, and has decided to opt for artificial insemination in the absence of a Mr. Right, asking him to help her find a suitable donor. He expresses his doubts about her decision, mainly because he is offended that she hasn't asked him herself. They agree not to talk about it, she realising Wally is uncomfortable with the subject, and he is surprised to be invited several weeks later to a 'pregnancy party', where Wally is very uncomfortable to be introduced to Roland, the married man who is to be Kassie's donor, and due to give the required sample, in private, that night, and to add to Wally's discomfort is Wally's boss at work. When alcohol mixes with the tranquilliser his friend Debbie gave him to keep him calm and emotionally stable, Wally gets very drunk, and while stumbling around in the bathroom accidentally knocks over the specimen jar with draught Roland in it, replacing the contents with his own, hastily summoned up, deposit. Kassie soon finds she is pregnant, and moves out of the city. Seven years pass and she returns to the city with her son, Sebastian, who has a strong resemblance to Wally. Meeting Roland, now divorced, once more, Kassie starts to date him. Having met Sebastian for the first time, Wally feels distinctly uneasy, spotting the resemblance, and the strange way he seems to be very much like him, then with utter horror remembers his drunken accident and what he did to rectify it. Believing that Sebastian is his son, and that Kassie is unaware of this, Wally becomes wracked by guilt, wondering whether or not he should tell her, and realising his hand is being forced when Kassie tells him to come to a dinner party, where Roland is going to propose to her. With a heavy heart, and knowing that he is going to have to tell her everything, and to confess that he is in love with her, and has been for years, Wally gets ready for a very difficult evening, but he isn't ready for just what is going to happen...
Production
- Director
- Josh Gordon and Will Speck
- Producer
- Albert Berger and Ron Yerxa
- Art Director
- Larry Gruber and Richard Johnson
- Editor
- John Axelrad
- Music
- Alex Wurman
- Screenplay
- Allan Loeb, based on the short story Baster by Jeffrey Eugenides
- Director of Photography
- Jess Hall
Review
A concept which sounds so initially remarkably tasteless that one wonders why the producers didn't go with the far more direct original title - The Baster - since it doesn't seem that taste is one of their big considerations here, being a decidedly odd comedy, one hesitates in calling it a rom-com, which seems to be yet another bizarre career choice from Jennifer Aniston who, after the blessed demise of TV's Friends, seemed to be the one who would go onto the be the most successful of all the irritating sextet, and after initial success and terrific notices in Miguel Arteta's 2002 comedy / drama The Good Girl, has opted for unchallenging comedies, usually getting decent enough box-office but occasionally making duds such as The Bounty Hunter. The original title referred to what Aniston character Kassie Larson is forced to turn to in order to fulfil her dream of having a baby, she being unmarried and planning to go the AID (artificial insemination by donor) route, and in a truly woeful plot contrivance, having her best friend Wally (Jason Bateman - TV's Arrested Development) upset the - er - sample to be, how do we put this, administered, he getting drunk at the 'pregnancy party' she throws, the supplier of the baby gravy being there as well in the form of a miscast Jeff Goldblum (The Fly), but all this goes to show what remarkably hard work the writers have to do to actually establish the plot twist, that Wally replaces it with his own, then conveniently, forgets, such is his state of bladderation, which makes one wonder just how he managed to get the starting handle turning. Fast-forward seven years and Wally and Kassie meet up for the first time since the birth of her son, who weirdly seems to have a lot of his own personal traits and habits, leading him to horrifyingly remember the events of that very drunken night, and exactly what he put in that little pot, and start to suspect that the kid is his, but does he tell Kassie or not? Heavily sold as a Jennifer Aniston comedy in the US, where it flopped most horribly, The Switch is actually a very different film from how it was originally being sold, focusing more on Bateman's character for a start, and there is a strange discomfort once he meets the seven-year-old Sebastian (young Bryce Robinson, obviously cast because of his resemblance to Bateman but also managing to put across some of his mannerisms and gestures), and the film becomes the story of Wally and his terrible secret, and whether or not to tell the mother who believes the father of her baby is the now-divorced Richard, the fact that he is about to propose to Kassie at a dinner party only making his dilemma all the more acute and actually strangely moving. Co-directors Josh Gordon and Will Speck (Blades Of Glory) certainly have talent to spare with the likes of Patrick Wilson (Watchmen), Juliette Lewis (Strange Days) as Wally's female friend Debbie, and actor and director Todd Louiso (High Fidelity) in support, but the sheer idea of this is going to make a some people feel queasy indeed and selling it as a warm and fuzzy Aniston rom-com is just being dishonest to a strangely brave script which certainly isn't an unqualified success but has enough unexpected angles to keep an audience very intrigued.