Cast
-
Michael Parks
-
Michael Angarano
-
-
Kyle Gallner
-
-
Stephen Root
-
Nicholas Braun
-
Kerry Bishe
-
Alexa Nicolas
-
Betty Aberlin
-
Kaylee DeFer
-
Ralph Garman
Synopsis
Kevin Smith's Red State was one of the main talking points at the Sundance Film Festival of 2011, and not for the right reasons wither, protests against the film by some previously unknown right-wing Christian groups proving to be hoaxes organised by Smith himself, with the protesters being paid volunteers, and a much-heralded public auction of the film's distribution rights turning out to be another stunt, Smith assembling some of the most influential buyers in the film business in a cinema and then announcing, after a lecture on how iniquitous the film distribution business is, that he would be distributing the film himself, 'roadshow' style, taking the film from city to city, and insisting that audiences would pay 'probably six, seven, maybe ten times' the normal price of a ticket to see the film and a live Q&A with him, which takes egotism to a degree which even Smith had seemed incapable of. A combination of terrible reviews and general animosity towards Smith, including a lack of theatres willing to book him and his pic, resulted in a box-office dud, the film taking barely $850,000 (@£519,210) against a $4.5 million (@£2.74m) budget and Smith, who had also declared he would be handling DVD and VOD sales himself through his own distribution office, handing over the ancillary rights to Lionsgate in the UK. Red State, referring to those states in the US run by the Republicans, seems initially to be a teen horror pic, with a religious faction led by a maniacal Hellfire preacher, Abin Cooper (Michael Parks - Kill Bill 1&2), protesting at the funerals of gay hate-crime victims, celebrating the murders, with Cooper and his sidekick Sarah (a surprisingly cast Melissa Leo - The Fighter) being so extreme even avowed neo-Nazis will not be affiliated with them, Of course Copper is actually responsible for the deaths he protests at, being a psychotic with a hatred of gays which has he and members of his flocks luring gay men into traps and literally crucifying them. Cooper sees immorality in all forms, and has also lured three young boys, Travis (Michael Angarano - The Forbidden Kingdom), Jarod (Kyle Gallner - Nightmare On Elm Street remake) and Billy Ray (Nicholas Braun - Chalet Girl) to a supposed assignation with a young woman, but the three accidentally surprise the local Sheriff (Michael Root) in the bushes with a young man, and he becoming intent that they won't reveal his secret. Following them to Cooper's lair, the twist is that the murderous Sheriff is trying to get in, as the three are trying to get out of the nightmarish Saw / Hostel-inspired house of horror, Cooper and his cult being tooled up with everything from razors to AK-47s. Things then get defused and more than a little confusing when John Goodman (Barton Fink) appears as Keenan, an Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms agent sent to knock off Cooper and disband the cult rather then have another Waco situation. Unfortunately this is all punctuated by long monologues, generally from the ranting cult members, and long stretches of Goodman who, fine actor though he is, some people have said appears to be in some scenes which come from a different film altogether, totally dissipating any sense of tension of menace, and the brief chase and skirmish scenes are confused a juddery, the audience rarely being able to see what is actually going on. The general critical opinion was that it was so calculated to offend, with its' portrayal of insane murderous Christians, and a closeted Sheriff wanting to kill the people who know his secret, plus some extremely over-the-top violence that it became the one thing Smith has always claimed he hates in cinema - predictable, as if working off a checklist of outrages to be included. And of course there are the unmistakable similarities to Robert Hartford Davis' notorious British pic Beware The Brethren (aka The Fiend). Six, seven, maybe even ten times the price of a ticket? Get your head examined.
Production
- Director
- Kevin Smith
- Producer
- Jonathan Gordon
- Art Director
- Susan Bolles
- Editor
- Kevin Smith
- Screenplay
- Kevin Smith
- Director of Photography
- David Klein
Review
Kevin Smith's Red State was one of the main talking points at the 2011 Sundance Film Festival, and not for the right reasons either, protests against the film by some previously unknown right-wing Christian groups proving to be hoaxes organised by Smith himself, the protesters being paid stooges, and a much-heralded public auction of the film's distribution rights turning out to be another stunt, Smith assembling some of the most influential buyers in the film business in a cinema and then announcing that he would distribute the film himself, 'roadshow' style, taking the film from city to city, and insisting that audiences would pay 'probably six, seven, maybe ten times' the normal price of a ticket to see the film and a live Q&A with him, which takes egotism to a degree which even Smith seemed incapable of. A combination of terrible reviews and general animosity towards Smith, including a lack of theatres willing to book him and his pic, resulted in a box-office dud, the film taking barely $850,000 (@£519,210) against a $4.5 million (@£2.74m) budget, Smith, who had also declared he would be handling DVD and VOD sales himself through his own distribution office, handing over the ancillary rights to Lionsgate. So much for that. Red State, referring to those states in the US run by the Republicans, seems initially to be a teen horror pic, with a bunch of three particularly naive but irrepressibly horny youngsters, Travis (Michael Angarano - The Forbidden Kingdom), Jarod (Kyle Gallner - Nightmare On Elm Street remake) and Billy Ray (Nicholas Braun - Chalet Girl), falling for an internet lure sent by Sara (Melissa Leo - Frozen River), and falling into the clutches of a cult headed by maniacal preacher Abin Cooper (Michael Parks - Kill Bill 1 & 2), obviously based on the hate-filled Westboro Baptist Church clan, protesting at the funerals of gay men, when they have been responsible for the murders themselves. When the boys are trapped in the cult's compound, and an unwary Deputy is shot, the closeted gay Sheriff (Stephen Root - Everything Must Go), himself the victim of blackmail by the Reverend, calls in the AFT, led by John Goodman (Matinee / The Artist), who is essentially given orders by his superiors to wipe out the cult entirely, unsubtle allusions to the Ruby Ridge and Waco sieges. Unfortunately this is all punctuated by long monologues, generally from the ranting cult members, and long stretches of Goodman who, fine actor though he is, seems to be in some scenes which come from a different film altogether, totally dissipating any sense of tension of menace, and the brief chase and skirmish scenes are confused and juddery due to unsteady hand-held digital lensing, the audience rarely being able to see what is actually going on. Red State is completely calculated to offend, with its' portrayal of insane murderous Christians, and a closeted Sheriff wanting to keep his secret, plus some extremely over-the-top violence with an even-handed approach to knocking off characters, both goodies and buddies, but the film quickly becomes the one thing Smith has always claimed he hates in cinema - predictable, as if working off a checklist of outrages to be included, and although subtlety is a word he probably cannot spell, the film would have been a lot more daring and genuinely subversive had the character of Cooper been a calmer, outwardly kinder, more calculating character rather than a howling, bug-eyed maniac. And of course there are the unmistakable similarities to Robert Hartford Davis' notorious 1972 British pic Beware My Brethren (aka The Fiend), which has a very similar premise but handled infinitely better. Six, seven, maybe even ten times the price of a ticket? Get your head examined.