Cast
-
-
Niels Arestrup
-
-
-
Melusine Mayance
-
Frederic Pierrot
-
Dominique Frot
-
Gisele Casadesus
-
Natasha Mashkevich
-
Arben Bajraktaraj
-
Sarah Ber
-
Karina Hin
Synopsis
Paris, 1942, and the French Police begin a city-wide round-up of Parisian Jews, sending thirteen thousand of them to be penned in the Velodrome d'Hiver. When the Police arrive to arrest her family, Sarah Starzynski, ten years old, hides her younger brother, Michel, in a cupboard, so that he escapes being taken away with them. Six decades later, in 2002, Julia Jarmond, an American journalist living in Paris, is working on an article on what is known as the D'Hiver Round-Up. Her research throws up the fact that her husband's family apartment was originally owned by the Starzynski family, and the family, the Tezacs, moved in only a month after the Starzynskis were forcibly removed, never to be heard from again, Julia discovers she is pregnant, something she has longed-for, but when she tells her husband, Bertrand, he is at first shocked and then simmeringly angry. Julia continues to research the story of the Starzynski's eventually piecing what happened to Sarah, she managing to escape the transit camp the prisoners were transferred to on their way to the concentration camps, being aided by a sympathetic couple, Jules and Genevivre Dufaure, in a small village. When she eventually gets back to Paris and into the now-occupied apartment, she finds Michel's body in the cupboard. Julia's father-in-law, Edouard, has known about this for sixty years, but never talked about it, telling Julia that they instead sent Sarah back to the Dufaures, paying for her to live with them. Needing to know what has happened to Sarah, Julia discovers that she was married in America in 1955, but Julia does not know how she got there, Bertrand tries to convince Julia to have an abortion, but she refuses and leaves him, going to New York having tracked Sarah's American family down to Brooklyn. From them she learns that Sarah was killed in 1966 in a car accident, the circumstances of which seem unclear, but that she left a son, William, who is now in his late forties and living in Italy. Visiting him there, he rejects the story she tells him of her mother, and the horrors she experienced as a child, refusing to believe her, but what she discovers from another source makes Sarah realise that the story she had managed to unearth is all too true, and that the truth has been kept from William for many years.
Production
- Director
- Gilles Paquet-Brenner
- Producer
- Stephane Marsil
- Art Director
- Francoise Dupertuis
- Editor
- Herve Schneid
- Music
- Max Richter
- Screenplay
- Gilles Paquet-Brenner and Serge Joncour, based on the novel by Tatiana De Rosnay
- Director of Photography
- Pascal Ridao
Review
Two very separate storylines run through the French drama Sarah's Key, one set in the present-day and the other decades earlier in World War Two, the two coming together through the character of Julia Jarmond (Kristin Scott Thomas - Tell No One / Leaving), an American journalist living in France with her family and who discovers, while investigating the use of a velodrome as a holding camp for French Jews during the War prior to transportation to the concentration camps, the story of Sarah Starzynski (Melusine Mayance), a young girl whose family was arrested by the collaborating French Police, but before they leave their apartment she locked her younger brother in a closet, expecting to be able to come back later and free him. That particular storyline ends, not unexpectedly tragically, and oddly Sarah's Key is released in the UK only six weeks after another film dealing with the shameful events in the D'Hiver velodrome in 1942, Rose Bosch's The Round-Up, suggesting a definite shift in French mainstream cinema to face up to the staggering levels of collaboration and collusion of the French government and authorities with the Nazis. Taken from a best-selling novel, the problem is yet another of transition from the page to the screen, since once the first story has been established, the story of the young Sarah and fate she and her family face, the mopeings of Scott Thomas in some very comfortable and affluent Parisian locations inevitably seem rather less important, and as her investigations reveal more of the story of Sarah, and more pointedly the involvement of her French in-laws, so it oddly seems to matter less, since anybody involved at the time in any meaningful capacity would in at least their late seventies, and Scott Thomas' character seems to at times be more concerned by her inability to become pregnant rather than bring the story she is researching to any sort of actual closure. While the film, eventually, deals with a very thorny subject, survivor guilt, it is also handled clumsily, with the introduction late-on of Aiden Quinn (Avalon) as Sarah's unwary son, which should be the climatic ending, but still has to be dragged out and even go into another time period before an conveniently all-too-neat ending. Directed and co-written by Gilles Paquet-Brenner (Payoff / Walled Up), the early wartime scenes, such as the internment at the velodrome, and the scenes of the arrivals at the camps are harrowing, but it is also predictable what will happen when Sarah eventually gets to Paris, setting a mark which the contemporaneous story struggles to ever match, while a fine cast includes Niels Arestrup (A Prophet), Frederic Pierrot (Monsieur N.), Michel Duchaussoy (the Mesrine duo) and Dominique Frot (Father Of My Children). Sarah's Key is a story which raises uncomfortable questions within French government and society which have been largely and conveniently ignored for decades, and which appears to be becoming drawn more and more out into the open, but so much so that the other storyline involving a well-off and pampered reporter with the baby blues just really doesn't matter.