Film details

Don't Be Afraid of the Dark  2011

Cast

  • Bailee Madison
  • Jack Thompson
  • Alan Dale
  • Bruce Gleeson
  • Edwina Ritchard
  • Garry McDonald
  • Carolyn Shakespeare Allen
  • David Tucci
  • Lance Drisdale

Synopsis

The Nineteenth Century, in the sprawling ancestral home on Rhode Island, Blackwood Mansion, Emerson Blackwood, a painter and illustrator, tries a peace offering of human teeth, both his own and his housekeeper's, freshly pulled, to the creatures which hide in the basements running under the estate, and which have abducted his young son, but the monsters reject the offering, seizing Blackwood and dragging him into the darkness. The present day. Young Sally Hurst arrives at Blackwood mansion, which is being restored by her father Alex and his new partner, Kim, the house having fallen into disrepair after rumours of mysterious happenings many years earlier. Sally is still upset by her parents breaking up, and finding it hard to open up to Kim, although she tries to be as accommodating as possible to the young girl. Sally finds the house forbidding and sinister, and starts to hear strange sounds coming from behind the walls and antique fixtures, hearing whispers coming from the behind the bricked-up concealed entrance to the basement. When Kim and Alex discover the entrance they open it, being amazed to find that it contains hundreds of sketches and drawings by Emerson Blackwood, but Harris, the estate caretaker, is wary of the discovery, warning them that the house has a dark history which should be left undisturbed. After the flue leading the surface is unblocked, the creatures are freed, small, voracious and seemingly cunningly intelligent monsters, with an acute sensitivity to light, hence their inhabiting the dark. The first victim is Harris, who they ambush in the dark, and then they turn their attention to Sally, appearing to be friendly, talking to her from their hiding places and trying to lure her towards them tempting her to leave her father and Kim and join them in the dark. She tries to tell her father of the monsters hiding in the basement, but Alex only humours her, making it clear he doesn't believe her, which drives sally towards them, wanting to prove him wrong and prove their existence, but Kim starts to believe Sally's claims, and becomes so convinced that she starts to worry that Sally may be in danger from whatever it is in the dark. Desperate to get Sally, the creatures attack, trying to drag her into their lair in the basement, but fighting desperately she manages to kill it, not quite understanding what the monster actually is but realising that she, Kim and Alex are all in terrible danger....

Production

Director
Troy Nixey
Producer
Guillermo del Toro and Mark Johnson
Art Director
Lucinda Thomson
Editor
Jill Bilcock
Music
Marco Beltrami and Buck Sanders
Screenplay
Guillermo del Toro and Matthew Robbins, based on the original 1973 TV movie written by Nigel McNeand
Director of Photography
Oliver Stapleton

Review

A remake of a very well-regarded 1973 TV movie, which still provokes genuine shivers among those who remember it from the telly, and being responsible for an awful lot of nightmare among those who were a certain age when they first saw it on the box, this big-screen remake of Don't Be Afraid Of The Dark is co-produced and co-written by Guillermo del Toro, but the Mexican movie mogul's involvement has resulted in a 're-formatting' of the premise, changing the story so that instead of the menaced victim being a married woman, played by Kim Darby (the original True Grit), the remake makes the central character a young girl, Sally Hurst (Bailee Madison - Letters To God), moving in with her father Alex (Guy Pearce - Memento) and his new girlfriend Kim, (Katie Holmes - Batman Begins), in the impressively gloomy Blackwood Mansion, a change of emphasis which mirrors Del Toro's magnificent Pan's Labyrinth by having a youngster as the central protagonist, but which also means that the horrific ending of the TV version, which really must have seemed utterly shocking nearly four decades ago and considering TV standards, won't be repeated here. Shot in Australia, doubling for the US, and directed by Troy Nixey (Latchkey's Lament), one of Del Toro's proteges, the plot remains largely the same, with Sally soon discovering strange creatures are living in the house, or rather under it, with them, hiding in the dark of the cellar. Initially scared of them, the creatures, odd Muppet-y hairy things in the original, and rather more creepy and white-eyed when finally revealed here, initially seem to be friendly, and Sally becomes fascinated by them, but of course they are not, and have plans for her and everybody else in the house. The Pan's Labyrinth parallels are pronounced, with the character of Sally being the child of a broken marriage, and whose feelings of semi-abandonment making her attraction to the whispering beings in the darkness all the more understandable, and director Nixey constantly tempts the audience with hints that things are going to get very grim indeed once the secret of the basement is revealed, but the pic never achieves the genuine frissons of fear the TV version does. The supporting cast is mostly comprised of very decent Australian talent, including Jack Thompson (Breaker Morant) as the first victim, inevitably the handyman who utters portents of doom before getting written out in reel four, Alan Dale (TV's Neighbours), Julia Blake (X-Men Origins: Wolverine) and Garry McDonald (Moulin Rouge!), and for those who have never seen the original this will provide a few chills, but those who still shudder at the thought of what was lurking in the dark of the '73 pic, and the very different, far less ruthless ending, will think this a slightly pale shadow of what could have been. Given the death of decent horror material at the moment one wonders why they don't plunder more 70's TV movies, some of which were rather decent, such as Steven Spielberg's early outing Something Evil (1972), Jerrold Freedman's A Cold Night's Death (1973), or the very chilling 1970 sci-fi pic Night Slaves, a real neglected little gem. We also wouldn't mind a remake of Killdozer (1974) either, but the less said about Whatever Happened To Rosemary's Baby the better.....