Cast
-
-
-
-
-
Sarah Gadon
-
Katherina Palm
-
Wladimir Matuchin
-
Franziska Arndt
-
Clemens Gisbei
-
Andrea Magro
-
Bjorn Geske
-
Christian Serritiello
Synopsis
1904. Sabina Spielrein, a young, hysterical and agitated woman is taken into a Swiss asylum, to be observed and put under the supervision of Carl Gustav Jung, a psychologist, who believes the way to treat her is to use 'the talking cure', a system of analysis devised by the famous Austrian Sigmund Freud. Jung finds she is an intelligent and well educated Jewish girl, who has an ambition to become a doctor, and he intrigues her, just as he is starting to become tired of his marriage to his repeatedly pregnant wife Emma. While feeling he is making progress with Sabina, Jung contacts Freud about her case, and is surprised at what he feels is Freud's caution in dealing with the field he has pioneered, often having to take on religious bodies and medical institutions who do not agree with his conclusions and suppositions. Sabina makes up her mind to become a psychoanalyst, just as she and Jung start to grow close to each other, despite his misgivings that she is one of his patients. Freud sends a patient to Jung, Otto Gross, a doctor who was formerly one of Freud's pupils who Freud has thought of as a possible heir to his title as a pioneer in the field, having developed his own controversial 'depth psychology', but Gross is now a shambles of a man, driven by an out-of-control libido which overwhelms all other motive functions. Jung finds himself unable to deal with Gross, or his problems, but after seeing how sexually driven the man is, living only for sybaritic pleasure, he begins an affair with Sabina. Gross breaks out of the asylum by climbing over the wall. Jung finds himself in an emotional cleft, still loving the wife who has given him children, and through her family fortune a very large, comfortable home and supported his practise, and Sabina, a beautiful passionate young woman who fascinates him for different reasons, and excites him with her demands that their relationship turns to the sado-masochistic, demanding he thrash her as it is the only way she can achieve satisfaction. Knowing that Jung supports the study of parapsychology, phenomena such as telepathy and prophecy, Freud warns him that his endorsement could lead to the enemies of all psychology to be able to dismiss it as just a crank theory. Worrying about both his marriage and his professional status, rumours of him having an affair with one of his patients being gossip in the salons of Vienna and Zurich, Jung tries to end his relationship with Sabina, but is unable to, still inalienably drawn to her and her masochistic nature. Having continued her studies, Sabina qualifies as a psychoanalyst in 1912 and moves to Vienna, continuing to research in the field with Freud, who has had several health scares. He and Jung become increasingly distant, their friendship turning to hostility, each complaining about the others theories and methods. Freud is angered about what he has discovered of Jung's treatment of Sabina, who he believes was vulnerable at the time of their affair and exploited, while Jung is furious that Freud's theories and methodology is totally dominant in the field. Jung and Freud never meet again, but in early 1914, Jung has a meeting with Sabina, where each discovers what has happened in the lives of the other, and wonder what might have been.
Production
- Director
- David Cronenberg
- Producer
- Jeremy Thomas
- Art Director
- Sebastian Soukup (supervisor)
- Editor
- Ronald Sanders
- Music
- Howard Shore
- Screenplay
- Christopher Hampton, based on the play The Talking Cure by Christopher Hampton, based on the book A Most Dangerous Method by John Kerr
- Director of Photography
- Peter Suschitzky
Review
Having finally got rid of the various labels which got attached to him in the early days of his career, such as the Sultan of Slime, after such uncomfortably visceral films as Shivers, Rabid and The Brood, David Cronenberg is finally being seen and appreciated as one of the most interesting and genuinely intelligent directors currently working, shifting genres constantly from such divisive and confrontational works as Crash to a genuinely affecting psychological drama in Spider, and a terrific London-set crime movie in Eastern Promises. a truly undervalued piece of work. Cronenberg is reunited with his Eastern leads, Viggo Mortensen, and a small almost cameo role for Vincent Cassel, with Mortensen playing the father of psychoanalysis, Sigmund Freud, opposite the other scholar and claimant to that title, Michael Fassbender (Inglourious Basterds) as Carl Gustav Jung, Both men were pivotal in the evolution and acceptance of psychiatry and psychoanalysis, and the screenplay by Christopher Hampton, based on his own play A Talking Cure, itself based on the book A Most Dangerous Method by John Kerr, focuses on the rivalry between the men, not only because of their groundbreaking work, which it has to be remembered at the time was regarded as at best radical and by some to be truly dangerous and evil, threatening society, but also because of their shared relationship with a young woman, Sabina Spielrein (Kiera Knightley - Never Let Me Go), who was a patient under Jung, then having an unorthodox affair with Jung, despite the ethical problem this caused him, as well as the fact that his wife, Emma (Sarah Gadon - Dream House), who could truly be called long suffering, not only bore him several children but was also independently very wealthy, allowing Jung to live in a luxury, and indulge in non-profitable cases such as Sabina's, which a doctor without such funding would not have been able to pursue in such depth. Cassel, always a compulsive screen presence, plays Otto Gross, a Freudian disciple who became a psychotherapist in his own right before becoming a violent anarchist, which is perfect casting for Monsieur Cassel but also shows just how the practise of psychotherapy, and those involved in it, were often regarded with, at least, skeptcism and at worst genuine fear. Actually Sabina Spielrein has almost been an industry on her own account, being the subject of three - count 'em three - stage plays, Sabina in 1996 by Willy Holtzman, an identically titled Snoo Wilson play two years later, and Hampton's own, which was first performed in 2003, as well as a fictionalised version of her life, Prendimi L'Anima / The Soul Keeper, directed by Roberto Faenza in 2002 with Emilia Fox in the lead with Iain Glen as Jung, and also a documentary, Ich Heib Sabina Spielrein / My Name Is Sabina Spielrein, also made in 2002 by Elisabeth Marton, showing just what an impact the woman had in her own field. Although the tabloids have fixated on a couple of brief scenes, showing the intensity of the S/M affair between Jung and Sabina, all the more effective through being shown non-sensationally but purely as the interactions between two consenting people, although Jung's discomfort at inflicting such pain on a woman he has come to love is obvious, the scenes seem perfectly fitting in a story which deals with often uneasy mental states and heightened emotions. The central performances are all exceptional, with Mortensen being an imposing and authoritative Freud, although perhaps somewhat more sturdy than contemporary photographs of the man may suggest, and Jung is played with a measure of both respect and independence by Fassbender, but the revelation is Knightly, superb as the conflicted and increasingly confident and determine patient turned teacher. A very different sort of subject for Cronenberg to tackle, but when one considers it concerns, psychosis, rivalry and sexual jealousy is actually perfect for the director, now well into his sixties, who is showing genuine maturity and truly assured handling of his material, which one would not have thought he was capable of four decades ago.