Cast
-
Elizabeth Olsen
-
Sarah Paulson
-
-
Christopher Abbott
-
Brady Corbet
-
John Hawkes
-
Maria Dizzia
-
Julia Garner
-
Louisa Krause
-
Allen McCullough
-
Adam Thompson
-
Lauren Molina
Synopsis
Martha, a young woman in her twenties, lives in a commune in the Catskills in the US, with a group of other young people who all seem to be in thrall to the community leader, a charismatic older man called Patrick. The community, living on an abandoned and rundown farm, have all pledged obedience to Patrick, who enforces nebulous but strict rules. The young children at the farm all being boys because Patrick has insisted that the only children should be boys. Martha is known as Marcy May in the commune, but also goes by the name of Marlene when she is forced into the outside world to go shopping or deal with some of the organisational side of the settlement. Finally taking a momentous decision, Martha escapes the farm early one morning, making her way to the nearest town, and despite the pleas and threats of one of Patrick's henchmen, refuses to return. She phones her sister, Lucy, who she has not talked to for two years, to come and pick her up. Lucy brings her back to her and her husband Ted's comfortable house on the banks of a Connecticut lake. Lucy realises that Martha, who has been missing for some time without any form of communication, has been through an ordeal, but she finds it impossible to explain what has happened to her, and insists that she has been staying with a boyfriend. Although safe, Martha starts to have horrifying flashbacks to her time with the community, bringing back memories, such as being attacked and raped by Patrick, and being involved with robberies and brutal murders, as well as being involved in the drugging of another young girl, another newcomer to what she now knows is a cult, so that she could become another of Patrick's rape victims. Lucy tries to communicate with her sister but finds it impossible, and blames herself for not staying in contact with Martha and making sure she was alright, but Ted finds himself increasingly exasperated and annoyed, his anger growing after Martha calls him a shallow materialist for having a luxurious house and all the trappings of success. Tensions rise, with Martha believing that Patrick and the cult members are watching her and monitoring her. Martha has a breakdown, unable to take the pain and guilt any longer. Lucy and ted arranger for marlene to be taken into a psychiatric unit, but Martha still has deep, gnawing fears that Patrick and his cult may be trying to get her back.
Production
- Director
- Sean Durkin
- Producer
- Josh Mond, Antonio Campos, Chris Maybach and Patrick Cunningham
- Art Director
- Jonathan Guggenheim
- Editor
- Zac Stuart-Pontier
- Music
- Saunder Jurrlaans and Danny Bensi
- Screenplay
- Sean Durkin
- Director of Photography
- Jody Lee Lipes
Review
Generally earning plaudits when shown at the 2011 Cannes Film Festival, Martha Marcy May Marlene, written and directed by Sean Durkin, is a very serious and to some upsetting drama, but some critics noted a certain resemblance to the works of German helmer Michael Haneke, most notably in its' lakeside setting, the location of both versions of Haneke's Funny Games, and the presence of Brady Corbett, who appeared in the US version of Haneke's film, Durkin almost showing the same sort of ruthlessness towards the plight of his central character. The Martha of the title is played by Elizabeth Olsen (The Silent House, and also formerly of the singing duo The Olsen Sisters, a young woman who leaves what initially is presented as a commune, living on a largely derelict farm, contacting the sister she has not spoken to for two years and eventually being taken to the lakeside house of sister Lucy (Sarah Paulson - TV's Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip), who is married to Ted (Hugh Dancy - Savage Grace), an extremely successful British businessman. Lucy realises something terrible has happened to her sister, who is unresponsive and insists that she was with a mysterious boyfriend all the time she was out of contact with her sibling, but the audience starts to realise the truth of her ordeal, having just escaped the clutches of an all-enveloping cult, flashbacks and memories revealing that she was repeatedly raped by the cult's charismatic but completely maniacal leader, Patrick (John Hawkes - Winter's Bone), later becoming culpable in the cult's other crimes, the script siting them as a mixture of the Symbionese Liberation Army who kidnapped heiress Patricia Hearst, and the rather more murderous Manson Family. She stays at the house, struggling to cope with both the loss of what passed for a warped form of stability and acceptance with the group, and an inability to make any sort of real connection to her painfully concerned sibling is what make Durkin's film so compelling in parts and so deeply uncomfortable, veering between drama to adding flashes of real horror when Martha's past with the cult, and their escalation into murder in uneasy parallels with Manson's 'creepy-crawly' outings, is expertly handled, and very well played by Olsen, now making a career in acting after the well-publicised break-up of the singing group, her pretty, open face obviously hiding the character's internal torments. Durkin is clever at withholding vital information, meaning that what the viewer sees on screen may only be the partial truth, and the cult scenes have a certain intensity which some may find upsetting, Hawkes making for a scarily convincing and plausible cult leader, kind and benevolent until the truth of his character is revealed, and perhaps Durkin's film has parallels with some of Haneke's work, which the American director would certainly take as a compliment, in that it also leaves the audience at as much of an impasse as most of its' characters, with some finding the ending perfectly fitting while others will just find it frustrating, and it certainly isn't some sort of comfortable, optimistic wrap-up. Durkin's film may leave trailing plot strands, but that is intentional and part of the whole scenario, of how catastrophic experiences can leave someone so damaged, and while Martha Marcy May Marlene certainly earns its' commendations, it is a sometime painful film to watch, as the lead character mentally crumbles while those around her want to help, but are just blocked at every turn. An impressive piece of work from the writer / director, but not easy viewing.