Film details

Margin Call  2011

Cast

Synopsis

2008. As the world financial markets start to appear vulnerable, there is a spate of redundancies at a major Wall Street bank, veteran senior risk manager Eric Dale being among them. As he is escorted from the building by security guards, he manages to pass a memory stick over to Peter Sullivan, his protege, telling him to read the contents. Peter opens the data on the stick that night, and is shocked by what he finds. He calls his colleague Seth Bregman, and Will Emerson, his immediate boss, to confirm what he has found. After viewing the data they contact Sam Rogers, Will's boss, who is in the middle of taking care of his dog, which is dying, and who in turn calls his superior, Jared Cohen. Cohen's instructions to Peter and Seth are to have them find Eric Dale, but he cannot be located. An immediate emergency board meeting is convened, those attending including the company's most senior female officer, Sarah Robertson, while the CEO, John Tuld, arrives by private helicopter. Peter explains what the information on the stick revealed, that the company is deeply involved with mortgage-based assets the value of which is plunging in the market, 'over leverage', thus the bank is overexposed and if the firm's assets decrease by 25%, as Dale predicts, the firm will owe more than its market capitalization and will quickly collapse. Tuld comes to a rapid conclusion, that the next day all the company's traders will sell off the toxic and soon to be virtually worthless assets for whatever they can get, not revealing the upcoming liability of what they are selling. Sam objects, claiming that it amounts to cheating on their own clients, many of whom have banked with them for years, and that they will be selling them stocks and assets which are little more than junk investments, but Tuld rejects his arguments. Eric is found, and Tuld offers him a large sum as a bonus if he comes back to the company to help with the sell-off plan, the company needing his experience and finesse in such matters. Dane initially refuses, but agrees after Tuld uses all his charm and persuasiveness to change his mind. Tuld calls Sarah into his office and explains that when the assets collapse, she is the one who will take the blame for the bad investments and financial decisions. The markets open in the morning and the company hastily makes huge trades in the asset market, managing to sell off most of the assets as the day wears on, believing the firm and their jobs have been saved. By the end of trading, with all the junk investments sold to unsuspecting others, Sam calls the traders together for a meeting to discuss the situation they now find themselves, and finally admitting the full scale of what they have been involved with.

Production

Director
J.C. Chandor
Producer
Neal Dodson, Corey Moosa, Zachery Quinto, Robert Ogden Barnum, Joe Jenckes and Michael Benaroya
Art Director
John Paino
Editor
Pete Beaudreau
Music
Nathan Larson
Screenplay
J.C. Chandor
Director of Photography
Frank G. DeMarco

Review

One can only think that debut writer and director J.C. Chandor can blame bad timing for how his drama Margin Call was received, the quite remarkable cast not being able to stop it receiving mixed reviews, and being a flop at the US box-office, taking under $4 million on release, although the low budget will mean, on an appropriately fiscal note, that the pic will break even globally, certainly more than half the characters in Chandor's script, essentially taking the events leading up to the events of a fictionalised version of Lehman Brothers' bank, arguably the event which ignited the 2008 global collapse, and trying to present it in dramatic form. The similarities are unsubtle, even to the point of Jeremy Irons' reptilian CEO being named John Tuld where the actual head of Lehmans' was Dick Fuld and, a parallel with Irons' fictitious portrayal, a man completely detested throughout the financial world and who revelled in his own, appalling, image and reputation. The script compresses the events into an imagined scenario at a a high-profile investment bank over a 24-hour period as the financial crisis looms, the bank and its' staff have to act to shed 'toxic' investments, selling them onto other institutions and investors who have dealt with the bank for years, often decades, and trust it, showing the sheer ruthlessness of the business where the bank is desperate to shed investments they know are essentially worthless, and if not sold on will send the company into collapse. That the sell-on will merely shift the burden, sending other companies and individuals to the wall is merely part of the business. Sparked by the data on a USB drive, compiled by the initially principled Eric Dale (Stanley Tucci - The Lovely Bones), the staff work through the night, and one can see the pecking system at work as the lower-ranked staffers report to their superiors, and ever upwards, the level of risk diminishing in personal terms the further up the corporate ladder one rises. Tuld wants to shed the debt so as not to have the bank go down under his stewardship rather than any worries about his career or nest-egg. It Is the young bankers and other investors who could lose everything. This layered strata also works in reverse, as only the very top executives know exactly what is going on, and even then perhaps only have an incomplete grasp on the complete picture, with the conscientious Dale being one of the few who has taken a global view, and been horrified at what he has found. Chandor has a terrific cast at his disposal, and although most are playing pretty self-centred and egocentric characters give fascinating performances, oddly the weakest link being Kevin Spacey as seemingly only one in the entire staff with any sort of conscience or guilt, and the fact that he is tending a dying dog is rather overemphasising both his morals and his borderline saintliness. Otherwise fine performances come from a line-up which includes Zachery Quinto (the Star Trek reboot), Paul Bettany (Creation), Simon Baker (TV's The Mentalist), Penn Badgley (TV's Gossip Girl) and, as the aptly named head of risk, Demi Moore (Disclosure) who has a telling scene in which he is baldly told that she is going to be the scapegoat for what is happening. Although set in the same world and with many of the same types, one only has to remember Oliver Stone's fatuous Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps, a virtual hymn of praise to traders, bankers, money marketers and other scum, to see how Chandor handles the story and shifts the emphasis, letting the events and those involved largely condemn themselves out of their own mouths, although to some the fact that it claims to be based on a true story doesn't make it any more palatable.