Cast
-
Vincent Gallo
-
-
Stig Frode Henriksen
-
Nicolai Cleve Broch
-
David Price
-
Philip Goss
-
Klaudia Kaca
-
Robert Mazurkiewicz
-
Zach Cohen
-
Torgrim Odegard
-
Dariusz Juzyszyn
-
Lars Markus Verpeide Bakke
Synopsis
Raising more than a few eyebrows when it picked up the special Jury Prize at the 2010 Venice Film Festival, Jerzy Skolimowski's Essential Killing, which also won a highly unexpected Best Actor award for Vincent Gallo as a Taliban Afghan prisoner, didn't quite surprise or indeed outrage as much as some of the awards given out that night, but with Quentin Tarantino as the jury chairman one has to expect a few unorthodox choices, and although Jerzy Skolimowski's pic got mild reviews at best, at least it didn't get the onslaught of ruthless reviews the other main prizewinner, Alex De La Ingleas' The Lost Circus, did. His second film since his return to film making, Skolimowski's 2008 pic Four Nights With Anna being his first production after seventeen years away, Essential Killing, written by the director and his partner Ewa Piaskowska, is a drama / adventure set almost entirely outdoors, and in freezing conditions, but takes a promising set-up and stretches the laws of credibility and coincidence to extreme levels, even though the director has insisted that the piece is a parable or allegory, which may not entirely silence audience complaints about some of the more implausible plot turns. Gallo, whose own film making career seems to have stalled, and we wonder why, plays Mohammed, although no names are used in the entire film, the denomination only being seen in the end credits, an Afghan Taliban who is captured by Americans after he ambushes, perhaps accidentally, two Americans on a reconnaissance expedition. Taken to a base and, inevitably, waterboarded, his interrogators take his silence for recalcitrance, even though he cannot hear their questions through having been deafened by an exploitation. Flown to another base with several other coves in orange jumpsuits, while being driven to another sinister location, he not even knowing which country he is in, the truck is involved in an accident and he is free, escaping through a forest deep in snow even though he is barefoot and has no clothes but the orange togs. Veering dangerously to being a terrorist version of The Fugitive, the location is eventually revealed to be the forests of Poland, and no matter what the script throws at him in terms of tumbles, falls, accidents and injuries, Mohammed still somehow manages to survive, and that is essentially that, the film being largely wordless, no background being given on the central character apart to some brief flashbacks to a mosque, which are apparently less than enlightening, and the only other significant character, a woman played by Emmanuelle Seigner (Frantic), who appears near the end, turns out to be mute, which will certainly cut down on the sub-titling bills for foreign distributors. What critics seemed to complain about the most was that it was largely pointless, and comparing it to watching some sort of endurance test as the Gallo character looks yet more miserable as he tumbles into another snow-covered gully, or regards yet more and more miles of snowy wilderness. Tarantino may have been enthusiastic but other audiences are liable to be less so, although of course there are a large number willing to shell out to see the deeply unpleasant Gallo waterboarded, for real.
Production
- Director
- Jerzy Skolimowski
- Producer
- Eva Piaskowska and Jerzy Skolimowski
- Art Director
- Joanna Kaczynska
- Editor
- Reka Lemhenyi
- Music
- Pawel Mykletyn
- Screenplay
- Eva Piaskowska and Jerzy Skolimowski
- Director of Photography
- Adam Sikora
Review
Raising more than a few eyebrows when it picked up the Special Jury Prize at the 2010 Venice Film Festival, Jerzy Skolimowski's Essential Killing, which also won a highly unexpected Best Actor award for Vincent Gallo as a Taliban Afghan prisoner, didn't quite surprise or indeed outrage as much as some of the awards given out that night, but with Quentin Tarantino as the jury chairman one had to expect a few unorthodox choices, and although Jerzy Skolimowski's pic got mild reviews at best, the awards can be described as unexpected at best and undeserved if one is being rather more candid. His second film since his return to film making, Skolimowski's 2008 pic Four Nights With Anna being his first production after seventeen years away, Essential Killing is a piece of work which seems to exist in its' own bubble, an extreme story where one is supposed to sympathise with a jihadist who kills three people as the film begins, claiming more as the film progresses, including an innocent woodsman whom he turns his own chainsaw on, before a final reel which finally takes the film into fantasy territory, making one wonder if any of this has actually happened at all. Written by the director and his partner Ewa Piaskowska, is a drama / adventure set almost entirely outdoors, and in freezing conditions, but takes a promising set-up and stretches the laws of credibility and coincidence to extreme levels, even though the director has insisted that the piece is a parable or allegory, which may not entirely silence audience complaints about some of the more implausible plot turns, almost becoming an essential version of The Fugitive, as Vincent Gallo's jihadist Mohammed, the name only being gleaned from the production notes, he never being named in the film in which there is actually very little dialogue, is flown to a European airbase after being captured in Afghanistan, and being temporarily deafened, and while being driven to another sinister location, he not even knowing which country he is in, the truck is involved in an accident and he is free, escaping through a forest deep in snow even though he is barefoot. The location is eventually revealed to be the forests of Poland, and no matter what the script throws at him in terms of tumbles, falls, accidents and injuries, Mohammed still somehow manages to survive, and that is essentially that, with no background being given on the central character apart to some brief flashbacks to a mosque, and the only other significant character, a woman played by Emmanuelle Seigner (Frantic), turns out to be mute, which certainly cuts down on sub-titling bills for foreign distributors. What Berlin critics seemed to complain about the most was that it was largely pointless, and comparing it to watching some sort of endurance test as the Gallo character looks yet more miserable as he tumbles into another snow-covered gully, or regards yet more and more miles of snowy wilderness. Tarantino may have been enthusiastic but other audiences will be less so, although of course there are a large number willing to shell out to see the deeply unpleasant Gallo waterboarded, for real. Skolimowski seems to be a director whose work was largely being re-evaluated in 2011, when there was also a re-release of his largely neglected 1970 London-shot Deep End, but there are many who believe that he is a director who really does not merit the accolade when his entire body of work is looked at, earning the veteran tag only through still being behind the camera aged 73, and Essential Killing is going to do little to change that opinion.