Film details

The Return of Frank James  1940

Cast

  • Gene Tierney
  • Jackie Cooper
  • Henry Hull
  • John Carradine
  • J. Edward Bromberg
  • Donald Meek
  • Eddie Collins
  • George Barbier
  • Russell Hicks
  • Ernest Whitman
  • Charles Tannen
  • Lloyd Corrigan
  • Victor Kilian
  • Edward McWade
  • George Chandler
  • Irving Bacon
  • Frank Shannon
  • Barbara Pepper
  • Louis Mason
  • Matthew 'Stymie' Beard
  • William Pawley
  • Frank Sully
  • Davison Clark
  • Tyrone Power
  • Bob Battier
  • A.S. 'Pop' Byron
  • Kernan Cripps
  • Lester Dorr
  • Edmund Elton

Synopsis

His brother Jesse having been killed by men he once trusted, former gang member Robert Ford, assisted by his brother Charlie Ford and Tom Grayson, Frank James wants revenge, but decides that the safest way is to keep out of the potentially volatile situation, most people believing him dead along with Jesse, letting the courts do their business and deliver justice. Living under the name Ben Woodson, when the perpetrators are found guilty Frank for once believes in the legal system, but is shocked and infuriated when the three are quickly pardoned and released. Deciding he has to take the affair into his own hands, he leaves the isolated farm where he thought he could perhaps live in peace, soon tangling with the law and realising that the word has leaked out that he is still alive, making him realise he is as much hunted as the men he is pursuing, but will not stop until he has avenged Jesse by making the Ford brothers and Grayson pay, with their lives.

Production

Director
Fritz Lang
Producer
Darryl F. Zanuck and Kenneth Macgowan
Art Director
Richard Day and Wiard B. Ihnen
Editor
Walter Thompson
Music
David Buttolph
Screenplay
Sam Hellman
Director of Photography
George Barnes and William V. Skall

Review

Having had a major hit with Tyrone Power biting the dust in Jesse James the previous year, Twentieth Century Fox were very keen to continue the saga of the James Boys, so turned to Fritz Lang, the German director having arrived in the US in the late 1930s, escaping the Nazis, and who had made a number of films in his native land which would later be regarded as cinematic masterpieces, including the original Metropolis, M and Dr. Mabuse Der Speiler and under Lang's direction, being his first film in colour, this sequel, dealing with the fictional quest of brother Frank James (Henry Fonda, reprising his role from Jesse James, as do all the principles) to gain revenge on those who killed his brother, Robert Ford (John Carradine - Stagecoach) and co-conspiritors Charlie Ford (Charles Tannen - The Grapes Of Wrath) and Tom Grayson (Jackie Cooper - The Champ), is a slow-building piece, but also hamstrung by the morality of the piece which has Frank James as the bad guy, despite being on the vengeance trail to avenge his brother, and manages to work its' way out of this wrangle by having Frank as the instigator of the events rather than the killings themselves. Impressively made on what was obviously a generous budget, Lang seems to intrinsically understand the Western ethos, with Fonda being noble and heroic as the dedicated James, wanting what he sees as genuine frontier justice for his brother, willing to put his faith in the justice system until, in his eyes, it so clearly fails. A very watchable Western, due in no small part to Fonda and the very capable supporting cast, but also too slowly-paced and hidebound by the production codes of the time. Interestingly the film is the debut of the actress Gene Tierney, here playing Eleanor Stone, a female reporter Frank gets close to, this being the first in a career which eventually encompassed over nearly forty films and lasting four decades.