Film details

Mother and Child  2009

Mother & Child

Cast

Synopsis

Karen is a successful Los Angeles psychotherapist, but harbours the fact that in her early teens in the 1960s, she gave up her baby to a Catholic adoption agency. Elizabeth, the child she gave up, and whom she has never met, or tried to meet, is now a lawyer, but has deliberately distanced herself from the family who adopted her. Both are tormented by their respective separations, Karen feeling little towards her own mother, who is on her death bed, while Elizabeth worships her idealised vision of the woman who gave birth to her. Seemingly unable to form lasting relationships, Elizabeth sleeps with a number of partners, including one of her married neighbours, and Paul, her boss at the law practise, considerably older than her, African-American and recently widowed. When she finds she is pregnant Elizabeth is stunned, but decides to go through with the birth and have the baby. She doesn't tell Paul what has happened, and abruptly leaves the company, joining another practise in the city. Paul tracks her down and, finding what has happened, offers to marry her, and give her a major promotion within the firm, but she turns both offers down. Despite the obstetrician seeing possible complications, she opts for a natural birth, but the delivery is difficult and Elizabeth dies giving birth to a baby daughter. With the help of Sister Joanne, the nun from the agency who also placed Elizabeth years earlier, the child is adopted by Lucy, a woman whose previous attempt to have a child, through surrogate pregnancy, failed with the potential mother, Ray, a twenty-year-old, decided to keep the child instead of giving it away. Lucy is abandoned by her husband, who decides he wants his own biological baby rather than a stranger's, leaving Lucy to bring up the baby, Ella, with the help of her resilient and determined mother. One of Elizabeth's last acts before going into labour was to write a letter to the mother who had her, to be delivered by the adoption agency if anything happened to her, and Sister Joanne gets the letter to Karen, who is still grieving after her mother's death, who makes an emotionally wrenching decision about the daughter she never met, and the grandchild she did not know she had.

Production

Director
Rodrigo García
Producer
Lisa Maria Falcone and Julie Lynn
Art Director
Christopher Tandon
Editor
Steven Weisberg
Music
Edward Shearmur
Screenplay
Rodrigo García
Director of Photography
Xavier Perez Grobet

Review

Rodrigo García is a director whose films seem to regularly somehow slip into distribution limbo, with his films Things You Can Tell Just By Looking At Her and Nine Lives apparently falling through the cracks and never quite getting the audiences they would seem to deserve, despite often impressive casts, particularly on the female side, and one cannot deny that Garcia's Mother And Child is blessed in that department, with a line-up which includes Naomi Watts (King Kong), Annette Bening (Bugsy), Amy Brenneman (Heat), Kerry Washington (Lakeview Terrace), Lisa Gay Hamilton (The Soloist), and the very fine S. Epatha Merkerson (TV's Law And Order) and on the male side such impressive names as Samuel L. Jackson (Pulp Fiction), Jimmy Smits (TV's L.A. Law) and David Morse (The Green Mile), which has to be called a heavyweight cast in anyone's estimation. Released in the US 2009 to distinctly underwhelming results, Mother And Child does not exactly market itself as that uncomfortably unctuous phrase a 'faith film' but may as well do, since this is almost Biblical in its' retribution against neglectful mothers, making sure that they, and the audience suffer, paying for such sins as, in the case of Watts' utterly luckless Elizabeth, having a number of lovers including Jackson's recently widowed Paul, but even his character is portrayed as weak when he offers to marry her. In a film which essentially revolves around a Catholic adoption agency, it is perhaps obvious that abortion is not going to be an issue, but it is utterly farcical and insulating to an audience that the subject isn't even mentioned except in one scene where an obstetrician sneakily suggest its to Elizabeth in coded, guarded terms as if offering black market yellow cake uranium. Despite having a broad ethnic range of actors, several of these are seemingly only there to give sage wisdom, possibly passed down from generation to generation, they of course being far wiser than mere Los Angelinos, and any woman who makes independent decisions is quite ruthlessly punished, an attitude which is almost horrifically fundamentalist, and even Bening's Karen is only given some sort of forgiveness after literally decades of pain and the death of the daughter she never met. Garcia's film may not have attracted any particular audience in the US but one suspects they missed a trick. Had it been marketed to the hellfire and brimstone crowd who attend the low-budget productions from the church-backed Sherwood Productions, almost laughably overwrought pics such as Fireproof and Courageous, then they could have sold a few more tickets.