Film details

Wuthering Heights  2011

Cast

  • Nichola Burley
  • Oliver Milburn
  • James Howson
  • Steve Evets
  • Amy Wren
  • Paul Hilton
  • Soloman Glave
  • Shannon Beer
  • Simone Jackson
  • Lee Shaw
  • James Northcote

Synopsis

The turn of the Nineteenth century, and in a rough and rugged hill farm in Yorkshire, a young half-caste orphan, Heathcliffe, is brought home to be adopted by Mr. Earnshaw, the farmer and landowner. The young Heathcliffe meets Cathy, Earnshaw's free-spirited young daughter, and begins an obsessive captivation with her, but Hindley, her brutish and volatile brother, detests Heathcliffe and his interest in his sister. When Mr. Earnshaw dies, Hindley inherits the farm, and immediately demotes Heathcliffe, who has been working on the farm, to purely servant's work. Cathy and Heathcliffe continue to see each other, and when they secretly spy on their very wealthy new ne ighbours, the Lintons, Cathy is injured when they try to get away without being seen. Cathy is taken into the Linton's house to recuperate, and she finds herself becoming close to Edgar Linton, one of their sons. Returning to the farm, she tells Hindley that Edgar has proposes to her, and Heathcliffe, overhearing this, flees the farm, knowing that although she lives him, to marry her would be too degrading a decision and would make her a social pariah. Years pass, and Heathcliffe, now a successful adult, returns to the farm, finding that Hindley is now a bitter, disillusioned drunk, He stays at the farm with his firmer employer, and tries to find his lost love, Cathy. Although now married to Edgar, she spends time with Heathcliffe, directly defying her husband's orders, and turns on him, blaming her for leaving the farm and, in her eyes, deserting her. Driven by revenge, Heathcliffe seduces Isabella, Edgar's sister, and takes her away from the Linton estate, purely to hurt Cathy, who is pregnant with Edgar's child. But Cathy falls gravely ill, as Heathcliffe becomes more violent and aggressive, threatening the Lintons, and Heathcliffe is about to discover just how destructive his love for Cathy really is.

Production

Director
Andrea Arnold
Producer
Kevin Loader, Robert Bernstein and Douglas Rae
Art Director
Christopher Wyatt
Editor
Nicolas Chaudcurge
Screenplay
Andrea Arnold and Olivia Hetreed, based on the novel by Emily Bronte
Director of Photography
Robbie Ryan

Review

Believed to be at least the seventeenth film or TV adaptation of the Emily Bronte classic, first published in 1847, initially under the male pseudonym Ellis Bell, and her only novel, this version of Wuthering Heights, directed by Andrea Arnold (Red Road), finally makes it to the screen after a tortuous time in pre-production and a number of crew and casting changes, the pic first being set for production in 2008 for a release in mid-2009, John Maybury directing and Nathalie Portman set to play the wind-bedraggled Cathy Earnshaw, the foster sister and the lover of the rugged and equally windswept Heathcliffe, but Portman was not attached for too long, Cathy and Heathcliffe then announced to be being played by the very promising pairing of the superb Abbie Cornish (Candy / Bright Star) and Inglourious Basterds' Michael Fassbender. This also did not last too long, Peter Webber (Girl With A Pearl Earring) replacing Maybury and Gemma Arterton (Quantum Of Solace) and Ed Westwick (TV's Gossip Girl) slipping into the C & H roles, but once more this didn't get off the ground and the whole project went quiet until mid-2010, when Arnold was attached and Kaya Scondclario (Moon / TV's Skins) announced as Cathy, she being more in line with the age of the character in the actual book, and a few eyebrows were raised with the casting of the debuting James Howson, a black actor, as Heathcliffe, but such a move shows the approach Arnold takes, for while most of those who have not read the book will probably have memories of the lushly romantic 1939 version starring the incredible screen pairing of Laurence Olivier and Vivien Leigh, the utterly perfect Sunday afternoon movie, or some of the rather diluted TV series version, the actual novel is a rather startling piece of work, more a story of obsession and madness rather than love, and one should also remember that, and this isn't particularly a spoiler, that Cathy dies, leaving a genuinely bereft and disturbed Heathcliffe to stalk the rugged heaths, convinced he can hear her ghost, and even before this trauma he is a violent and dangerous man, constantly threatening all around him and exuding a pent-up volatility. The screenplay by Arnold and Olivia Hetreed adds lots of new dialogue, much of it brought to you be the letters F and C, hence the 15 certificate, and has explained how the feeling in the book that Heathcliffe is an 'outsider' steered her casting choice, although some wags have mentioned that it adds whole new meanings to the phrase 'the Yorkshire Moors'. The screenplay also makes explicit in the later stages what as largely implied in the book, and very disturbing it is too, seeing how far Heathcliffe's desire to get Cathy back, even after she has died, has driven him. Heavy handed at times in its' symbolism, Arnold has put the shock value back into a story which various incarnations over the decades had largely sanitised, and made it subject to such indignities as Cliff Richard's panned stage version Heathcliffe, one of the most famously terrible musicals ever staged, and even when one listens to the words of Kate Bush's wonderful song one realises that it is no ordinary love ballad, being sung by a ghost to torment the man who still lives. With rugged photography by Robbie Ryan, earning him the Cinematography Award at the 2011 Venice Film Festival, showing just what an inhospitable landscape the tale is set against, the casting of James Howson tends to overshadow the performance by Kaya Scondclario, who makes Cathy convincingly wild and free-spirited, although heathcliffe's later actions still seem to be the work of a man who has clearly tripped into insanity rather then one stricken by passion, A rough and brutal version of the story, the additional strong language seems at times to be a rather needless addition to the text, and those who think of Wuthering Heights as a passionate and essentially mild love story are in for a very rude shock, since this take on Bronte's slightly grotesque tale is anything but.