Film details

Beginners  2010

Cast

Synopsis

2003, and Oliver, a Los Angeles graphic artist, is clearing out the house of his late father, Hal, after the elderly man's death, and the act of clearing the house brings back recent memories, Hal startling his son by, five years earlier, at the age of 75, coming out as gay, Oliver realising that for years he and his mother had lived in a sterile, loveless marriage. He remembers his often awkward younger years, and his early realisation that although they were married, his mother and father certainly didn't love each other, and he believes this has contributed to his own emotional coldness and reluctance to commit himself to anyone. Still depressed after his father's death, Hal is invited to a party by a friend, and there meets Anna, a young french actress, but although they are attracted to each other, Olive is reluctant to make the running in their shy and tentative relationship. Troubled by his conflicted feelings he begins an art project, The History Of Sadness. The work triggers memories of Hal after he was diagnosed with the cancer that would eventually kill him, and how he decided to live every day as if it were his last, refusing to succumb to the illness and instead found happiness with his boyfriend, a much younger man called Andy. As the illness progresses, Hal and Oliver, who were often awkward with each other, found themselves becoming closer, Hal eventually telling his son of the sham which was he and his mother's marriage, they being together, unhappily, for forty-four years. His advice to his son is to live and love as he is doing now, for the moment. Anna and Oliver's relationship seems to develop to the point where she movies into his apartment, but both feel uncomfortable in such close proximity and she soon movies out again, causing oliver to remember the advice of his late and loved father, and instead of seeing her leave him, do something about it.

Production

Director
Mike Mills
Producer
Miranda De Pencier, Lars Knudsen, Leslie Urdand, Dean Vanech and Jay Van Hoy
Art Director
Shane Valentino
Editor
Olivier Bugge Coutte
Music
Roger Neill, Dave Palmer and Brian Reitzell
Screenplay
Mike Mills
Director of Photography
Kasper Tuxen

Review

Beginners is obviously a very personal story for Mike Mills, writer and director of the interesting if flawed Thumbsucker (2005), and here making his second feature, a comedy / drama with a provocative idea at its' core, centring on Oliver (Ewan McGregor - the second Star Wars trilogy), trying to get over the recent death of his elderly father and also cope with his own loneliness. This changes when he meets the beautiful but unpredictable French actress Anna (Melanie Laurent - Inglourious Basterds), which in turn brings back memories of his father, Hal (Christopher Plummer - Inside Man), married to Oliver's mother for forty-four years but who then came out of the closet, admitting to being gay at age seventy-five, living the last few years of his life with an honesty he has never had before, and making Oliver see that one has to be honest with everything in life, which gives him the courage to at least attempt to commit to a relationship with Anna. Based on the life of Mills' own father, some may find this implausible, but the writer / director insists that he only realised just how miserable his parents were for most of his life as a child and adolescent when his father revealed to him the truth of what he had only suspected for years, and Plummer, who arguably is undergoing a remarkable late-career renaissance, makes the flamboyant Hal a believable character, trying to establish the truth of how he is in what he knows is a limited amount of time, going so far as to become involved in a May-December relationship with a much younger man, Andy (Goran Visnjic - TV's E.R.), but just as Thumbsucker occasionally became weighed down by its' own cleverness and quirkiness, so Mills cannot leave well enough alone here also. As if the quirks of the story are not enough, and McGregor's Oliver setting up his own art project entitled The History of Sadness is just underlining his emotional state in heavy pencil for those who have still not cottoned on, but when even his dog, a Jack Russell terrier, is offering him advice, and having as equally pretentious lines as some of the peripheral characters then one starts to wonder just how much Mills is playing fair and how much he is manipulating to raise the quirkiness level, and an increasing reliance on such as photo montages and flashbacks and a commentary which almost seems to place the film in a different time-set altogether, all to establish the persistence of memory, also threaten to push the viewer's patience towards fraying completely. Despite some of the self-conscious weirdness, Mills is obviously sympathetic towards everyone involved, and it is clear that Plummer's septuagenarian, finally escaping the restrictions which have been put on him for most of his adult life, is the happiest of all of them, and it is his message which he is trying to make his son, and McGregor can mope for Scotland if he wants to, understand. Beginners is based on what seems to be a remarkable story, and one that deserves to be told, but whether how Mike Mills actually handles it in the right way is arguable.