Film details

All Good Things  2010

Cast

  • Ryan Gosling
  • Frank Langella
  • Jeffrey Dean Morgan
  • Kristen Wiig
  • Diane Venora
  • John Cullum
  • Lily Rabe
  • Michael Esper
  • Nick Offerman
  • Maggie Kiley

Synopsis

New York City, the 1970s. David Marks, the son of Sanford Marks, a powerful and influential real estate tycoon, falls in love with Katie McCarthy, a beautiful student from a working-class background, and marries her. Together they leave the city, returning to the country life for a quieter, less pressured life in Vermont, only for David to be lured back to NYC by the demands of his father, taking Katie with him. Katie returns to college and eventually applies to study at medical school while also trying to cope with David's sudden and often aggressive mood swings and trying to understand his unwillingness to have children. As Katie becomes increasingly independent, and the pair seem to be drifting apart, David mysteriously turns more openly violent and controlling. Secrets the Marks family have tried to keep hidden are revealed, and then Katie disappears without a trace, never to be seen again. After months of investigation, and with David as their main suspect, the Police call off the search, and Katie is eventually presumed dead. With no evidence against him, David remains free. Two decades pass, but when David's best friend Lauren Fleck turns up dead, seemingly killed execution-style, the twenty-year-old case is re-opened, David once again being considered the main suspect, and the Marks family's dark past seems to is about to be dragged out into the open once and for all.

Production

Director
Andrew Jarecki
Producer
Andrew Jarecki, Michael London, Bruna Papandrea and Marc Smerling
Art Director
Russell Barnes
Editor
David Rosenbloom and Shelby Siegel
Music
Rob Simonson
Screenplay
Marcus Hinchey and Marc Smerling
Director of Photography
Michael Seresin

Review

Despite the interesting line-up of (at the time) new talent in the form of Ryan Gosling (Blue Valentine / Drive) and Kirsten Dunst (Elizabethtown / Wimbledon), All Good Things, directed by documentarist Andrew Jarecki (Capturing The Friedmans), making his first narrative feature, and based on a genuine controversial New York high society murder case, had surprising trouble in actually getting released, being shot between April and July 2008 but then having the initial US opening date of July 2009 cancelled, as were several others before the film was relinquished by original distributors The Weinstein Company and passed onto another, Magnolia Pictures, which managed a token release in November 2010. In the UK the film went straight-to-disc in February 2013, by which time Gosling and Dunst were certainly very established in their careers, all of which might just tip one off that not all is well here. Scripted by Marcus Hinchey and Marc Smerling, the film is largely based on the story of the accused murderer Robert Durst, a real estate heir whose first wife, Kathleen McCormack, disappeared in 1982, and whose best friend was also found murdered years later, taking the real life story into truly bizarre territory, with many people believing that justice was not property exercised in the case of Robert Durst, and may feel pretty much the same about this fictionalised version of events. As good as the leads are, with Frank Langella (Frost/Nixon / Robot And Frank) showing that he really is one of the best characters actors currently working, as the controlling, imperious Sanford Marks, based on Durst's own real estate baron father Seymour Durst, Jarecki has a very strong supporting cast, including Jeffrey Dean Morgan (The Losers / The Possession), Kristen Wiig (Bridesmaids), Philip Baker Hall (Dogville / Zodiac), Diana Venora (Heat), John Cullum (TV's Northern Exposure) and Lily Rabe (No Reservations / TV's American Horror Story), and reputedly filmed 'hundreds of hours' of interviews with those involved, Durst himself not contributing, and those who knew the real protagonists, but the characters still remain strangely vague, despite the committed performances. The real Robert Durst is known to be very unhappy with the film, what a pity, and it certainly seems to be a pretty accurate depiction of the actual events, albeit with altered names and some locations, but the film cannot quite get to the core of the David Marks character, his motivations never being made clear, probably because writer / director Jarecki can't fathom them, but Gosling is always compulsively watchable on screen, even in such a strange, indefinable portrayal.