Film details

One Day  2011

Cast

  • Anne Hathaway
  • Jim Sturgess
  • Romola Garai
  • Jodie Whittaker
  • Rafe Spall
  • Jamie Sives
  • Ken Stott
  • Georgia King
  • Sarah Jane O'Neill
  • Matthew Beard
  • Amanda Fairbank-Hynes

Synopsis

15th July, 1988, St. Swithin's Day. Emma Morley, a studious and bookish Northerner, and Dexter Mayhew, the son of wealthy parents, have an abortive one-night stand, the day after graduating from the same university in Edinburgh. It doesn't go well for either of them but the pair remain friends for the next two decades, always arranging to meet on the same day each year in order to catch up with what has happened in their lives, the 15th July. Dexter finds success and becomes a popular TV presenter, using his easy charm and wit, while Emma, despite her academic success and qualifications, is stuck working as a waitress in a Mexican restaurant. Years pass, and the two continue to meet regularly. Emma finds a boyfriend in Ian, an aspiring stand-up comedian, moving in with him, and decides to retrain as a teacher rather than go with the degrees she already holds. After slipping into alcoholism and drug abuse, Dexter eventually loses his job, and finds his popularity dropping away badly. After one meeting, Emma is disgusted by his behaviour, he still being in the grip of his addictions, and decides to end their relationship. They do not see each other for four years, but when both go to the wedding of a mutual friend, they are reunited by the intervention of a well-meaning mutual friend. Emma has since broken up with Ian, but by this time Dexter is engaged, his bride-to-be being Sylvie, the daughter of an upper class family and who is pregnant with Dexter's child. They eventually marry, Emma finding herself feeling a loss when she hears the news, Dexter's child turns out to be a girl, Jasmine. Emma tries not to think of him or how he seems to be settled and happy, then later hears that the pair have filed for divorce after Sylvie had an affair with another man, one of Dexter's university friends. Years pass, and by 2003 Emma has made major changes in her life, and is now a very successful children's book author, and is living in Paris. Dexter visits her, having decided to open his heart and declare his love for her. Having felt the same about him for fifteen years, yet being unable, through emotions or circumstances, to tell him, Emma tells him she loves him too and the pair become a couple. They marry, and the next three years are joyful, but their efforts to have a child of their own are unsuccessful. But then something happens which proves that the future is never what we are expecting, and that everything can change in a second.

Production

Director
Lone Scherfig
Producer
Nina Jacobson
Art Director
Denis Schnegg (supervisor)
Editor
Barney Pilling
Music
Rachel Portman
Screenplay
David Nicholls, based on his own novel
Director of Photography
Benoit Delhomme

Review

Director Lone Scherfig was always one of the more interesting directors working in the Dogma movement, and how long ago that now seems, the making such impressive films as the oddly charming Italian for Beginners and the award-winning An Education, and making English language films before many of her Scandinavian contemporaries. One Day, based on the huge bestseller by David Nicholls, scripted by the writer, is based on the theme that the future is never going to be as one planned it, and no one can know what it brings, which ironically is exactly the opposite of what many viewers will be expecting, knowing the book and in some cases decrying every change and alteration from the printed page, the most obvious of these being the casting of American Anne Hathaway (The Princess Diaries / The Devil Wears Prada) as Emma, who in the book is slightly owlish, very Yorkshire and, although Hathaway makes a good stab at the accent, wanders through most of the uppers Shires and all points north. Jim Sturgess (The Other Boelyn Girl / The Way Back) is rather more accurate casting as Dexter, the upper-class student who meets Hathaway's Emma as they extricate themselves from an awkward night together after graduating from the University of Edinburgh on 15 July, St. Swithin's Day, and vow to meet again, on the same day every year, the film follows them through twenty years of such meetings as their lives change, their relationships change them as well as their circumstances, and their friendship alters over the decades. Of course the obvious thing for them to do, knowing what they feel about each other, would be to get together, but of course their lives are too difficult and involved with others by this point for them to do that, they seeing their yearly meetings as a way of catching-up, and a reminder of the times they had, The problem with dealing with such a bestseller, and one which is also written in such a distinctive style, us that the episodic nature of the piece means that at times the pic is little more than a series of vignettes, some more effective than others, and the fact that the film runs at its' own pace, bringing the viewer ailing with it, means that some of the more important twists have actually less effect than if it were being read, and where certain ends of chapters can have so much more emotional effect. Scherfig manages to pull off a delicate balancing act, making two characters who are less than perfect, but, as the audience knows, are perfect for each other, and despite complaints from the purists, both Hathaway and Sturgess are well chosen. Apart from Patricia Clarkson (Lars And The Real Girl / Shutter Island), the rest of the cast is top UK talent, including Romola Garai (I Capture The Castle), Jodie Whittaker (Venus), Ken Stott (TV's Rebus), Rafe Spall (Hot Fuzz), amiable and well cast as Emma's boyfriend Ian, and Sarah Jane O'Neill (Clash Of The Titans remake) which is a line-up impressive enough for a couple of films. Even if one is inevitably reminded of the 1978 Alan Alda / Ellen Burstyn comedy / drama Same Time, Next Year, adapted from a stage play, and which as a very similar premise, if dealing with two older people, the director and cast combine to make a very creditable version of a book some may think unfilmable, through both structure and the sheer tangled net of emotions involved.