Film details

Conviction  2010

Cast

Synopsis

Tony Goldwyn (Ghost / The Last House On The Left remake) is not only a talented and underrated actor, but also a very decent director, homing his skills on episodes of such TV series as Dexter and Damages as well as helming such features as A Walk On The Moon and The Last Kiss, and here turns his attentions to a remarkable true story, the efforts of a one woman to overturn her brother's unsafe and unjust murder conviction, aided by a very strong cast including double Oscar-winner Hilary Swank, the always watchable Sam Rockwell (Confessions Of A Dangerous Mind), and Juliette Lewis (Strange Days), backed up by some fine character performers including Peter Gallagher (American Beauty), Melissa Leo (Frozen River) and Karen Young (TV's The Sopranosi/>). A Massachusetts bartender with two children, BettyAnne Waters (Swank), is convinced that her brother, Kenny (Rockwell), serving a life sentence without parole for the stabbing of a woman in 1980, more than a decade earlier, is innocent, and is determined to prove it, trying to take care of her children while studiously studying for her law degree in order to try to mount an appeal. Flashing back to the investigation and court case itself, the spearhead is a dedicated cop, Nancy Taylor (Leo), who is determined that Kenny should be convicted, convinced of his guilt, and the testimony of two ex-girlfriends is especially damning, showing Kenny to be volatile and often violent towards women. The brother and sister are close, as seen in prepared flashbacks to their shared childhood, and some critics have pointed out that these scenes are the weakest in the film, being a little too idyllic in their depiction of a sibling relationship, but emphasises that BettyAnne's studying is what she sees as having to do in order to save her brother. Or course there is also the implausible angle of the story, and whether BettyAnne wouldn't have saved a whole lot of time and effort by simply trying to find a pro bono lawyer willing to take the case, but then of course there would be no story. Finally passing the bar exam, and encouraged by her best friend Abra (Minnie Driver - Good Will Hunting) and sympathetic attorney Barry Scheck (Gallagher), she searches for the evidence which is missing from the case files, and believes that DNA testing, a new technique at the time, will clear Kenny, and the numerous scenes between brother and sister on prison visits are apparently the most affecting parts of the film. Early word is that Conviction is certainly watchable but often confusing in its' flashbacks and forwards, some saying a few more captions detailing time and place would make it more comprehensible in parts, and of course there would be no film if BettyAnne's quest were a failure, but those familiar with the case, notable in the annals of US law, also not that a very important event which happened six months after Kenny's release, and which it would be unfair to reveal, is completely ignored, not even earning a final caption, and even if not having any bearing on BettyAnne and her monumental efforts, adds a sobering edge to the seemingly triumphant ending.

Production

Director
Tony Goldwyn
Producer
Tony Goldwyn, Andrew S. Karsch and Andrew Sugerman
Art Director
Stephanie Gilliam
Editor
Jay Cassidy
Music
Paul Cantelon
Screenplay
Pamela Gray
Director of Photography
Adriano Goldman

Review

Tony Goldwyn (Ghost / The Last House On The Left remake) is not only a talented and underrated actor, but also a very decent director, homing his skills on episodes of such TV series as Dexter and Damages as well as helming such features as A Walk On The Moon and The Last Kiss, and here turns his attentions to a remarkable true story, the efforts of a one woman to overturn her brother's unsafe and unjust murder conviction, to the point of sacrificing her own marriage, but handles it in a surprisingly conventional way, a very straight and solemn retelling of the story, some of the details being altered in the interests of serving the film, and despite the true heroics shown by Betty Anne Waters in wanting to get her brother released, never believing he was guilty of murder despite the evidence presented, one ends up thinking that this is really little more than a very efficient and well preformed TV movie, making one wonder if that is probably its' natural home rather than the cinema screen. The film is very respectful of Betty Anne and her devotion to her brother, and the film's most successful scenes are those between them, but this reverence almost makes the character, played by a well-cast Hilary Swank, into a demi-saint, and an equally well chosen Sam Rockwell as Kenny is a sympathetic character who the audience instinctively knows is innocent, even if some of his less appealing characteristics, such an apparent propensity for violence against women, are discreetly air-brushed out of the picture. Goldwyn has a strong cast to back up the leads, including Juliette Lewis (Strange Days) and Minnie Driver (Good Will Hunting), backed up by some fine character performers including Peter Gallacher (American Beauty), Melissa Leo (Frozen River) and Karen Young (TV's The Sopranos) and it should be remembered that even after she qualified it took Betty Anne another six years to secure Kenny's release, which is where the story ends, not including the sad and peculiar fact that he died in a very bizarre and slightly suspicious accident only six months after being released. Conviction is certainly watchable if confusing in its' flashbacks and forwards, and a few more captions detailing time and place would make it more comprehensible in parts, and of course there would be no film were Betty Anne's quest a failure, but the ironing out of some of the less palatable elements of the story presents a false impression, removing a sobering edge from the seemingly triumphant ending.