Cast
-
Joseph Cirincione
-
Robert McNamara
-
Valerie Palme-Wilson
-
Graham Allison
-
Zbigniew Brzezinski
-
James Baker III
-
Mikhail Gorbachev
-
Roger Malander
-
Tony Blair
-
Rolf Mowatt-Larson
-
Pervez Musharraf
-
Gary Oldman Narrator
Synopsis
A documentary concerning the proliferation of nuclear weapons around the world, the many ways they can fall into what can be termed 'the wrong hands', and the case for total global disarmament, the three sections of the film being titled after the address made by John F. Kennedy by 1961 to the United Nations General Assembly in which he stated that a nuclear disaster could come about by any of three ways - Accident, Miscalculation, or Madness. Having called the threat of nuclear disaster 'a nuclear Sword of Damocles, hanging by the slenderest of threads', the film examines the history of nuclear weapons, from their first use in 1945 to the ever-present threat during the Cold War, and how strict protocols were established by the US and Russia, who between them hold 22,400 of the 23,335 nukes known to exist as of early 2010, to deal with anything which may look like a first strike attack. Despite strict rules and procedures, a disaster was nearly triggered in 1995 when due to a breakdown in communications a scientific rocket was launched off Norway and was taken for an American missile heading towards Russia. President Boris Yeltsin did not order immediate retaliation as demanded in the tactical nuclear instructions but waited until the rocket was revealed just to be an experiment-bearing carrier, possibly stopping a tactical nuclear exchange. The film goes on to describe how, after the fall of the Soviet Union, security became lax around nuclear sites, and high-yield uranium was being stored in warehouses where the only security was one shop-bought commercial lock on the front doors, just one example of the almost nonexistent security at Russian nuclear resource bases and the sheer amount of nuclear material and weapons-grade matter which has simply vanished, or cannot be accounted for. Those interviewed range from political leaders such as Tony Blair, Mikhail Gorbachev and former Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, former policy makers including the late Robert McNamara, and other contributors including Valerie Palme-Wilson, the former CIA agent who was investigating the clandestine sale of yellow cake uranium in Niger when her identity was shockingly exposed by the Bush administration. How comparatively easy for those with the resources to build their own bomb is also shown, with the basic instructions being available on the Internet and can be located through any of the major search engines, the rough cost of the materials being under $1 million, and how the finished bomb would be relatively easy to smuggle across borders if one knows how to disguise the radioactive elements. The film ends with the detailed description of the effects of a nuclear blast in a major city, how there would be unleashed 20 billion degree heat and winds of up to 650 mph, and how everything within a five mile radius would be completely vaporised. On the idea of this ever occuring, physicist Frank von Hippel notes if the possibility of something happening isn't zero, eventually it will happen.
Production
- Director
- Lucy Walker
- Producer
- Lawrence Bender
- Art Director
- Not credited
- Editor
- Brad Fuller and Brian Johnson
- Music
- Peter Golub
- Screenplay
- Not credited
- Director of Photography
- Robert Chappell, Gary Clarke, Bryan Donnell and Nick Higgins
Review
An obviously gravely sincere documentary which takes as its' starting point a rather grim conclusion, that the proliferation of nuclear weapons around the globe, and particularly the threat of terrorists getting hold of nuclear materials or even complete nuclear weapons, means that mankind is essentially living on borrowed time, Countdown To Zero is clearly dealing with some serious theories, and little that director Lucy Walker can do makes it any more comfortable. Interviewing a fascinating range of people, from political leaders such as Tony Blair, Mikhail Gorbachev and former Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, former policy makers as the late Robert McNamara, and such interesting contributors as Valerie Palme-Wilson, the former CIA agent who was investigating the clandestine sale of yellow cake uranium in Niger when her identity was shockingly, unforgivably exposed by the Bush administration, the film gives frightening details about a number of aspects of the whole spectre of nuclear weapons, from how there have been near-misses where only a mixture of luck and surprisingly good judgement have stopped a tactical exchange of nukes, to how many have gone missing, particularly since the break-up of the Soviet Bloc. And should one not be able to actually get one's hands on one 'off the peg', as it were, there is always the route of knocking up one's own, and before the cries of this documentary being any sort of terrorist's handbook, the information is now freely available on the Net to all with the necessary determination, ingenuity and the funds, since they still don't come cheap. And just in case one may have underestimated just what a nuke detonating in a major built-up area would do, there are genuinely horrifying descriptions of the resultant fireball and searing tornadoes which could truly cause nightmares. Gary Oldman narrates, his measured tones guaranteed to give you sleepless nights, and the film has a clear and unapologetic no-nukes agenda, poignantly including Mikhail Gorbachav talking about the 1986 Reykjavik Summit when it seemed, if only for a brief while, that there was a multi-national move towards disarmament, a hope which was eventually extinguished. Undeniably well-intentioned, and also utterly harrowing, Lucy Walker has made a documentary to give people yet more to worry about, as if there wasn't enough already.