Cast
-
Robert Pattinson
-
-
-
James Frain
-
-
Paul Schneider
-
Tim Guinee
-
Ken Foree
-
Brad Greenquist
-
Calvin Dean
-
Dan Lauria
-
Adrienne Rusk
Synopsis
There's a very interesting cast in the film version of Water For Elephants, originally published in 2006 and written by Sara Gruen, which rather worryingly the authoress says is essentially a retelling of the story of Jacob in the Bible's Book of Jacob, but relocated to a 1920's circus, which is quite some relocation. Eccentric story aside, and it is a very odd one indeed, this has to be seen as a litmus test for the viability of Robert Pattinson (or R-Patz, we've got all the lingo) in a film where he isn't a fey and wan vampire, and since the Twilight Saga will finally go dark in 2012 after Breaking Dawn Part 2 its' a moot point to see what sort of career, if any, he will have post-Edward Cullen, is previous leading role in a non-Twilight pic, Remember Me, got pretty poor reviews and wasn't a b.o. hit. This is one bizarre story indeed, being the reminiscences of Jacob Jankowski, a man in his nineties, and played by Hal Holbrook (The Fog / Capricorn One) in a nursing home, reminiscing about his past, and how, as a young man (Pattinson) during the Great Depression, he abandons his medical studies after the death of his parents and joined a travelling circus, the Benzini Brothers, travelling from town to town by train, to work as their veterinary, bringing him into contact with many interestingly off-kilter characters including August Rosenbluth (Christophe Waltz - Inglourious Basterds), the head animal trainer and the husband of Marlena (Reese Witherspoon - Walk The Line), the circus' star performer and the person who cares for the company's horses. August is alternately kid and brutal towards animals and the company alike, and the circus owner, known only as Al, is borderline psychopathic, and is known for throwing performers and staff off the moving train if they have displeased him, and doing it while the train is going over a bridge if he suspects them of having cheated or swindled him. The main plot device of the book is when Al buts Rosie, an elephant, who seems unable to understand standard commands until it is revealed that she only understands Polish, which Jacob speaks, meaning he is the only one who can establish a rapport with her, while also falling in love with Marlena, which puts him into grave danger, but since he's telling this in flashback it's a good bet to believe he survives. Francis Lawrence (Constantine / I Am Legend) directs this eccentric tale, which seems to balance brutality and whimsy, and the extremely odd cast also includes British actor James Frain (TV's The Tudors), Paul Schneider (Bright Star), Tim Guinee (John Carpenter's Vampires), and Ken Foree (Dawn Of The Dead), but the success of the pic is purely down to whether the massed ranks of the 'Twihards' will pay to see their idol mucking out an elephant....
Production
- Director
- Francis Lawrence
- Producer
- Gil Metter, Erwin Stoff and Andrew R. Tennenbaum
- Art Director
- David Crank
- Editor
- Alan Edward Bell
- Music
- James Newton Howard
- Screenplay
- Richard LaGravenese, based on the novel by Sara Gruen
- Director of Photography
- Rodrigo Prieto
Review
The idea of having Richard LaGravenese (The Fisher King / A Little Princess) write the screenplay for the film version of Water For Elephants, originally published in 2006 and written by Sara Gruen, which rather worryingly the authoress claims is essentially a retelling of the story of Jacob in the Bible's Book of Jacob, relocated to a 1920's circus, is a clever one, the author's dabblings with 'magic realism' and borderline fantasy being particularly fitting for this extremely dreamlike and very romantic piece of work, in which realism and a far more ethereal atmosphere clash into a strangely watchable and evocative whole, as one doesn't take it too seriously. Eccentric story aside, this is virtually a litmus test for the viability of Robert Pattinson (or R-Patz, we've got all the lingo) in a film where he isn't a fay and wan vampire, but in a rather calculated move bound to appeal to the hoards of 'Twihards', his character, Jacob Jankowski, a man in his nineties, and played by Hal Holbrook (The Fog / Capricorn One) in a nursing home, reminiscing about his past, and how, as a young man (Pattinson) during the Great Depression, he abandoned his veterinary studies after the death of his parents and joined the Benzini travelling circus as their vet, travelling from town to town by train, bringing him into contact with many interestingly off-kilter characters including August Rosenbluth (Christophe Waltz - Inglourious Basterds), the head animal trainer and the husband of Marlena (Reese Witherspoon - Walk The Line), the circus' star performer and who cares for the company's horses. Both are well cast, with Witherspoon being as luminous as expected in a role originally intended for Scarlett Johannson and Waltz giving another frighteningly complex characterisation, turning August, who could be a pretty one-dimentional bully and sadist into someone far deeper and fascinating, taking this in a far more interesting direction than the basic love story set against a fantastical circus background would suggest. The main plot device comes when August buys Rosie, an elephant, who seems unable to understand standard commands until it is revealed that she only understands Polish, which Jacob speaks, meaning he is the only one who can establish a rapport with her, while also falling in love with Marlena, which puts him into grave danger, but since he's telling this in flashback it's a good bet to believe he survives, which does slacken the tension rather, but since Waltz makes such a convincing borderline psycho that it is entirely possible that his rage will be vented against the almost ridiculously slight and defenceless Marlena. Francis Lawrence (Constantine / I Am Legend) directs this eccentric tale, which balances brutality, sentimentality and whimsy, and the extremely odd cast also includes British actor James Frain (TV's The Tudors), Paul Schneider (Bright Star), Tim Guinee (John Carpenter's Vampires) and the substantial Ken Foree (Dawn Of The Dead), There is certainly a degree of burnishing in LaGravenese's script, with such events as putting an animal down given the same sort of lyrical makeover as marlena riding her horses or, eventually, Rosie, but Lawrence displays a fine visual eye, several sequences being visually captivating, including Jacob being led down the circus train and introduced to the wide cast of performers and staff, very quickly establishing without words the general pecking order in the troupe. Having had his only other major non-Twilight role, in the overwrought drama Remember Me, thoroughly rubbished and being a box-office flop, Pattinson acquits himself well, showing there is perhaps a life post-vampires, but what the actor really needs is a role which stretches him, which Water For Elephants, as watchable as it, doesn't.