Film details

Perfect Sense  2011

Cast

  • Connie Nielsen
  • Ewan Bremmer
  • Stephen Dillane
  • Denis Lawson
  • Alastair Mackenzie
  • James Watson
  • Shabana Akhtar Bakhsh
  • Caroline Paterson
  • Richard Mack
  • Liz Strange

Synopsis

David Mackenzie (Young Adam / Hallam Foe) has two very different films coming out this year, one being the micro-budgeted festival-shot comedy You Instead, and this very different offering, a semi-sci-fi drama which drew responses at the 2011 Edinburgh Film Festival ranging from extremely intrigued to utterly baffled, with audiences either wanting to see it again to get the subtle nuances to those who would rather pull out their own eyes with a pickle fork than ever glance another frame. Reuniting with Young Adam's Ewan MacGregor, and co-starring the startling Eva Green (The Dreamers / Casino Royale), the setting is Glasgow, seemingly the present day or the very near future, and a there is an epidemic sweeping Scotland and, as it transpires, the entire world, which makes people's emotions run berserk, turning them into expressive, irrepressible extroverts, living for the moment and being completely and rawly honest about their inner feeling, but that is a precursor to them losing their sense of smell, followed by their eventual shutdown of all other sense. MacGregor plays Michael, the head chef at a top restaurant, and who becomes involved with Susan (Mme. Green), an epidemiologist who has picked up on the first reports of the spreading virus, and realises what it means for the future of the human race. With some critics calling this an lower-budgeted variation of Fernando Meirelles' almost equally divisive Blindness (2008), the film, scripted by Kim Fupz Aakeson, has an impressive array of supporting talent from all over the globe, including Connie Nielsen (Gladiator), Ewen Bremner (Trainspotting), Stephen Dillane (The Hours / 44 Inch Chest) and Denis Lawson, MacGregor's uncle, acting with his nephew in the same project for the first time. Perfect Sense is certainly provoking some very polarised reactions, but one has to admire Mackenzie, as with all his films, for not taking the easy option and making challenging, ambitious pieces of work.

Production

Director
David Mackenzie
Producer
Gillian Berne and Malte Grunert
Art Director
Andy Thomson
Editor
Jake Roberts
Music
Max Richter
Screenplay
Kim Fupz Aakeson
Director of Photography
Giles Nuttgens

Review

David Mackenzie (Young Adam / Hallam Foe) had two very different films coming out during 2011, one being the micro-budgeted festival-shot comedy You Instead, and Perfect Sense, a very different offering, a semi-sci-fi drama which drew responses at the various film festivals it played ranging from extremely intrigued to utterly baffled, with audiences either wanting to see it again to get the subtle nuances to those who would rather pull out their own eyes with a pickle fork than ever glance another frame, and while one can admire Mackenzie's bravery with taking one such a vague and abstract plot and script, it is also infuriating that a film which pairs Ewan MacGregor, reuniting with the helmer after Young Adam, and the startling Eva Green (The Dreamers / Casino Royale). The setting is Glasgow, in presumably the present day, where a worldwide contagion is starting to rob people of their senses, beginning with smell, and then moving onto taste, MacGregor playing a chef, Michael, whose restaurant is managing to stay open, despite their customers losing the ability to really enjoy their food, while Green, a fine and underrated actress, an epidemiologist who picked up on the first reports of the spreading virus, and realises what it means for the future of the human race. With some seeing this an lower-budgeted variation of Fernando Meirelles' almost equally divisive Blindness (2008), Perfect Sense, scripted by Kim Fupz Aakeson, has a fascinating premise, and some very effective scenes in showing just what the loss of senses, in many ways the arbiters of human experience, means to people, such as where they are seen eating anything which comes to hand, such as raw fish or flowers, since they cannot neither taste or smell them, and there are constant references to how society is beginning to collapse, but one of the senses the film itself loses is a sense of urgency, despite throwing in some small-scale scenes of fighting in the streets, and radio reports or heavy-handed responses to rioting by the authorities, but the crux of the film remains the story of a couple who seems to constantly bickering while being repeatedly told the world is collapsing around them Mackenzie collates an impressive array of supporting talent from all over the globe, pairing the excellent Ewen Bremner with McGregor once again after Trainspotting, as sous-chef James, including Connie Nielsen (Gladiator), Stephen Dillane (The Hours / 44 Inch Chest) and Denis Lawson, MacGregor's uncle, acting with his nephew in the same project for the first time. Perfect Sense is certainly provoking some very polarised reactions, and one suspects that some of these are caused by frustration more than anything else, the film more often preferring to describe the narrative rather then show it, but one has to admire Mackenzie, as with all his films, for not taking the easy option and instead making challenging, ambitious pieces of work, even if not all of them succeed.