Film details

The Stoning of Soraya M.  2010

Cast

  • Shohreh Aghdashloo
  • Mozhan Marnò
  • Navid Negahban
  • Ali Pourtash
  • David Daiann
  • Perviz Sayyad
  • Vida Ghahremani
  • Vachik Mangassarian
  • David Fariborz Davoodian
  • Maggie Parto
  • Bita Sheibani

Synopsis

Iran, 1986, and Freidoune Sahebjam, a French-Iranian journalist is driving through a remote area when his car breaks down. Managing to get to a nearby village he finds a mechanic capable of repairing his vehicle, and while he is passing time in the village is approached by a woman, Zahra, who tells him she has a terrible story for him which should be made known. The story she tells him concerns her niece, Soraya, married to Ali. Their union is unhappy, and Ali wants to marry another. a fourteen-year-old girl, and not have to support two spouses. He pressures the local Mullah to try to persuade Soraya to accept a divorce but she refuses. causing the Mullah to decree that she should have to cook and clean for Hashem, a local widower whose wife has recently died, as a penance for refusing her husband's orders. Ali and the Mullah conspire to have her accused of adultery, the punishment for which under Sharia law is death, forcing Hashem to become part of the conspiracy against her by threatening to have his young son taken away from him unless he testifies that he knows Soraya has been having an affair with another man, Zahra realises what is happening and goes to the local mayor to try to save her niece and expose Ali and the Mullah, but the Mayor, knowing the power of the religious officials, says he cannot intervene. A Sharia court is assembled, finding Soraya guilty on totally fabricated evidence and with no defence case allowed to be presented. Zahra and Soraya tries to escape from the village as the verdict is read, but are chased and trapped by the locals and dragged back into the village square. Soraya is beaten, buried up to her waist and stoned to death by the braying horde, a long, barbaric and prolonged process, taking her a long time to die of her wounds. Freidoune is stunned at this, yet more so when Zahra reveals that the vents occurred only the previous day, yet all evidence of the execution has already been cleaned up in the village square. Believing that he may have been told of Soraya's execution, the Mullah tries to stop the journalist leaving the village, not wanting the story of the barbaric murder to be made known to the outside world, taking the tape recorder Freidoune has used to record Zahra's testimony. The Mullah believes he has confiscated the vital evidence, but has not reckoned on the resourcefulness of the one person who most wants Soraya's fate made known.

Production

Director
Cyrus Nowrasteh
Producer
Stephen McEveety and John Shepherd
Art Director
Bradley Schmidt
Editor
David Handman and Geoffrey Rowland
Music
John Debney
Screenplay
Betsy Giffen Nowrasteh and Cyrus Nowrasteh, based on the book La Femme Lapidee by Freidoune Sahebjam
Director of Photography
Joel Ransom

Review

A drama set in the Iran of 1986, and based on a best-selling book, La Femme Lapidee by Freidoune Sahebjam, the absolute authenticity of which has been questioned in recent years, The Stoning Of Soraya M certainly has its' own point of view, co-produced by avowedly right-wing film company Mpower Pictures, the story is certainly damning of the Iranian regime, Sharia law, the Middle Eastern attitudes to women, and Islam in general, and makes a gruelling piece of viewing, even if one should probably approach this as more fictional and embroidered than the publicity and marketing may project. The tale has a man, Freidoune Sahebjam (played by a very oddly cast Jim Caviezel - The Passion Of The Christ), stranded in a remote Iranian village when his car breaks down, and being approached by Zahra (Shohreh Aghdashloo - House Of Sand And Fog / Saw III), a woman who wants to tell him the story of her niece, Soraya Manutchehri (Mozhan Marno - Traitor), and what happened to her, Married to the brutal Ghorban-Ali (Navid Hegahban - Brothers), who wants to dump her and marry a fourteen-year-old girl, but will not support two families or return the dowry paid by Soroya's family. When Soraya start to cook for a local widower, the husband of a late friend, he finds his excuse and accuses her of adultery, the village authorities passing the sentence that she should be stoned to death, a sentence which is inescapable under the ruthless Islamic regime. Although Freidoune Sahebjam is the son of a former Iranian ambassador, French-Iranian journalist and war correspondent who extensively reported on crimes reportedly committed by the Iranian government on their own people, there were definite questions about some of the details of the story raised at the time of publication, and while no one is saying such things do not happen to this day in Iran, stoning actually being written into the legislative statutes of the country, making it legal, and given a terrible topicality by what at time of release was happening in the disputed case of the accused Sakineh Ashtiani. Although one can understand the maker's instance on showing the actual stoning on the screen, to emphasise the sheer barbarity of the punishment, the long and extended sequence, oddly paralleling in some ways the almost torture-porn relish in which Caviezel suffered in The Passion, skewing the film from a drama into a gruesome and almost voyeuristic horror pic as the victim, buried up to the waist, is stoned to death with no angle, impact or laceration being missed by director Cyrus Nowrasteh's lingering camera. Adapted by the director and his wife from the original book, the film is also slanted remarkably by having every single woman a paragon of innocent virtue and goodness while every single Iranian man is a barely civilised drooling pervert, psychopath or ruthless sadist. One can understand the director's sincerity in wanting to expose the story to a wider audience, and no one can complain about the equally committed performances, but some may think that rather too many liberties have been taken in the efforts to vilify yet further, as if it were needed, the ruthless Iranian regime.