Film details

My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done  2009

Cast

Synopsis

After a period of comparative inactivity in the first few years of the new millennium, Werner Herzog has been remarkably productive recently turning out both features and documentaries, all of which bear his own very distinctive, offbeat trademark, My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done coming very hard on the heels of the extremely strange Bad Lieutenant: Port Of Call New Orleans, which it would be fair to say divided audiences and critics alike. Showing at the Venice Film Festival to an equally mixed reaction, this will probably play to the helmer's faithful regular audience rather than bringing in new converts, being a bizarre blend of elements and eccentric casting within a relatively traditional thriller set-up, but as with any of the German helmer's work, the key word is relatively. Claimed as being 'inspired by a true story', the actual event was the killing of an elderly woman by her own son, the macabre twist being that the weapon of choice was a huge sword, which in this version becomes the murder of Mrs. MacCullum (Grace Zebriskie - TV's Twin Peaks), being slain by her own son Brad (Michael Shannon - Revolutionary Road), in the home of her neighbours, played by veterans Loretta Devine and Irma P. Hall, who are witnesses to the grisly event, with San Diego Detective Hank Havenhurst (Willem Dafoe - Spider-Man), being brought into the case. Brad is holed up, armed, with two hostages, and when his girlfriend Ingrid (Chloe Sevigny - TV's Big Love) arrives, she tells the cop about Hank's mental state, and how he started to unravel following a trip to Peru, after which he started hearing voices, and others start to fill in Brad's back story, including a weirdly-cast Udo Keir (Flesh For Frankenstein) as an actor who tells him that Brad started to identify a little too closely with his role as Orestes in a production of The Furies by Aeschylus, the character being one who killed his own mother. Of course Brad is well mental, as is the narrative of the pic which includes trips to Peru, evoking Herzog's own masterly Aguirre, Wrath Of God, a trip to an unidentified country which seems to be Mongolia, and a trip to an ostrich far run by Herzog regular Brad Dourif (Trauma / Dune), but this is far less audience friendly than Bad Lieutenant, and seems at times to be a deliberate parody of a David Lynch movie, even down to the almost inexplicable appearance of a dwarf, very much a Lynchian motif and her played by Austin Powers' Verne Troyer, but this too seems to be an in-joke since Lynch is the executive producer of the film. Herzog's movies are often oblique and difficult to penetrate, but usually well worth the effort involved, but this time it seems as if this is a little too indulgent to appeal to the wider audience he may have been gathering since the remarkable documentary Grizzly Man, arguably the film which triggered his remarkably prolific work since.

Production

Director
Werner Herzog
Producer
Eric Bassett
Art Director
Danny Caldwell
Editor
Joe Bini and Omar Daher
Music
Ernst Reijseger
Screenplay
Werner Herzog and Herbert Golder
Director of Photography
Peter Zellinger

Review

After a period of comparative inactivity in the first few years of the new millennium, Werner Herzog has been remarkably productive recently turning out both features and documentaries, all of which bear his own very distinctive, offbeat trademark, My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done coming very hard on the heels of the extremely strange Bad Lieutenant; Port Of Call New Orleans, which it would be fair to say divided audiences and critics alike, and if it seems at times this is a deliberate parody of a David Lynch movie, even down to the almost inexplicable appearance of a dwarf, very much a Lynchian motif and her played by Austin Powers' Verne Troyer, this is perhaps unsurprising since Lynch is the executive producer of the film. This will probably play to the helmer's faithful regular audience rather then bringing in new converts, being a bizarre blend of elements and eccentric casting within a relatively traditional thriller set-up, but as with any of the German helmer's work, the key word is 'relatively', and it comes to something in a cast where the most grounded and subtle performance comes from Willem Dafoe (Spider-Man). Claimed as being 'Inspired by a true story', the actual event was the killing of an elderly woman by her own son, the macabre twist being that the weapon of choice was a huge sword, which in this version becomes the murder of Mrs. Macallum (Grace Zebriskie - TV's Twin Peaks), being slain by her own son Brad (Michael Shannon - Revolutionary Road), in the home of her neighbours, played by veterans Loretta Devine and Irma P. Hall, who are witnesses to the grisly event, with San Diego Detective Hank Havenhurst (Dafoe), being brought into the case. Brad is holed up, armed, with two hostages, and when his girlfriend Ingrid (Chloe Sevigny - TV's Big Love) arrives, she tells the cop about Hank's mental state, and how he started to unravel after a trip to Peru, after which he started hearing voices, and others start to fill in Brad's back story, including a weirdly-cast Udo Keir (Flesh For Frankenstein) as a stage director who tells him that Brad started to identify a little too closely with his role in a production of Orestes, the character being one who killed his own mother. Of course Brad is well mental, as is the narrative of the pic which includes trips to Peru, evoking Herzog's own masterly Aguirre, Wrath Of God, a trip to an unidentified country which seems to be Mongolia, complete with locals gazing openly into the camera lens, and a trip to an ostrich farm run by Herzog regular Brad Dourif (Trauma / Dune), and who just happens to have the huzzin' great sword Brad wants to borrow for the play. Less audience friendly than Bad Lieutenant, and Herzog's movies are often oblique and difficult to penetrate but usually well worth the effort involved, this time it seems as if this is a little too indulgent to appeal to the wider audience he may have been gathering since the remarkable documentary Grizzly Man, arguably the film which triggered his remarkably prolific work since, but still has some fascinating scenes, and a couple of good jokes, particularly when Brad releases his two hostages as the SWAT team prepares to move in. Utterly bizarre in parts, and unfathomable in a couple of others, the combination of Lynch and Herzog has produced a fascinating if sometimes infuriating piece of work, and one would have loved to be a fly on the wall during script conferences, and yet somehow what has emerged is surprisingly coherent considering the talents involved.