Film details

Something Borrowed  2011

Cast

  • Kate Hudson
  • John Krasinski
  • Ginnifer Goodwin
  • Steve Howey
  • Ashley Williams
  • Peyton List
  • Jill Eikenberry
  • Colin Egglesfield
  • Sean Patrick Reilly
  • Mary O'Rourke
  • Anya Bergstedt Jordanova
  • Pedro Alvarado

Synopsis

As New York lawyer Rachel White celebrates her thirtieth birthday at a party, she reveals to her close friend Dex Thaler that six years ago she had a major crush on him, and they end up sleeping together that night, despite Rachel knowing that Dex is actually engaged to her best friend, the self-absorbed Darcy Rhone, and their wedding is imminent. Rachel and Dex continue their affair, Darcy not knowing they are involved, and fearing Rachel is destined to be left on the shelf, tries to set her up with Marcus, a slippery ladies man, while Ethan, Rachel's long-time friend and confidant, finds himself being pursued by the clingy and borderline desperate Claire. Rachel and Dex find themselves torn between feelings of lust and guilt as the wedding draws closer. Only Ethan knows of their affair, and he is moving to London shortly. Darcy arranges to meet Rachel, telling her that she and Dex have stopped having sex, and that she cheated on him with someone else. Rachel, surprised at what Darcy has told her, tells her she should still marry Dex, which exasperates Ethan who believes that Rachel and Dex are made for each other. Rachel finally goes to Dex and tells him that they should live together, but he sadly tells her that he cannot. Rachel's shattered, and travels to London to see Ethan, who finally reveals his own, long-held unrequited love for her, and his belief that she truly loves Dex and should be with him. Returning to New York, she finds that Dex has called off the wedding, in order to be with her. They are together in Rachel's apartment when Darcy arrives unexpectedly, Dex hiding and hearing Darcy explain how she is glad that the marriage is now off, now that she has discovered that she is pregnant by Marcus. Hearing this, Dex comes out of hiding, and there is a chilly moment as all three face each other for the first time, in circumstances so very different from what they ever expected.

Production

Director
Luke Greenfield
Producer
Broderick Johnson, Andrew A. Kosove, Aaron Lubin, Pamela Schein Murphy, Molly Smith and Hilary Swank
Art Director
Jane Musky
Editor
John Axelrad
Music
Alex Wurman
Screenplay
Jennie Snyder and Jennie Ulman, based on the novel by Emily Giffin
Director of Photography
Charles Minsky

Review

After a string of rom-coms including Fool's Gold, My Best Friend's Girl and Bride Wars, Kate Hudson continues with the sort of pic which somehow seems to be her default setting, in this film version of Emily Giffin's novel, first published in 2004, followed by a sequel, Something Blue in 2006, and which may tip one off that the romantic problems of the leads may not be sorted out by the fade-out. Directed by Luke Greenfield (The Girl Next Door), this first film made from the best-selling authoress' work concerns two friends, Rachel White (Hudson) and Darcy Rhone (Ginnifer Goodwin - TV's Big Love), best friends since childhood but diametrically different. Rachel is the good girl, everybody's friend, a hard-working Manhattan attorney and dedicated and studious compared to Darcy, who is brash, outgoing to the point of being borderline obnoxious, and self-centred. On Rachel's thirtieth birthday she gets drunk and finds herself sleeping with Dex (Colin Egglesfield - TV's Melrose Place), Darcy's fiancee. Such an out-of-character event changes everything, especially when the two begin an illicit affair behind Darcy's back. Of course this makes Rachel realise she has to choose between having a friend she has known since she was a child, or continuing an affair which is only going to end in disaster. The problem with this is what works on the printed page doesn't translate so easily to the screen once the basic idea, girl having affair with best friend's fiancee, is established, and the film soon gets stuck in a cycle of liaisons, trysts and fretting about whether to stick with the hot boyfriend or to tell all to the oddly unpleasant friend, audiences finding it hard to actually feel aggrieved for the betrayed fiancee simply since she's so self-obsessed and callous. A relationship situation which at least begins with a fraction more reality than most of the movies Hudson made previously, this is at least a slight change of characterisation for the actress who was very much on danger of type-casting herself through her choice of material, and Goodwin makes for an appealing if eventually ineffectual heroine, although the various twists which allow at least a three-quarter way happy ending are tortuous to say the least, and yes, a sequel is promised (threatened?) by a post-credits coda. Director Greenfield has a very interesting supporting cast also including John Krasinski (the US TV version of The Office), Ashley Williams (TV's decidedly odd Saving Grace) and comparative veteran Jill Eikenberry (TV's L.A. Law), but this is really best suited to those who know the novel, and can put up with Rachel's almost interminable wavering, and the sometimes utterly obnoxious Darcy.