Cast
-
Tariq Ali
-
Raul Castro
-
Hugo Chavez
-
'Lula' (Luiz Ignacio Lula Da Silva)
-
Rafael Correa
-
Cristina Kirchner
-
Nestor Kirchner
-
Fernando Lugo
-
Evo Morales
Synopsis
Filmmaker Oliver Stone goes to Venezuela in order to make a film about President Hugo Chavez, claiming it will balance the attacks on him in the American media, led by Rupert Murdoch's right-wing Fox News and News Corporation empire. A brief re-cap of recent Venezuelan history covering the last thirty years is given, how in 1992 Hugo Chavez, then a young military officer, was part of an attempted coup to overthrow President Perez. When the coup failed Chavez was given two years in prison, emerging to enter politics, being elected President in 1997, promising to raise living standards, and broaden democracy, casting himself in the role of a modern-day Simon Bolivar, the national icon regarded as the liberator of South America by historians. An anti-Chavez coup in 2002 was backed with the approval of the Bush government, but the new government was overturned by popular protest and Chavez reinstated. Stone spends time with Chavez, accompanying him on a visit to his grandmother's home and being with him on a public walkabout, addressing several meetings. Believing Chavez is spearheading a new political movement throughout South America, Stone then travels through the continent, interviewing the leaders of several states, including Brazil's popularist leader Luiz Ignacio Lula Da Silva, or Lula, Raul Castro, Fidel's bother, assuming control in Cuba after his ailing brother Fidel, the subject of Stone's 2003 's documentary Comandante, Bolivia's Evo Morales, and Cristina Kitrschner of Argentina, who Stone seems to question about shoes and fashion rather then political matters, seeming to treat her husband, former President Nestor Morales, more seriously. They all express a feeling that the countries of South American should try to put aside their differences, and will eventually be able to do without US aid and assistance, most claiming their countries are being held back by the demands of both the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, who have imposed severe conditions on the massive loans made to the various regimes. Chavez saying he sees the election of Barack Obama as an indication that relations between the North and the South will soon improve.
Production
- Director
- Oliver Stone
- Producer
- Jose Ibanez. Oliver Stone, Fernando Sullchin and Robert S. Wilson
- Art Director
- Not credited
- Editor
- Elisa Bonora and Alexis Chavez
- Music
- Adam Peters
- Screenplay
- Mark Weisbrot, Oliver Stone and Tariq Ali
- Director of Photography
- Lucas Fuica, Carlos Marcovich and Albert Maysles
Review
Following up 2003's Comandante, his fawning feature-length documentary concerning Fidel Castro, which flirted with being quite grovellingly sycophantic, Oliver Stone claims that South Of The Border is a corrective to the corrosive fabrications and personal attacks launched on Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez by such American media as, but not limited to, Fox News and News Corporation, but his presentation is as droolingly pliant and worshipping as Fox as aggressive and caustic, the first part of the film, Stone following Chavez, who is not exactly sparky company, like a particularly devoted lapdog, laughing on cue at slightest quip, refusing to follow up any questions which Chavez either swats aside or simply ignores, and whose first actions in office were to change the constitution to make himself Presidente for life, and then clamping down on the media and shutting down any outlet which showed the slightest dissent, and his sabre-rattling and threats of invasion and war against neighbouring Columbia are also conveniently ignored. Stone also shamefully refuses to mention the fact that since Chavez's election over two hundred journalists and broadcasters have been killed in the country according to several anti-censorship bodies, and the deaths remain unsolved, with no ongoing Police investigations. But Stone is too goo-goo eyed to follow any sort of hard questioning, to the point where you really felling like telling him to get a room, such is his unquestioning adoration. A BBC Hardtalk interview with Stone concerning the film had him squirming and also batting away any difficult questions on Chavez's record and his own unquestioning approach in the film, and his repeated attempts to change the subject when interviewer Stephen Sacker pressed him on such topics as the journalist murders were fascinating, since Stone in no way wanted to confront what was being asked. At halfway point he decides to turn South Of The Border into a wider documentary about the new generation of leaders in South America, most of which have been elected in the last five years, and of course sees nothing but glorious freedom fighters, interviewing seven heads of state who are a fascinatingly varied bunch, Fernando Lugo of Paraguay, Evo Morales of Bolivia, Rafael Correa of Ecuador, Cuba's Raul Castro and Brazil's Lula Di Silva, but his treatment of Cristina Kirchner of Argentina, as well as her husband and ex-President Nestor Kirchner, is nothing less than jaw-dropping, since he clearly sees her as some bimbo, her husband being the real power behind the throne, when any examination of the facts would show him that Mrs. Kirchner is a strong and very able politician on her own terms, Stone's obvious sexism, which he somehow sees as playful, being incredible since he seems oblivious of it, despite it revealing what he really seems to think about women in politics. He didn't ask his buddy Chavez about his stylish choice of army fatigues or that cool buzzcut, so why is that all he seems to ask Cristina Kirchner. Stone's premise is that there is a revolution happening throughout South America, which is about to turn it into an economic and political powerhouse, despite the fact that inter-colonial relations between several bordering countries are rarely anything less than tense, never mind the sort of united brotherhood he seems to imagine is on the way, Of course some of these have got their own problems at home, with Raul Castro being accused of an even bigger clampdown of human rights than his ailing brother, both Lula and Lugo being charged with massive corruption, both having been elected on anti-corruption tickets, and of course Chavez. More a gooey love letter than a considered documentary, at least when Stone was writing horror movies like Seizure and The Hand back in the late 70s he was writing fiction. Now he is falling for the fictions of others and peddling them as fact.