Film details

Moneyball  2011

Cast

Synopsis

Originally to have been directed by Steven Soderbergh, the producers became more than a little worried when Soderbergh wanted to treat this particular subject in semi-documentary style, interweaving genuine interview footage with the parties concerned among the fictionalised dramatisation of their story, but now under the direction of Bennett Miller (Capone) any such approach has been dispensed with, but even so its' very hard to see this getting much of an audience outside the US, despite the top-lining presence of Brad Pitt, and a cast which includes Robin Wright (State Of Play), Philip Seymour Hoffman (Capote / M-I: III) and, regrettably, Jonah Hill (Get Him To The Greek), replacing the equal warmth vacuum, the originally cast Demetri Martin (Taking Woodstock) With a final screenplay by the impressive line-up of Steve Zaillian (Schindler's List / American Gangster / The Interpreter) and Aaron Sorkin (The Social Network / TV's The West Wing), based on the book Moneyball: The Art Of Winning An Unfair Game, by Michael Lewis. Based on a true series of events in the world of baseball, another reason why this will do zippity outside the US, Pitt plays Billy Beane, arriving at the baseball team the Oakland Athletics, known as the Oakland As, and, seeing the team is in deep financial difficulty, deciding to put together a team using a new approach to scouting potential players, an approach he called 'sabermetrics', using a complex statistical approach to actual in-game activity as an indicator as to a player's true value and workrate, believing this will produce a better team given the meagre resources available. Now this may all be quite fascinating for baseball nuts, but there are few enough of those outside the fifty states, and it isn't surprising that Soderbergh's approach was enough to have the producers pull the plug merely days before shooting was originally to begin back in June 2009, not wanting to commit such a budget to what is essentially marginal material, and which would not be made any more audience- friendly by making it a docu-drama. The cast is certainly impressive, the three leads anyway, but this really is one which is aimed at the obsessives, and is probably going to be quietly but firmly buried in the rest of the world.

Production

Director
Bennett Miller
Producer
Michael De Luca, Rachael Horovitz and Scott Rudin
Art Director
Brad Ricker and David Scott
Editor
Christopher Tellefsen
Screenplay
Steve Zaillian and Aaron Sorkin, screen story by Stan Chervin, based on the book Moneyball: The Art Of Winning An Unfair Game, by Michael Lewis
Director of Photography
Wally Pfister

Review

Originally to have been directed by Steven Soderbergh, the producers of Moneyball became more than a little worried when Soderbergh wanted to treat this particular subject in semi-documentary style, interweaving genuine interview footage with the parties concerned among the fictionalised dramatisation of their story, an approach which was rather at odds with how they saw the film. With Bennett Miller (Capote) replacing Soderbergh, any such approach has been dispensed with, making the film into a sports-driven star vehicle for a rather scruffy and ill-groomed Brad Pitt as sports coach Billy Beane, but even so its' very hard to see this getting much of an audience outside the US, despite Pitt and a cast which includes Robin Wright (State Of Play), Philip Seymour Hoffman (M-I: III / Synecdoche, New York) and, regrettably, Jonah Hill (Get Him To The Greek), replacing the equal warmth vacuum, the originally cast Demetri Martin (Taking Woodstock), as Peter Brand, a Yale economics graduate who espoused 'sabremetrics', a statistical theory which essentially had Coach Beane, heading up the inept and consistently failing Oakland Athletics, using a complex statistical approach to actual in-game activity as an indicator as to a player's true value and workrate, believing this will produce a better team given the meagre resources available, as opposed to the other teams spending millions on player's with either burgeoning reputations or bags of promise, as well as being marketed by slick and professional agents. With a final screenplay by the impressive line-up of Steve Zaillian (Schindler's List / American Gangster / The Interpreter) and Aaron Sorkin (The Social Network / TV's The West Wing), both multi-award winners, and based on the 2003 book Moneyball: The Art Of Winning An Unfair Game, by Michael Lewis, the script acknowledges that quite a few liberties have been taken with the actual story, Hill's Brand actually being based on a character called Paul DePodesta, the club's assistant manager, but the problem remains that it almost, until the final reels, doesn't actually feature any actual baseball, except being briefly seen on TV sets and very short close-ups of on-field games, but drama fans could be put off simply because at its' heart it is still a sports film, despite largely being about one determined man, and his annoying sidekick, trying to beat the statistical odds. Now this may all be quite fascinating for baseball history nuts, even in this bowlderised version, but there are few enough of those outside the fifty states, and it isn't surprising that Soderbergh's approach was enough to have the producers pull the plug merely days before shooting was originally to begin back in June 2009, not wanting to commit such a budget to what is essentially marginal material, and which would not be made any more audience- friendly by making it a docu-drama. Pitt is surprisingly convincing as the rough-edged Beane, a man with problems off as well as on the pitch, and there is also a pleasingly sour ending, which actually puts the events of the film into perspective, since the A's success was what you might call fleeting, but Moneyball still has the problems of not being one thing or the other, although the performances of Pitt, Wright and Hoffman, as scornful coach Art Howe, in particular are all very watchable.