Cast
-
-
William Shinell
-
Jean-Claude Carriere
-
Agathe Natanson
-
Gianna Giachetti
-
Adrian Moore
-
Angelo Barbagallo
-
Andrea Laurenzi
-
Filippo Troiano
-
Manuela Balsimelli
Synopsis
The first film made outside Iran by director Abbas Kiarostami, and starring Juliette Binoche, who also appeared in the helmer's previous Shirin, Certified Copy surprised some critics, who saw the film in its' screenings at the 2010 Cannes Film Festival, at how surprisingly conventional a film it is, a love story set in rural Italy between British author James Miller (William Shennell, an opera singer making his first film appearance) and a woman known only as 'She' (Binoche). With a surprising resemblance to Richard Linklater's Before Sunset, Miller is presenting his latest work to a European audience, wit She being in the audience, and She arranges to meet him afterwards, at her antique shop which is filled with reproductions of valuable originals, before he catches his train to Tuscany. The pair start a strange sham-relationship, discussing the central concept revolving around the nature of originals and copies in both life and art, and whether if one can get a copy, should one want an original, or does it make the copy less valuable or real. Even going for a drive at one point, She offering to drive Miller later when he misses his train, the pair are even taken for a long-married couple, and one sees that Kiarostami is also incorporating large chunks of Roberto Rossellini's Voyage To Italy in the way the pair seem to fall into their ascribed roles. At no times do the pair become particularly sympathetic or likeable, and the film does essentially come to no firm conclusions, but is enlivened by some very fine photography of the Tuscan countryside by Luca Bigazzi (The Consequences Of Love / Romanzo Criminale), but in reading what a lot of the Cannes critics said it was very obvious that although many liked it on an aesthetic level, it was overall a disappointment given the opportunities offered to the helmer outside his native country for the first time.
Production
- Director
- Abbas Kiarostami
- Producer
- Marin Karmitz, Nathaniel Karmitz, Charles Gilibert and Angelo Barbagallo
- Art Director
- Giancarlo Basili and Ludovica Ferrario
- Editor
- Bahman Kiarostami
- Screenplay
- Abbas Kiarostami
- Director of Photography
- Luca Bigazzi
Review
The first film made outside his native Iran by director Abbas Kiarostami, and starring Juliette Binoche, who also appeared in the helmer's previous Shirin, Certified Copy surprised some critics who saw the film in its' screenings at the 2010 Cannes Film Festival, at how strangely conventional a film it is in parts, but also some saw the central character's argument, that a copy of a work of art can be as valid as the real thing, as a strange analogy to the narrative here itself, at times coming over almost as a copy of standard European arthouse production, even down to having Binoche's character just known as 'She', even though the other significant other character, the author, has a name, James Miller (William Shimell, a British opera singer making his first film appearance). Bearing a surprising resemblance to Richard Linklater's Before Sunset, the film has Miller presenting his latest work to a Tuscany audience, with She being in the audience, and She arranges to meet him afterwards, at her antique shop before he catches his train to Tuscany. After a drive into the countryside they discuss the central concept revolving around the nature of originals and copies in both life and art, and whether if one can get a copy, should one want to own an original, or does it make the copy less valuable or real. The pair are taken for a long-married couple in a cafe, and carry on the deception, even to the point of inventing their own shared history and family, and one sees that Kiarostami is also incorporating large chunks of Roberto Rossellini's Journey To Italy (1954) in the way the pair seem to fall into their ascribed roles. At no times do the pair become particularly sympathetic or likeable, and the film does essentially come to no firm conclusions, the pair still in this faux-marriage, with She seemingly want to take it rather further then he, but is enlivened by some very fine photography of the Tuscan countryside by Luca Bigazzi (The Consequences Of Love / Romanzo Criminale). With a typically committed performance from Binoche, and a rather less certain one from Shimell, whose screen appearances have been limited to some broadcast stage operas, one is never sure what Kiarostami is trying to say, to prove the theory of the original / copy as put forward by Shimell's Miller, or to debunk it, and although this is certainly more accessible and rewarding than some of his more experimental pieces such as Ten or Shirin, some may say that they would rather have an original Kiarostami, such as The Wind Will Carry Us, rather than this odd, unfocused copy.