Cast
-
Belen Rueda
-
-
Francesc Orella
-
Boris Ruiz
-
Clara Segura
-
Andrea Hermosa
-
Julia Gutierrez Caba
-
Joan Dalmau
-
Daniel Grao
-
Pablo Derqui
-
Oscar Foronda
-
Carlos Fabregas
Synopsis
Another of the many projects Guillermo del Toro has his dabs on, being lined up for everything from remakes of Dr. Jekyll And Mr. Hyde, the US version of The Orphanage, and The Creature From The Black Lagoon (yes please!), to an H.P. Lovecraft adaptation, At The Mountains of Madness, Julia's Eyes sees him returning to Spain and being reunited with Belen Rueda, the star of the superb The Orphanage, for which he was also responsible, and while reviews of this have been generally good, praising the ingenious set-up and performances, but also complaining that the pic, directed by Guillem Morales (2004's The Uninvited Guest), runs out of steam after the first hour, becoming extremely complicates as the mystery at its' heart is slowly unravelled. The excellent Rueda plays twin sisters, Julia and Sara, and the film opens with Sara hanging herself, the Police investigation, headed by Inspector Dimas (Francesc Orella - Disonarcha), deeming it to be suicide, although Julia, and her initially skeptical husband Isaac (Lluis Homar - Broken Embraces) is not convinced, and is determined to investigate in order to find the truth. Like her sister, Julia suffers from an inherited eye condition, from which she is slowly going blind, the condition being exacerbated by stress. She soon starts to think her sister's sinister neighbour, Blasco (Boris Ruiz), and his equally unsettling daughter Lia (Andrea Hermosa) are involved somehow, but as her sight worsens so she starts to find she is literally missing clues which are right in front of her, and starts to wonder whether she can trust what her reduced vision is letting her see, and when her husband vanishes Julia has to try to unravel what is happening with very reduced vision, director Morales using light, shade and digital fogging to give the viewer the POV of the increasingly handicapped woman, the final reel being a game of cat-and-mouse as Julia tries to evade the person behind the grim events, and some critics have pointed out that a vital scene, in which the face of someone vital to the plot is obscured in her POV, but is not so much a cheat as the clever use of the central plot device, as is the heightened use of sound as her sight fails. Not as effective as The Orphanage, Rueda still gives a reportedly excellent central performance, and the set-up is certainly clever, even if it cannot quite carry the plot and its' twists and turns quite to the end.
Production
- Director
- Guillem Morales
- Producer
- Joaquín Padro, Mar Targarona and Guillermo del Toro
- Art Director
- Balter Gallart
- Editor
- Joan Manel Vilaseca
- Music
- Fernando Velazquez
- Screenplay
- Guillem Morales and Oriol Paulo
- Director of Photography
- Oscar Faura
Review
A Spanish chiller starring the superb Belen Ruden, co-producer Guillermo del Toro reunites several key cast and crew from the magnificent The Orphanage (2007) for this intriguing horror / thriller, which never quite enters standard giallo territory, director Guillem Morales (The Uncertain Guest) preferring a more suspenseful and restrained approach which may frustrate some, but also produces a film which keeps the audience's attention, even when the script resorts to some outrageous cheats to keep the identity of one particular character shrouded, and the audience is probably half a step in front of the script at any given point. Interestingly both this and The Orphanage feature the same themes of loss and pain, the main character trying to discover what happened to a loved one who has vanished, and the plot device of the increasing blindness due to the sister's eye condition is both a gimmick and a cleverly worked plot strand, her sight deteriorating so she starts to fear that she literally cannot see the evidence, her husband, played by Lluis Homar, who ironically also played a blind man in Pedro Almodovar's Bad Education, assisting her, despite warning her of the effect her efforts could have on her sight before falling victim to the murderer himself. Some may complain that once the solution is approaching a number of escalating plot twists come one after the other, although one of them is truly surprising and affecting. Although never hitting the emotional heights of The Orphanage, Julia's Eyes is still a very effective package, with fine performances from both Ruden and Homar, and the technical side of things, reuniting many of the crew, with excellent photography by Oscar Faura showing Julia's POV as gradually escalating shades of grey as her sight deteriorates, and while some may think certain scenes, where a key character's face is deliberately fuzzy and obscured, is a cheat, it also works within the strictures of the optical condition. Belen is truly one of the best Spanish actresses currently working, and also perfect for the horror / thriller genre, and even if Julia's Eyes suffers slightly from the undue restraint of the director in certain areas, the cast and presentation, as well as a cleverly devious screenplay, make this a very enjoyable and effective production, another of the many projects Guillermo del Toro has his dabs on and another indicator of just how talented he is on both his own account and as a producer and talent-spotter.