Film details

Arthur  2011

Cast

Synopsis

Possibly the most redundant remake in a slew which have more than their fair share of pointless projects, this remake of the 1981 comedy which consolidated the unexpected Hollywood stardom of Dudley Moore after he stepped into the lead role of 10 at short notice, casts Russell Brand in the role of the drunken, irresponsible millionaire of the title, but interestingly the publicity push behind this went extremely quiet after the severe under-performance, and bad reviews, of Brand's previous Hollywood vehicle, Get Him To The Greek. Opening rather more low-key than may have been originally intended, British writer Peter Baynham reworks the original screenplay by director Steve Gordon, who also helmed the huge hit, and sticks to the original story, Brand playing Arthur Bach, a dissolute and usually drunk multi-millionaire living in New York, who is forced by his mother, Vivienne (British actress Geraldine James - TV's The Jewel In The Crown) into an arranged marriage with society girl Susan Johnson (Jennifer Garner - Electra), or lose his upcoming $750 million inheritance. Unfortunately the Bach family plans unravel when instead he finds true love for the first time, in the form of working class girl Linda Marolla, played by Lisa Minelli in the original and by mumblecore favourite Greta Gerwig (Hannah Takes The Stairs / Greenberg) here, which naturally leads to all sorts of bust-ups as Arthur finds the course of true love indeed never runs smoothly. Although director Jason Winer (TV's Modern Family) has some interesting talent, including veteran Nick Nolte, Luiz Guzman (Boogie Nights) and Leslie Hendrix (TV's Law And Order: Criminal Intent), the oddest touch seems to be the recasting of Arthur's butler, played with imperious scorn by the wonderful Sir John Gielgud in the original and inexplicably having Helen Mirren in the role here, which really may be an eccentric and distracting touch too far. The first film may still have its' fans, although the sequel, Arthur 2: On The Rocks, was a critical and box-office disaster, and many suspect the American enthusiasm for Brand may be waning, and quickly too to judge from the absolutely dreadful reviews the man got for the Julie Taymor adaptation of The Tempest, also opposite Helen Mirren. There's actually a rather sad end to the original Arthur story. Having made one of the unexpected mega-hits of the decade, Gordon never followed up his success of his feature debut, dying of a sudden heart attack in November 1982, only sixteen months after Arthur opened, aged only 43.

Production

Director
Jason Winer
Producer
Chris Bender, Russell Brand, Larry Brenzner, Kevin McCormack, J.C. Spink and Michael Tadross
Art Director
Doug Huszti
Editor
Brent White
Music
Theodore Shapiro
Screenplay
Peter Baynham, based on the story, characters and film created and directed by Steve Gordon
Director of Photography
Uta Briesewitz

Review

Possibly the most redundant remake in a slew which have more than their fair share of pointless projects, this remake of the 1981 comedy which consolidated the unexpected Hollywood stardom of Dudley Moore casts Russell Brand in the role of the drunken, irresponsible millionaire of the title, but in the three decades which have passed between the two films attitudes have changed, and sadly the reworked screenplay by British writer Peter Baynham (Borat) has accommodated them also, meaning that the dissolute character of Arthur Bach, which Moore made a surprisingly affable reprobate, here he is far less libidinous, doesn't hire hookers, is rather less free with the drunken insults, and even joins Alcoholics Anonymous in a staggering sop to PC attitudes. Where the film seems to be brave in its' deviation from the original, in the recasting of Arthur's butler, played with imperious scorn by the wonderful Sir John Gielgud in the original and inexplicably having Helen Mirren in the role here, it seems to be an eccentric and distracting touch too far, especially when lines in the script describing Mirren's Hobson breast-feeding Arthur as a child make one wonder if the family should give up the search for a bride and just pair the two of them off instead. Another shift, all geared to ensure a more family-friendly film is the change to the woman Arthur loves, Lisa Minelli's shoplifting loudmouth Linda in the original and here replaced by mumblecore favourite Greta Gerwig (Hannah Takes The Stairs / Greenberg), minus the sticky fingers and, it has to be said, Minnelli's snap and timing. Whereas Linda was a match for Arthur on a lot of levels, Gerwig's Naomi exists purely as a way to have Arthur empathise with a working class family. Although having some very odd casting choices, such as British actress Geraldine James (TV's The Jewel In The Crown) as Arthur's domineering mother, the problem remains with Brand, his nasal voice being as attractive as a trapped dentist's drill bit to some ears, and for all his hyper-mugging and the tailoring of the character to make him more acceptable in a post-Millenium world, he vitally lacks what Moore had in abundance, which was plain and simple charm. Moore's Arthur wriggled out of most situations because he was a rather louche and amusing lush, Brand is just a gaunt, shrieking gurn machine, and after the audience has met the vacuous Naomi one has to think the pair are ideal for each other. The first film still has its' fans, although the sequel, Arthur 2: On The Rocks, was a critical and box-office disaster. There's actually a rather sad end to the original Arthur story. Having made one of the unexpected mega-hits of the decade, Gordon never followed up his success of his feature debut, dying of a sudden heart attack in November 1982, only sixteen months after Arthur opened, aged only 43.