Film details

Miral  2010

Cast

  • Freida Pinto
  • Hiam Abbass
  • Alexander Siddig
  • Makram Khoury
  • Yasmine El-Masri
  • Omar Metwally
  • Stella Schnabel
  • Shredi Jabarin
  • Jamil Khoury
  • Donald Liddawi
  • Yolande El-Karam

Synopsis

1948, Palestine, and seeing the large number of orphaned Palestinian girls with a home or education, the philanthropic Hind Husseini opens a boarding school for them in east Jerusalem, the Tifi Al-Arabi Institute, which she will eventually go on to run for over four decades. Nadia, a young girl raped by her brutish, violent father as a child, flees her home, going to live and study at the school. As a young woman she gets into an argument with an Israeli citizen on a bus in Jerusalem, leading to Nadia being arrested, beaten by the Police and imprisoned. Once there she meets Fatima, previously a nurse without an interest in politics, but who became radicalised after Israel's victory in the Six Day War. The women become friends and Nadia is told how Fatima was given three life sentances for attempting to plant a bomb in a Jerusalem cinema, but her mission was a failure. Eventually released, Nadia marries Fatima's brother, Jamal, but their relationship is unhappy from the beginning, although they have a daughter, Miral. Nadia becomes a depressive alcoholic, eventually abandoning her family and drowning herself. Miral, unwanted by her father, goes to Hind's school. Becoming a confident and intelligent teenager, she leaves in order to act as a teacher in a Ramallah refugee camp, wanting to teach young girls who were in the same position as herself, and his horrified at the brutality of the Israeli soldiers during the Intifada, firing on civilians and bulldozing buildings with occupants still in them. Going on a peace march, Miral is trapped when the clashes between the protesters and the authorities turn violent, but she is pulled out of the throng by Hani, a PLO local leader. They start a relationship and she starts to embrace his beliefs and aims, but when the Israeli Police raid properties looking for him, Miral is arrested, repeatedly beaten and brutalised. Released, she is sent into exile, and not allowed to her home, having to take refuge in the city of Haifa, where she is put in contact with her cousin's girlfriend, Lisa, and is surprised to find that she is Jewish, something her cousin has kept secret, but the two become good friends. When Hani tells his comrades that he believes a two-state solution to the Arab-Israeli problem is possible, they start to view him as a potential traitor. With Miral wanting to become a journalist, she is given devastating news by her dying father, just as someone else important in her life is making plans for her also.

Production

Director
Julian Schnabel
Producer
Jon Kilik
Art Director
Nir Alba
Editor
Juliette Welfling
Music
Julian Schnabel (supervisor)
Screenplay
Rula Jebreal, based on the book by Raul Jabreal
Director of Photography
Eric Gautier

Review

Although receiving generally very good notices at the 2010 Toronto Film Festival, director Julian Schnabel (Basquiat / The Diving Bell And The Butterfly), showing the contrariness for which he known, then announced that he would be considerably re-cutting Miral before it was generally release, annoying a lot of critics who then realised that their Toronto reviews were essentially now invalid. Schnabel never chooses easy subjects, that much is for certain, but with Miral he has managed to pull off a very delicate balancing act, as any film dealing with the Arab / Israeli conflict, if it is not to be regarded as just a piece of propaganda, but what is very unusual is that the film presents a clearly Palestinian point of view, essentially being four interlinked chapters based on the partially autobiographical novel by Rula Jebreal, covering the story of four Arab women, from the founding of the Tifi Al-Arabi Institute for orphaned Palestinian girls in 1948 by the strong-willed and determined Hind Husseini (well played by Hiam Abbass - Lemon Tree), showing the changes in the region via the characters of thwarted bomber Fatima (Ruba Blal - Forgiveness) and then Nadia (Yasmine El-Masri - Caramel), a young woman arrested for punching an obnoxious Israeli woman on a bus, before focusing on the title character, Miral, played as a child by Yolande El-Karam, the daughter born to Nadia, being sent to the Tifi Institute and eventually emerging as a young woman, surprisingly played by Frieda Pinto from Slumdog Millionaire, odd casting in a film which otherwise his a showcase for very strong Middle Eastern actresses. Falling for a radical PLO activist, Hani (Omar Metwally - Rendition), she realises she has to choose which path to take, that of peace or that of terrorism and rebellion, which in some ways are the less interesting parts of the narrative when compared to what has gone before. Certain scenes are remarkably effective, such as the attempted cinema bombings, making very clever use of Roman Polanski's Repulsion, which is playing as Fatima attempts to plant her explosives, Having to cope with Schnabel's often erratic style in both lensing and editing, he is also forced to add a lot of contextual matter, such as captions and archive footage to establish timelines and historical events, and some obvious commercial concerns and compromises have been picked upon by critics, such as the fact that the film is made in English rather than Arabic and Hebrew, which only turn up in brief snippets, and the fact that although name actors Willem Dafoe and Vanessa Redgrave are given prominent billing, their appearances are little more than cameos, and brief ones at that. Schnabel's films are never less than impassioned, but one suspects with Miral that in order to spread the message further than to the already converted he has made a film which instead of being accessible may just be a little bland and compromised, which is very regrettable given the possibilities, being clearly sincere but perhaps too eager not to offend or anger any viewer.