Film details

Jack and Jill  2011

Cast

  • Dana Carvey
  • Santiago Segura
  • Valerie Mahaffey
  • Jackie Seiden
  • Yvette Rachelle
  • Eugenio Derbaz
  • Ken Lally
  • John Yuan
  • Luis Fernandez-Gil

Synopsis

Holy Lord, what psychopath came up with this one?...... Another Adam Sandler comedy, the seventh to be directed by frequent collaborator Dennis Dugan, in which most if it takes place in a very exclusive holiday resort / theme park or other such desirous location, allowing Sandler to essentially have a very nice holiday at the film company's expense, Jack And Jill could well be one of the weirdest, and most off-putting, entries in a CV which isn't exactly short of them. Sandler plays Jack Murray, an average family man living in New York who is alarmed when his sister, Jill, arrives, ostensibly to stay for a few days over Thanksgiving, but then won't leave, which is a very well-worn plot, stemming back to George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart's masterly stage farce The Man Who Came To Dinner, written all the way back in 1939, but the script, by Steve Koren, Robert Smigel and Ben Zook, based on an original story, entitled The Weird Personality, by Zook, takes this a bizarre and slightly nauseating step further when Jill starts to be pursued around the Big Apple by, playing himself, Al Pacino, who has fallen madly in love with her. All well and good, until you realise that Sandler also plays Jill, under rather unsettling but oddly convincing make-up by the superb Tony Gardner, whose long list of credits includes Darkman, the Child's Play series and Zombieland among many others. Sandler, it has to be admitted, has an audience, even if they seem to be almost exclusively in the US, the overseas grosses for his films being almost negligible outside of English-speaking territories, and perhaps to counter this he includes, in a terrific cast which includes Katie Holmes (Don't Be Afraid Of The Dark) and Dana Carvey (as in whatever happened to...?), Santiago Segura, the Spanish comedian, writer and director who is probably the biggest Iberian media star, his gross spoof private eye movies, the Torrente series, four in all, 2011's Torrente: Crisis Letal (Torrente: Lethal Crisis) even being in 3D, regularly breaking the Spanish box-office records set by the previous pic, making one think that Sandler possibly has an eye on expanding his profile in Europe, or at least in Spain and Portugal. To ensure he also gets a good holiday while shooting the pic, much of this is shot on The Allure Of The Sea, a new super-luxury liner and shot before its' actual maiden voyage in December 2010, because one wouldn't want to think of such a sensitive and delicate intellectual genius as Adam Sandler having to rough it while making a delicate comedy of manners such as this, would one?

Production

Director
Dennis Dugan
Producer
Todd Garner, Jack Giarraputo, Adam Sandler and Bettina Sofia Viviano
Art Director
Alan Au and John Collins
Editor
Tom Costain
Music
Rupert Gregson-Williams
Screenplay
Steve Koren, Robert Smigel and Ben Zook, based on the original story The Weird Personality by Ben Zook
Director of Photography
Dean Cundey

Review

Another Adam Sandler comedy, the seventh to be directed by frequent collaborator Dennis Dugan, in which most takes place in a very exclusive holiday resort / theme park or other such desirous location, allowing Sander to essentially have a very nice holiday at the film company's expense, Jack And Jill could well be one of the weirdest, and most off-putting, entries in a CV which isn't exactly short of them. Sandler plays Jack Sadelstein, an adman living in New York who is alarmed when his sister, Jill, arrives, ostensibly to stay for a few days over Thanksgiving, but then won't leave, which is a very well-worn plot, stemming back to George S. Kaufman and Moss Hart's masterly stage farce The Man Who Came To Dinner, written all the way back in 1939, but the script, by Sandler and Steve Koren, based on an original story, entitled The Weird Personality, by Ben Zook, takes this a bizarre and slightly nauseating step further since the reason Jill remains is that she starts to be pursued around the Big Apple by, playing himself, Al Pacino, who has fallen madly in love with her. This is fortuitous for Jack, whose boss is pressuring him to get Pacino for an ad campaign they are planning. All well and good, until you realise that Sandler also plays Jill, under rather unsettling but oddly convincing make-up by the superb Tony Gardner, whose long list of credits includes Darkman, the Child's Play series and Zombieland among many others. That Pacino plays himself as broad and loud as a California six-lane highway, getting into uncomfortably intimate positions with Sandler in drag, seems to exude the supreme confidence of a man now in his early seventies, with tens of millions in the bank and who really doesn't care any more, while Katie Holmes in a truly thankless role seems to just be looking for another chance to get out of the house. Sandler, it has to be admitted, has an audience, even if they seem to be almost exclusively in the US, the overseas grosses for his films being almost negligible outside of English-speaking territories, and this has all the hallmarks of his previous canon, including an array of cameos from various C-list US comedians, such as Dana Carvey (as in whatever happened to...?), Tim Meadows (The Ladies Man) and David Spade (TV's Terms Of Engagement), all of whom failed to establish their own film careers, and an array of celebrities walk-ons which range from the reasonably famous, such as John McEnroe and basketball player Shaquille O'Neal, to 'celebrities' only US audiences will recognise if at all, Michael Irvin and Bill Romanowski anybody? To ensure he also gets a good holiday while shooting the pic, another Sandler trademark, some of this is set on The Allure Of The Sea, a new super-luxury liner and shot before its' actual maiden voyage in December 2010, because one wouldn't want to think of such a sensitive and delicate intellectual genius as Adam Sandler having to rough it while making a delicate comedy of manners such as this, would one? It seems unfair to criticise Jack And Jill since, despite slightly disappointing box-office in the US, it is perfectly tailored for the sort of person who finds his films funny, while others may find it everything from mildly sexist to completely misogynist, and the character of Jill is truly uncomfortable in her sheer crudity, but those who go knowing what to expect will not be disappointed. Those who still believe Al Pacino to be a fine and impressive actor may be, however.