Cast
-
Li Bingbing
-
Gianna Jun
-
Vivian Wu
-
Jiang Wu
-
Archie Kao
-
-
Coco Chiang
-
Hu Qing Yun
-
Russell Wong
-
Shi Ping Cap
-
Ruilia Zhang
-
Zhebing Gong
Synopsis
Notable for a number of reasons, not all of them terrifically encouraging, Show Flower And The Secret Fan is the return to the screen after several years away for director Wayne Wang (Chan Is Missing / The Joy Luck Club), once a darling of the arthouse but reduced to the indignity of directing a Queen Latifha comedy, Last Holiday, in 2006, and having a very varied cast featuring Chinese, Korean and American actors, and little more than a cameo from Hugh Jackman. Despite attracting some far less than complimentary reviews, Fox are giving this a surprisingly robust release worldwide, obviously believing there is an international market for this adaptation of a 2005 novel by Lisa See, and which of course has nothing to do with the fact that it is produced by Wendi Murdoch, much, much, much, younger wife of Rupert, who recently had her own moment of glory in the Parliamentary hearings over the phone hacking affair, and word is that Murdoch Senior personally gave the order that this was to be given a well-supported release in all territories, despite what the critics said, specialist trade website FilmBizAsia insisting Wang's career 'hits close to rock bottom' with the film. What seems to have irritated many is the fact that while the book, a surprise bestseller in the West, was set entirely in 19th Century Hunan Province, focusing on the secret friendship of two women, Snow Flower, mainlander Li Bingbing (The Forbidden Kingdom) and Lily, played by the Korean Gianna Jun (Blood - The Last Vampire), who meet as children and get around the social strictures of the day by communication in their own secret code, the screenplay insists on adding a completely new parallel plot, focusing on another pair of women in contemporary Shanghai, Nina and Sophia, again played by Li and Jun, one of them being the great-great-granddaughter of one of the original characters, and which seems to miss the point entirely of the book, that the two women of Hunan, are forced to keep their friendship secret because of the strict social conventions of the time, but in today's Shanghai there is no such restriction, which makes any comparison between the two stories redundant. Although there are hints at a lesbian relationship in both stories, especially taboo in the period scenes, this is also apparently badly handled by Wang, and Jackman seems extraordinarily out of place, especially when delivering a love ballad in a nightclub, and seems to have turned up as a favour for Rupert Murdoch for bankrolling Baz Lurmann's folly Australia. One of the few aspects to have attracted praise is the photography by Richard Wong which perfectly captures the ornate and intricately detailed Hunan scenes and the crisper, cleaner scenes in Shanghai, while both lead actresses are given difficult dialogue, Li Bingbing struggling with the few English language scenes and Gianna Jun having trouble in two languages she doesn't speak, Mandarin and English, and although nice to look at, the words 'vanity project' have been mentioned in most reviews, and that's a judgement it seems hard to argue against.
Production
- Director
- Wayne Wang
- Producer
- Wendi Deng Murdoch and Florence Sloan
- Art Director
- Molly Page
- Editor
- Deirdre Slevin
- Music
- Rachel Portman
- Screenplay
- Angela Workman, Ron Vass and Michael K. Ray, based on the novel by Lisa See
- Director of Photography
- Richard Wong