Film details

For Colored Girls  2010

Tyler Perry's For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When The Rainbow Is Enuf / For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When The Rainbow Is Enuf

Cast

Synopsis

New York City. Crystal's boyfriend Willie, an Iraq veteran, has returned home and is drinking heavily, refusing to take his medication to cope with post-traumatic stress and abusing both Crystal and their children. Kelly, a social worker, tries to assist Crystal, but finds herself distracted by her when her doctor tells her an untreated STD has left her infertile. Jo, the fashion magazine magnate Crystal works for, is also trapped in an unhappy, difficult marriage. Tangie, Crystal's neighbour, is sleeping with a number of different men, while Nyla, her sister, still lives with Alice, their religious maniac of a mother. Nyla takes dance lessons with Jasmine, who tells her she has met a wonderful man, but he rapes her on their second date Jo, realising that Crystal is distracted at work and undergoing relationship difficulties, drives Crystal to her apartment, An enraged Willie who now believes that Crystal is having an affair and that the children are not his, and he throws both of them out of the apartment window to their deaths. A support group for the now-suicidal Crystal is organised by Jo, Kelly and Juanita, a local community organiser. Nyla is forced to go to a backstreet abortionist in order to terminate her pregnancy, and nearly dies during the procedure, but when he returns home she is attacked by a maniacal, crazed Alice, and forced to flee their home rapidly but is found by Kelly, who takes her back to Crystal's apartment to clean up and rest, and where she is reconciled with her sister Tangie. Alice confronts Tangie, blaming her for letting her sister having an abortion, reminding her she was molested and abused as a child. Alice's rant is overheard by a neighbour, Gilda, who tells tangie to confront the demons in her past so that she con cope with them and stop sleeping with other men in order to try to bolster her self-esteem. Hearing the man who raped her has been murdered, Jasmine finds that the news allows her to start to recover. Finding her boyfriend Frank has been unfaithful, Juanita has the determination to leave him, just as Jo learns that her husband has been having secret gay affairs, and has given her HIV. All the women now know each other, and meet for a celebration when one of the number has that rare item, something to celebrate.

Production

Director
Tyler Perry
Producer
Tyler Perry and Paul Hall
Art Director
Roswell Hamrick
Editor
Maysie Hoy
Screenplay
Nzingha Stewart, based on the stage play by Ntozake Shange
Director of Photography
Alexander Gruszynski

Review

One of that particular clutch of plays and stage productions, such as the musicals Rent and The Fantasticks, and August Wilson's Picket Fences, which are constantly revived in the US and play to packed houses but which have pretty much flopped everywhere else, Rent having been staged twice in the West End and failed both times, Tyler Perry's For Colored Girls is the film version of Ntozake Shange's extravagantly-titled 1976 piece For Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When The Rainbow Is Enuf, complete with self-conscious bad spelling, the first time the multi-hyphenate writer / director / everything else in between has filmed a script not his own, Nzingha Stewart adapting the stage version. Previously filmed for TV in 1982, with a cast including Alfre Woodard, Lynn Whitfield and many of the original stage cast, including the authoress herself. The piece at least on stage reflects the far later Vagina Monologues, in being essentially a twenty-part interlocking poem, delivered directly to the audience by the actresses, detailing the trials and inevitable tribulations of black women, and by dint women in general, living in modern-day America, dealing with the struggles with their everyday lives, their relationships, and how years after civil rights legislation they are so often regarded as second class citizens, not least by their own husband and boyfriends. The 'everywoman' status of the characters is reflected in the fact that none have names, and are known on stage only by the colours of the dresses they wear, Green, Blue, Brown, Yellow, Purple etc. This is a huge challenge to Perry, whose previous hits have all been largely faith-based and redemptive pieces, and his biggest hits have been very broad comedies with himself in drag as the dragon-like Medea, and the film version restructures the original considerably, giving the characters not only named but putting them into a fully-fledged, interlacing drama, all the characters becoming involved with each other in one way or another, and while this may emphasise the sisterhood of woman, and the fact that so many of their experiences are shared, it also threatens to turn this in to an African-American Sex And The City without the camp laughs. When the characters stop being mouthpieces and are formed into stand-alone personalities they start to seem to be in competition with each other for who has it the worst, rather in the way of the Monty Python Four Yorkshiremen sketch, as they battle with spousal abuse, drugs, rape, Aids, STDs, infidelity, alcoholism, disturbed war veteran partners and, in the biggest miscalculation, Whoopi Goldberg as the religiously-driven Alice, a genuinely bug-eyed ranting performance which makes Piper Laurie in Carrie look like an exercise in theological calm and peace in comparison. Indeed Goldberg's big scene, religious fervour taking her over, has already become an internet template much in the way of the famous scene from Downfall, being redubbed by various wits and wags. What is so strange is that the piece is so utterly polarised against both men and anything resembling an adult relationship. The last film to make sex this dangerous was Friday The 13th, but when such scenes as the death of Crystal / Brown's children, so shocking on stage, is staged like something out of a Victorian penny-dreadful, it loses a lot of its' power and just becomes another damn thing to stack on top off the others these stoic women have to suffer, and even the most kind and decent man in the piece, played by Hill Harper from CSI: New York, turns out to be secretly gay, and gives his wife HIV. One can't deny that there is an undeniably strong line-up of talent, including Thandie Newton (M:I - 2), Janet Jackson (also seen in Perry's Why Did I Get Married Too?), Whoopi Goldberg (Ghost), Kerry Washington (Lakeview Terrace), Anika Noni Rose (Dreamgirls), Loretta Devine (the US Death At A Funeral) and Phylicia Rashad (TV's The Cosby Show), but what was stark and powerful when stripped down on stage is bloated and borderline risible when turned into a large-scale over-designed double-barrelled drama, and that this, Perry's biggest-budgeted film so far, was also his biggest flop, is possibly no coincidence.